Ecology and Evolution · Skim version

Evolution of Development

About 2 min to skim · 2 figures · Rewritten on

Read the full lesson → Skim the whole course →

The guiding idea

Some lake sticklebacks have almost no pelvis, yet their Pitx1 protein is unchanged. If the protein did not break, what did?

A gene's protein and its pattern of use can evolve separately: in the best-studied case, freshwater threespine sticklebacks lost much of the pelvis when Pitx1 stopped being expressed there, linked to deletions in a pelvic enhancer, while the Pitx1 protein and its expression in the jaw stayed intact.

From the film: Same Protein, Different Switch

  • In the pelvic-reduced Paxton Lake sticklebacks examined, the Pitx1 protein is unchanged.
  • An enhancer is a stretch of noncoding DNA that switches a gene on in particular tissues, and one gene can have several.
  • Paxton larvae still have Pitx1 RNA in the mouth and lower jaw, but none where the pelvis forms.
  • Losing the protein outright would remove Pitx1 wherever it works; losing pelvic enhancer activity can shrink one body part and spare the gene's other jobs.

From the film: Putting the Switch on Trial

  • In a reporter test, marine PelA drove expression in the developing pelvis, and the Paxton version with a deletion drove none in 8 fish.
  • A reporter shows what a sequence can drive in a construct, not that the body depends on it.
  • Marine PelA driving Pitx1, added to eggs from another pelvic-reduced lake, variably enhanced pelvic spines.
  • Deletions with different endpoints remove PelA in many pelvic-reduced populations, so the same switch was lost more than once.
  • Not every pelvic-reduced population carries a PelA deletion.
  1. The puzzle: a lost pelvis with a working gene

  2. Mapping: one major region, four minor

    AI-generated illustration: a marine stickleback with long pelvic spines and a Paxton benthic fish with a reduced pelvis are crossed; their F1 hybrids are bred together to give F2 fish, each scored for pelvic reduction and genotyped beside Pitx1.
    Crossing a marine fish with a Paxton benthic fish and breeding the F1 hybrids lets each F2 fish's genotype beside Pitx1 be compared with its pelvis. The fish and counts in the worked problem are invented. AI-generated illustration
    AI-generated illustration: a Paxton benthic stickleback larva in side view with gold stain on the mouth and lower jaw only; the pelvic region and tail are unstained. An inset shows an antisense probe pairing with the transcript.
    Paxton larvae still make Pitx1 transcript in the mouth and lower jaw but not where the pelvis forms, so the gene's pelvic use was lost while its jaw use stayed. Gold marks transcript detected with an antisense probe in the corrected 2006 figures; neither marine nor Paxton larvae showed any in the tail. AI-generated illustