Ecology and Evolution · Skim version
Ecology and Evolution
Each lesson in order: its guiding idea, then the take-homes from its films. All 26 have film take-homes.
Only this unit will print. Press Ctrl+P or ⌘P to print it. Show the whole course again
Evidence and evolutionary reasoning
1. How to Test an Evolutionary Explanation
Guiding idea. A nonrandom difference in survival shows selection, not yet evolution.
First film Three Claims in One Drought
- The 1977 drought on Daphne Major sorted the finches: survivors had larger beaks than the population before it.
- That gap measures selection through survival; if the survivors breed about equally, it is the selection differential S. It is not yet shown to be evolution.
- For one trait, the breeder's equation R = h² × S predicts how far the chicks' average moves: only part of the way, a fraction h² of S.
- If heritability were zero and the environment stayed the same, the chicks' average would not move, however strong the selection.
- Selection happened, the trait is inherited, the offspring changed: each claim needs its own evidence.
Second film Changing the Cause on Purpose
- Comparing natural sites shows an association, because the sites differ in more than one way.
- Moving guppies from one source into a reach with a different predator changed the setting on purpose.
- About 11 years later, the moved guppies matured later and larger, the predicted direction.
- An experiment can test a cause, but this one is still one stream and one introduction, and the new reach differed in more than its predator.
- When a past event cannot be rerun, historical inference tests rival explanations against the traces it left.
2. Reading Phylogenetic Trees
Guiding idea. On a phylogenetic tree, relatedness lives at the nodes and change lives on the branches: a trout is closer kin to you than to a shark because the ancestor it shares with you descends from, and so is more recent than, the one it shares with a shark.
First film Relatedness Lives at the Nodes
- Each internal node on a tree is an inferred common ancestor of every lineage descending from it.
- Two tips are more closely related the more recent the common ancestor they share.
- A trout shares a more recent ancestor with you than with a shark, so it is closer kin to you.
- Spinning the branches at a node changes the drawing, not the relationships.
- No living tip is more evolved than another: every lineage has had the same time since the root.
Second film Change Lives on the Branches
- Characters change state along branches, and the outgroup's state is taken as the starting point.
- Jaws need only one gain, on the branch from the root to node J, so on this mapping jaws in sharks and humans are homologous.
- Two taxa share a state by homology when both inherit it from one gain on a shared branch; other lineages may later lose it. Separate gains are convergence.
- Parsimony prefers the mapping with the fewest changes, and two mappings can tie.
- A tie means parsimony alone cannot tell homology from convergence, so more evidence is needed.
3. Natural Selection in Ecological Context
Guiding idea. Natural selection is a difference in reproductive success among variants that already exist, caused by an agent in an environment; inheritance carries the sorting forward, so it becomes evolution only when that variation is inherited.
First film Selection Has an Agent
- Natural selection is a difference in reproductive success among variants that already exist, caused by an agent in an environment, such as a predator.
- Which variant is favoured depends on the environment: on sooty bark birds took more pale moths, on lichen more dark ones.
- Fitness is relative: what matters is how one morph does compared with another in the same place.
- Selection sorts within one generation; inheritance carries the sorting forward, so it becomes evolution only if the sorted variation is inherited.
Second film Two Enemies, One Gall
- For a trait with a range of values, plotting relative fitness against the trait shows the mode of selection.
- Favouring one end is directional, favouring the middle is stabilizing, and favouring both ends is disruptive.
- In goldenrod galls, wasps took more larvae in small galls and birds more in large ones, so intermediate galls survived best.
- Because wasp attack outweighed bird attack in those fields, selection also favoured larger galls: one trait carried two components.
4. Drift, Gene Flow and Competing Explanations
Guiding idea. Across replicate populations, drift spreads allele frequencies apart without pushing their average; gene flow and consistent selection push the average.
First film Mean and Spread
- Genetic drift is change in allele frequency from the chance sampling of parents; it needs no difference in fitness.
- Across replicate populations, drift spreads allele frequencies apart without pushing their average.
- Gene flow pulls replicates that start alike and receive the same immigrants toward the immigrants' frequency by the same amount.
- Consistent selection, favouring the same allele everywhere, pushes the average toward it, while drift still scatters each population.
- How fast the replicates spread depends on the effective population size, Ne, not simply the number of animals you count.
Second film 107 Bottles
- Buri started 107 fruit-fly lines at an allele frequency of 0.5 and kept 16 parents in each, generation after generation.
- Over 19 generations the lines spread toward 0 and 1, and many ended with only one allele.
- The frequency pooled over all the lines showed no systematic change: spread without a push on the average, the pattern drift predicts.
- From how fast the lines spread, Buri estimated an effective size of about 9, below the 16 flies in each bottle.
- One line on its own wanders and tells you little about cause; replicates show whether the average was pushed.
Only this unit will print. Press Ctrl+P or ⌘P to print it. Show the whole course again
Genomes, development and diversification
5. Molecular Evolution
Guiding idea. Neutral changes are fixed, on average, at the rate they arise, so the count of differences between two species grows steadily with time and can be dated from one calibrated split; a departure from that count is a clue to selection, not proof.
First film Why Genes Keep Time
- A substitution is a mutation that has spread to every member of a lineage.
- Differences between two species build up on both branches since their common ancestor.
- On average, neutral mutations become substitutions at the rate they arise, whatever the population size: a bigger population makes more, but each is less likely to spread.
- Sequences alone cannot tell a fast rate over a short time from a slow rate over a long one; an outside date, usually a fossil, is needed, and it can date another split only if the two share a rate.
- The oldest fossil of a group gives a minimum age: the real split was earlier.
Second film Reading Selection in Genes
- A synonymous change keeps the amino acid; a nonsynonymous, or replacement, change alters it.
- If synonymous changes are neutral, omega = dN/dS reads selection on the protein: below 1 suggests purifying selection, near 1 is consistent with neutrality, above 1 suggests positive selection.
- The McDonald-Kreitman test compares the ratio of replacement to synonymous changes among variants within a species with the same ratio among differences fixed between species.
- At Adh in fruit flies, fixed differences held more replacements than the variants predicted, which McDonald and Kreitman suggested reflected adaptive fixation.
- Each test is a model inference: a departure from the neutral count is a clue to selection, not proof, and needs further checks before it counts as adaptation.
6. Evolution of Development
Guiding idea. A gene's protein and its pattern of use can evolve separately: in the best-studied case, freshwater threespine sticklebacks lost much of the pelvis when Pitx1 stopped being expressed there, linked to deletions in a pelvic enhancer, while the Pitx1 protein and its expression in the jaw stayed intact.
First film Same Protein, Different Switch
- In the pelvic-reduced Paxton Lake sticklebacks examined, the Pitx1 protein is unchanged.
- An enhancer is a stretch of noncoding DNA that switches a gene on in particular tissues, and one gene can have several.
- Paxton larvae still have Pitx1 RNA in the mouth and lower jaw, but none where the pelvis forms.
- Losing the protein outright would remove Pitx1 wherever it works; losing pelvic enhancer activity can shrink one body part and spare the gene's other jobs.
Second film Putting the Switch on Trial
- In a reporter test, marine PelA drove expression in the developing pelvis, and the Paxton version with a deletion drove none in 8 fish.
- A reporter shows what a sequence can drive in a construct, not that the body depends on it.
- Marine PelA driving Pitx1, added to eggs from another pelvic-reduced lake, variably enhanced pelvic spines.
- Deletions with different endpoints remove PelA in many pelvic-reduced populations, so the same switch was lost more than once.
- Not every pelvic-reduced population carries a PelA deletion.
7. Speciation: How Barriers to Gene Flow Evolve
Guiding idea. A new species forms when barriers that reduce gene flow evolve between populations that once interbred, and several partial barriers, whose leaks multiply, can together block nearly all of it.
First film Leaks That Multiply
- A reproductive barrier is anything that reduces gene flow between populations.
- When barriers act one after another and independently, each one blocks only the gene flow left by earlier barriers.
- The fractions that get through multiply, so several partial barriers can block nearly all gene flow.
- Barriers before the zygote are prezygotic; barriers after it, such as hybrids that fail to survive or are sterile, are postzygotic.
- In the monkeyflowers, most of the isolation comes before any hybrid forms.
Second film Isolation Follows Ecology
- Divergent selection favours different traits in different habitats.
- Selection acts on individuals and builds no barrier on purpose; isolation that arises as a side effect of adaptation is called ecological speciation.
- In stickleback mating trials, fish of the same form from different lakes showed no strong isolation, while fish of different forms were strongly isolated.
- When isolation repeats with the environment, lake after lake, drift alone is unlikely and divergent selection is the likely cause.
- In the monkeyflowers, adaptation to elevation and to pollinators is itself the barrier.
8. History of Life: Transitions, Extinctions and Radiations
Guiding idea. The number of kinds of living things changes by births minus deaths of lineages: speciation adds them and extinction removes them.
First film Births Minus Deaths
- The number of lineages changes by births minus deaths, speciation minus extinction (r = λ − μ); a slowly changing count alone cannot show whether the two rates are high or low.
- For most of its history life was microbial; many-celled eukaryotes, animals and land plants came later. Each fossil date means by this time, at the latest, while the oxygen date is bracketed from both sides.
- By a widely used benchmark, a mass extinction loses more than three-quarters of species in a geologically short interval; the Big Five are the standard list, though how sharply each stands out is debated.
- Iridium at distant sites, a crater of the right age and dating that ties impact to extinction point to an impact as the trigger of the end-Cretaceous extinction.
- In still broth one genotype of Pseudomonas fluorescens diversified into new heritable types; in shaken broth it did not.
Second film Floors and Brackets
- Fossils are rarely dated directly; often minerals in nearby rocks are, such as zircon carried into volcanic ash.
- Each atom decays at random, so in each half-life about half the remaining parent atoms decay; in a closed mineral that started with no daughter, the parent left tells how many half-lives have passed.
- Dated layers below and above a fossil bed, in undisturbed rock, give a bracket, not a single date.
- The oldest fossil of a group is a minimum age: the group existed by then and may be older.
- The clock must fit the age: carbon-14 has a half-life of about 5,730 years, and after about 50,000 years too little remains to measure, so dinosaur bones are not carbon-dated.
9. Human Evolutionary History: An African Origin and Archaic Ancestry
Guiding idea. To read the human past, ask what each piece of evidence dates: fossil layers place Homo sapiens in Africa among connected populations, not at one birthplace on one date, and the length of archaic DNA segments dates when some descendants interbred with Neanderthals and Denisovans.
First film What Was Dated?
- Homo sapiens arose in Africa from connected populations that split and sometimes merged, not at one birthplace on one date.
- A fossil's date usually belongs to something beside or above it, so ask what was dated and where it lay.
- An ash layer above a fossil gives a minimum age: Omo I is at least about 233,000 years old.
- People with partly modern anatomy lived in north Africa around 300,000 years ago.
- A fossil outside Africa, like Misliya's, shows presence there, not that living people descend from that group.
Second film A Clock Made of Cuts
- Sampled Eurasian genomes share more Neanderthal variants than sampled sub-Saharan African genomes do: a clue to mixing, not proof.
- The surplus gives no date, and old population structure could produce some of it.
- Recombination breaks inherited Neanderthal DNA into shorter pieces, so long pieces mean recent mixing: segment length is the clock.
- Ust'-Ishim, who lived about 45,000 years ago, carried longer Neanderthal segments than people today: the mixing came 7,000-13,000 years before he lived.
- At Bacho Kiro, three early Homo sapiens each had a separate, recent Neanderthal ancestor only a few generations back.
10. Life Histories and Evolutionary Trade-offs
Guiding idea. What an individual takes in sets its budget, how it splits that budget among growth, upkeep, storage and reproduction is where trade-offs live, and selection favours the split that leaves the most descendants, given who dies at what age.
First film One Budget, Many Uses
- Treat what an individual takes in and can use as one budget, split among growth, upkeep, storage and reproduction.
- For one individual with a given budget, more to reproduction leaves less for itself: that negative link is a trade-off.
- Two classic trade-offs: this year's young against the parent's own future, and many small offspring against a few large ones.
- Selection acts on the split, favouring whichever split leaves the most descendants, given who dies at what age.
- Low adult survival lowers the extra young one big bout needs to pay, so putting more into this year's bout can pay; how far still depends on how extra effort changes breeding and survival. Where adults survive well, or young survive poorly, holding back to breed again can pay.
Second film Why the Trade-off Hides
- Birds that take in more can afford more of everything, so larger clutches can go with better survival even when each bird faces a trade-off.
- Van Noordwijk and de Jong's comparison: people with large incomes have bigger houses and newer cars, yet for any one income the two still trade off.
- A natural correlation alone cannot show a trade-off or rule one out.
- Adding chicks to nests chosen at random balances richer and poorer parents between the groups on average, so a later survival difference can be laid on the extra chicks, allowing for chance.
- Across 30 bird species, enlarged broods lowered parents' survival a little on average (the cost per extra chick was uncertain), while naturally larger clutches went with better survival.
Only this unit will print. Press Ctrl+P or ⌘P to print it. Show the whole course again
Environments and populations
11. Climate, Biomes and Environmental Variation
Guiding idea. Rain falls where moist air rises and cools and is scarce where air sinks and warms, and the warmer a month, the more rain it needs to count as humid; read month by month, warmth and water give a first guess at a place's biome.
First film Where the Rain Falls
- Sunlight striking at a slant spreads over more ground, so over a year the tropics get the most energy per square metre and the poles the least.
- Where moist air rises it cools and drops rain; where air sinks it warms and dries, which is why many deserts lie near 30 degrees north and south.
- The rain belt shifts north and south through the year, roughly following the overhead Sun with a lag, giving many tropical places a wet season and a dry one.
- On a Walter-Lieth climate diagram, a month is read as dry when its rain in millimetres is below twice its temperature in degrees C.
- Monthly warmth and water give a first guess at a place's biome, not a final answer.
Second film Same Warmth, Two Answers
- Two places with similar average warmth can get different first guesses at the biome because of how much rain falls and when.
- Station A has no dry month and a tropical rainforest climate (Af); station B has five dry months on its climate diagram and a tropical savanna climate (Aw).
- In Staver and colleagues' analysis, at about 1,000 to 2,500 mm of rain a year with a dry season shorter than seven months (by their own measure), tropical tree cover was mostly either savanna-like or forest-like, rarely in between.
- Fire was associated with keeping savanna open; the proposed feedback is that fire can keep open areas open and a closed canopy can hold fire back, so the two may be alternative states under similar climates.
- A savanna climate does not guarantee a savanna: climate gives a first guess, and fire, soils, rain timing and microclimate can change the answer.
12. Distributions, Niches and Tolerances
Guiding idea. A species' niche is the set of conditions in which its population replaces itself over the long run without immigrants; its map records where it is found, sinks kept going by immigrants included, and cannot by itself tell the two apart.
First film Where It Can Live, Where It Is
- A niche is the set of conditions in which the long-run lambda, across good and bad years with no immigrants, is at least 1.
- Niche space is a space of conditions; the map shows the places where the species is found.
- A species can be missing from a place inside its niche because it has never reached it.
- A sink population lives outside the niche and is kept going by immigrants, so presence alone does not mark the niche.
Second film Planting Past the Edge
- A range edge can be set by conditions, by other species, or by access: the species not arriving or not recolonising.
- Planting beyond the edge, with the same planting inside the range, tests which; if the inside plantings fail too, handling, the seed or a bad year may be to blame, and the test cannot single out the edge.
- Clearing neighbours on random plots separates the neighbours' net effect from a limit set by conditions.
- Lambda over the whole life cycle, not one measure such as first-year survival, decides whether a population can persist.
- The dune plant grew beyond its northern edge, so at that site the edge was not where the plant fails; its neighbours were not tested.
13. Demography and Survivorship
Guiding idea. Whether a population can replace itself depends on survival and births at each age: R0, the sum of l_x m_x, is the number of daughters an average newborn female leaves.
First film Survive, Then Give Birth
- A cohort is a group of females born together; l_x is the fraction still alive at age x, and m_x is the average number of daughters per live female at that age.
- R0, the sum of l_x times m_x over all ages, is the number of daughters an average newborn female leaves.
- If R0 is above 1 the cohort more than replaces itself; below 1 it does not. R0 is counted per generation, not per year.
- Survival to any age is the product of every earlier year's survival, so with later rates unchanged, a loss early in life lowers every later term of R0.
- R0 predicts long-run growth only if the rates stay fixed and nobody arrives or leaves.
Second film A Straight Line on a Log Axis
- A survivorship curve plots l_x against age, usually on a logarithmic axis, where equal drops mean equal fractions lost.
- Type II means a constant probability of death each interval: the same fraction dies, so the number dying shrinks and the log curve is a straight line.
- Type I curves stay high and then plunge, with deaths late in life; Type III curves drop steeply early, then flatten.
- In laboratory Hydra, ten of twelve cohorts kept a yearly chance of natural death near 0.006, with no systematic fall in fertility (budding) with age.
- That is a laboratory counterexample to a universal rise in mortality with age, not evidence that Hydra are immortal.
14. Population Growth and Regulation
Guiding idea. In a closed population, growth is the per-capita rate times the population's size, and a population is regulated only when its net per-capita rate falls as density rises, from positive below a level to negative above it (negative density dependence, which in real populations may act after a lag).
First film Watch the Per-Capita Rate
- In a closed population, growth is the per-capita rate, births minus deaths per individual, times the population size N.
- With a constant positive per-capita rate, each day's gain is larger than the last, so growth compounds.
- The logistic model assumes the per-capita rate falls in a straight line as N rises, reaching zero at the carrying capacity K.
- Total growth is largest halfway to K, where the S-shaped curve is steepest.
Second film Catching the Brake
- Adding food and fencing out mammal predators raised snowshoe hare numbers, which shows both were limiting, but counts alone do not show density dependence.
- On Bahamian patch reefs, the fraction of young blue chromis that died rose with starting density when both resident and transient predators were present, measured across reefs within one generation.
- With only one predator group, no rise was detected, and one of those tests had low statistical power: not detected is not the same as absent.
- A brake makes net per-capita growth fall as density rises, so it is judged by per-capita measures, such as the fraction that die, not by the total number killed.
15. Movement and Spatial Populations
Guiding idea. A region can keep a species even though no patch keeps its population, as long as the colonization rate c is greater than the extinction rate e: in the Levins model occupancy then settles at p* = 1 − e/c, where patches refounded balance patches lost.
First film A Region Outlasts Its Ponds
- In the Levins model each patch is simply occupied or empty, and p is the fraction occupied.
- Occupancy rises by colonization, c p (1 − p), which needs both occupied and empty patches, and falls by local extinction, e p.
- Occupancy settles where gains balance losses, at p* = 1 − e/c, so a region keeps a species only while colonization beats extinction: c greater than e.
- Which patches are occupied keeps changing even when the fraction occupied does not.
- The model assumes many identical, equally reachable patches with constant rates; a small network can still lose every patch by chance.
Second film Two Kinds of Zero
- A survey zero can mean the species is absent, or that it was there and missed.
- A history such as 010 shows a site that was occupied and missed on two of three visits.
- If each visit independently detects an occupied site with probability 0.5, three visits all miss it one time in eight.
- Visiting each site several times, while occupancy stays fixed, lets a model estimate detection and occupancy separately.
- In Maryland in 2000, American toads were detected at 10 of 29 wetlands analysed, about 0.34, but estimated to occupy 0.49.
Only this unit will print. Press Ctrl+P or ⌘P to print it. Show the whole course again
Interactions and communities
16. Competition
Guiding idea. In the Lotka-Volterra competition model, two competitors coexist stably when each can grow when it is rare and the other is at its carrying capacity: each limits itself more than it limits the other.
First film Can It Grow When Rare?
- Competition lowers each species' per-capita growth, and alpha converts the other species into units of one's own kind.
- The invasion test asks whether a species can grow when it is rare and its competitor is at carrying capacity.
- In the model, with both species present: if both pass, they coexist stably; if only one passes, it excludes the other from that place; if neither passes, the start decides.
- The growth rate r is not in the rule, so it changes how fast and by what route the populations move, not which verdict the model gives: the faster grower need not win.
- In this model, both coexist stably when each can grow when rare: each limits itself more than it limits the other.
Second film What Keeps Chthamalus High?
- At Millport, Chthamalus lives above Balanus, and longer immersion, predators or crowding by Balanus could each explain that boundary.
- Connell removed Balanus from a randomly chosen half of each mapped patch and left the other half untouched as the comparison, so better survival on the cleared half is strong evidence that Balanus limited Chthamalus.
- Chthamalus kept free of Balanus survived well at the levels he studied, and Balanus killed it by smothering, undercutting and crushing it.
- So at Millport, competition from Balanus set the lower limit of Chthamalus, whose fundamental niche reaches lower than its realized niche.
- It is one shore and one pair of species; its strength is the design, not the generality. Randomized, controlled removal: better survival is evidence the neighbour was limiting.
17. Predation and Community Effects
Guiding idea. Every kill is entered in two ledgers, a death for the prey and food that, on average, predators turn into births, so each population's per capita growth rate is set by the other's numbers, and a predator can affect species it rarely or never eats, and can even help some species it also eats.
First film Two Ledgers, One Kill
- Each kill is a death for the prey and food that, on average, predators turn into births, so each population's per capita growth rate is set by the other's numbers.
- Prey increase while predators are fewer than P* = r/a; predators increase while prey are more than N* = m/(ea).
- Predators keep rising after prey have peaked, so predator peaks come after prey peaks, though the model builds in no delay.
- In the classical Lotka-Volterra model each start with both populations present and away from the equilibrium keeps its own closed loop, so the start sets the size of the cycle.
Second film Fifteen to Eight
- Paine kept the sea star Pisaster ochraceus off one patch of shore at Mukkaw Bay, Washington, beside an untouched control.
- Without Pisaster, mussels, the strongest competitors for space on the rock, spread, and the species holding space on the rock fell from 15 to 8.
- Pisaster's effects ran through the mussels it ate to the species they compete with: it kept space open, including for some species it also ate.
- A keystone species has an effect on its community that is large relative to its abundance.
- This was one removal patch and one control: a strong local result, not yet a general law.
18. Mutualism, Parasitism and Coevolution
Guiding idea. An interaction's sign is set by each partner's net of benefit minus cost, so it can shift when conditions or the partner's own evolution push a net across zero.
First film The Net Decides the Sign
- An interaction is scored by its net effect on each partner: benefit minus cost, compared with life without the partner.
- The sign follows the net, so the same root fungus can help a plant in poor soil and cost it in rich soil.
- A net of zero can hide a large benefit and a large cost that cancel.
- A partner that takes the reward and skips the service can be held back if the host cuts its reproduction enough, a host sanction.
- Coevolution means each partner evolves in response to the other; a good fit alone does not show it.
Second film Reading Evolution Across Time
- A time-shift assay pairs parasites with hosts from the past, the same time and the future; if neither partner's heritable traits changed, every pairing should give about the same infection rate.
- In an arms race, a parasite infects past hosts best and future hosts worst, and the difference grows with the time gap: a one-way trend points to escalation.
- In fluctuating selection, parasites do best on hosts of about their own time, and infection rises and falls as the gap grows: a wave points to tracking. Both shapes are evidence, not proof: coevolution also needs heritable change in both partners.
- In rotifer-alga chemostats, algae able to evolve gave long cycles with predator and prey peaks largely out of step, and defended algae were poorer competitors for nutrients.
- Those runs showed prey evolution changing population cycles, not coevolution: predator evolution was not tested.
19. Diversity, Disturbance and Succession
Guiding idea. A diversity index can be read as an effective number of species, how many equally common species would give the same value; above order zero it falls as a few species dominate, and it changes only when who is present, or how evenly they are shared, changes.
First film How Many Species Is It Worth?
- Richness counts species; diversity also asks how evenly the individuals are shared among them.
- An effective number of species is how many equally common species would give the same diversity value.
- At order zero it is the richness; above order zero it equals the richness only when every species is equally common, and it falls as a few species take over.
- These count-based indices use only counts, never names, so none of them sees which species are present: name the measure, its order and what it misses.
- A disturbance that kills the same share of every species leaves the shares, and so the effective number, unchanged; diversity changes only if who is present or how evenly they are shared changes.
Second film Holding a Boulder Still
- On Sousa's southern California shore, winter waves overturned small boulders often and large ones rarely, and intermediate boulders carried the most diverse communities.
- Each overturning kills some or all of the algae on the upper face and sets succession on that surface back; how often it strikes helps decide how far a patch gets.
- Boulder size and how often a boulder is overturned travelled together, so the pattern alone could not say which mattered.
- Small boulders fixed so waves could not turn them were taken over by later red algae and became as species-rich and diverse as larger, intermediate-sized boulders, while loose ones stayed early.
- The test varied how often disturbance struck, not how hard, and it holds for one shore.
20. Island Biogeography
Guiding idea. An island's species count changes at the rate new species arrive minus the rate resident species are lost, so it settles near where the two rates are equal while the species themselves keep being replaced.
First film Two Rates, One Crossing
- An island's species count changes at the rate new species arrive minus the rate resident species are lost.
- Arrivals of new species slow as the island fills and losses speed up, so the count settles near where the two rates are equal.
- A farther island receives fewer new species and a smaller island loses species faster; both lower the equilibrium number, S*.
- At equilibrium species keep arriving and disappearing at the same rate, the turnover, so the count holds roughly steady while the list changes.
- This is a model: it leaves out new species forming on the island, real curves need not be straight, and it predicts how many species, not which ones.
Second film Emptying Islands
- Simberloff and Wilson censused the arthropods on six small red mangrove islands in the Florida Keys, removed them by fumigation under a tent, and censused again for a year.
- By about day 250, all but the most distant island, E1, held species numbers similar to untreated islands, though population densities were still abnormally low.
- The returning species were not all the ones present before, and in the second year arrivals and losses continued while the count changed little.
- The Jaccard similarity, species shared divided by species in either list, separates which species are present from how many.
- A steady count with a changed list fits a dynamic equilibrium without proving its mechanism, and census gaps make the measured rates rough.
Only this unit will print. Press Ctrl+P or ⌘P to print it. Show the whole course again
Ecosystem processes
21. Energy Flow and Productivity
Guiding idea. Energy fixed by plants leaves every feeding step by one of three doors, passed up as production, dropped into detritus or lost as heat, so production shrinks by a product of fractions at each level.
First film Three Doors
- Production is a rate, energy fixed or formed per square metre per year; biomass is a stock.
- Net primary production is gross primary production minus what the producers themselves respire.
- At every feeding step energy leaves by one of three doors: passed up as consumer production, dropped into detritus (uneaten, or as feces), or lost as heat.
- Transfer efficiency is consumption times assimilation times net production efficiency; in the made-up budget the first link passed on 6%.
- Because the fractions multiply, production shrinks fast up a food chain, as long as consumers eat no more than the production below them.
Second film Where the Marsh Grass Goes
- In Teal's Georgia salt marsh, insects and other animals grazing living cordgrass took only a small part of its production.
- Most grass production went to detritus rather than to grazers: it died, broke into fragments and fed bacteria and detritus-feeding animals, which are themselves eaten.
- Energy in detritus can feed decomposers, detritus feeders and their predators, but it never returns to the producers: respiration releases it as heat, and only matter cycles.
- Teal's figure of about 45% of net production available to leave with the tides was a remainder, not a measured export.
22. Nutrient Cycling
Guiding idea. An ecosystem's store of an element changes only through what crosses its boundary, while a loop of recycling inside, often much larger, cancels in the sum.
First film The Loop Inside the Line
- An element's store inside a boundary changes only by what crosses it: change in stock = inputs - outputs, for a stated boundary and interval.
- Inside a forest, decomposers and plants pass nitrogen round a loop that is often several times larger than all the inputs.
- That loop never crosses the boundary, so it cancels in the budget, yet here it is the largest flux.
- Cut the trees and stop regrowth, and decomposers keep releasing nitrogen that no plant takes up; much of it leaves in the stream as nitrate.
- At Hubbard Brook the stream from the cut watershed carried far more nitrate and calcium than the uncut one: the broken loop had crossed the boundary.
Second film Two Halves of One Lake
- In Lake 226 both basins received nitrogen and carbon, but only the basin that also received phosphorus became highly eutrophic.
- In Lake 227, nitrogen fertiliser stopped in 1990 while phosphorus continued, and the lake stayed highly eutrophic.
- Nitrogen-fixing cyanobacteria took nitrogen from the air and made up the nitrogen that was no longer added.
- No microbe can fix phosphorus from the air, so in these lakes phosphorus supply set how much algae the lake could hold.
- These are two Ontario lakes; other lakes and many estuaries can respond to nitrogen.
23. Biodiversity and Ecosystem Function
Guiding idea. A grassland plot's production is the sum of its species, and in experiments that assigned richness at random, more species generally raised that sum and steadied it from year to year; how much steadier depends on the species' sizes and swings and on how far they rise and fall together.
First film A Field Is a Sum
- A plot's total production is the sum of what each of its species produces.
- A mixture yields extra when it beats the yield expected from its monocultures; with an even sowing that benchmark is the average monoculture, not the best.
- Extra yield can come from species doing better together on average (complementarity) or from high-yielding species gaining the most relative to their yield alone (selection); a richer draw is more likely to include such species, and both can act at once.
- With four equal species swinging independently, their swings partly cancel and the total is twice as steady as one species.
- If all the species rose and fell together, nothing would cancel; assigning richness at random keeps soil or water from systematically lining up with richness.
Second film Ten Years at Cedar Creek
- At Cedar Creek, 168 plots were sown in 1994 with 1, 2, 4, 8 or 16 species drawn at random from a pool of 18, with the same seed mass in every plot.
- Because richness and composition were assigned at random, soil differences and the experimenter's choices are not expected to explain the consistent rise in biomass with richness.
- Partitioned year by year over 1996 to 2005, the extra yield shifted from selection toward complementarity, and by the end selection was strongly negative.
- In richer plots species varied proportionally more from year to year on average, yet the plot's total varied proportionally less.
- The analysis found no evidence of a covariance effect; statistical averaging and a higher mean explained the steadier total.
Only this unit will print. Press Ctrl+P or ⌘P to print it. Show the whole course again
Global change and decisions
24. Global Change: Species on the Move
Guiding idea. Under warming, a range edge set by temperature keeps up only if it moves as fast as its isotherm, whose speed is the warming rate divided by the local temperature gradient, so ecologists measure how the gap between species and isotherm changes from a stated start.
First film The Climbing Line
- Warming moves an isotherm, a line of equal temperature, poleward and uphill.
- The isotherm's speed, the climate velocity, is the warming rate divided by how fast temperature changes across the land.
- On a slope cooling 0.6 C per 100 m, warming of 0.3 C per decade moves the isotherm about 50 m uphill per decade.
- In one European example, one metre uphill gives the cooling of about 1.5 km poleward; the exchange rate varies by place, so each shift is compared with its own isotherm.
- A range keeps up only by moving as fast as its isotherm; a shift shows change, not its cause.
Second film Two Forests, One Bird
- Many spring events now come earlier, but interacting species often shift by different amounts, so an earlier date alone cannot show keeping up.
- Trophic mismatch is the offset between peak food and peak demand, such as nestlings in the nest; unequal shifts can open or widen it.
- In nine Dutch pied flycatcher populations, numbers fell about 90% over two decades where caterpillars peaked early, and weakly at most where they peaked late.
- That comparison across sites supports a cost of mismatch, but the forests were not assigned their food timing.
- In aviaries with food freely available, a warmer temperature pattern generally advanced great tits' laying, pointing to temperature as a likely cue.
25. Conservation and Restoration
Guiding idea. In a simple model of one population, if the trend, its average yearly change on a log scale, is zero or below, the population reaches the floor in the long run and size only buys time; how soon depends on the trend, the size and the year-to-year swings together, so conservation starts by removing the cause of decline.
First film Trend and Chance
- In a simple model of one population, if the trend, its average yearly change on a log scale, is zero or below, the population reaches the floor in the long run; how soon depends on the trend, the size and the swings together.
- In this model, without a trend above zero, a bigger population only buys time: over a long enough span nearly every run reaches the floor.
- Chance in which animals survive and breed matters most when numbers are small, and inbreeding can pull the trend down further.
- A population viability analysis runs a fuller model of the population many times and reports the fraction that falls to the floor within a chosen time.
- So conservation starts by removing the cause of decline; alongside it, numbers, connections and genes can lift the trend or cut the risk.
Second film Eight Females from Texas
- In 1995 eight female pumas from Texas were released into the small, inbred Florida panther population, a planned genetic rescue.
- By 2010 panther numbers had about tripled and heterozygosity, a measure of genetic variation, had doubled.
- A 2024 follow-up found the genetic benefits lasting through five generations, while the population stabilised and declined during 2016 to 2020.
- Genetic rescue can ease inbreeding and lift the trend, but it does not by itself remove other causes of decline, such as habitat loss, so a population gain from it may not last.
26. Integrative Evidence Workshop
Guiding idea. A run of negative eDNA tests never proves a species is absent: each independent negative water sample multiplies the occupied sites still hidden among the negatives by the chance an occupied site is missed, and wells from one sample cannot push that sample's detection above the chance the water holds DNA.
First film What a Negative Is Worth
- A negative eDNA result does not show that a species is absent: DNA can be missed in the water, in the extraction or in the qPCR well.
- Together, the three steps set q, the chance that one water sample detects an occupied pond: its water must hold DNA, and at least one extraction must capture it and have a well amplify it.
- Each independent negative sample multiplies the occupied sites still hidden among the negatives by that miss chance, while the empty sites stay put, so the probability of occupancy falls with every new sample but, as long as a sample can sometimes detect and sometimes miss, never reaches zero.
- That probability is the hidden occupied sites divided by all the sites that tested negative, so it also depends on how likely occupancy was before sampling (the prior).
- The count assumes no false positives and a site that stays occupied or empty for the whole survey.
Second film Wells Share One Scoop
- Wells and extractions from one water sample all test that sample's water: they are second chances at the lab steps, not new tries at the scoop, so they cannot detect DNA the sample does not contain.
- However many wells you add, one sample's chance of detecting an occupied pond cannot exceed θ (theta), the chance the water holds DNA.
- In this example, adding wells to two samples (two extractions each) leaves an all-negative pond above the 5% line; a third independent water sample brings it below.
- Counting wells as if they were separate field samples is pseudoreplication: it makes a pond look emptier than the evidence shows.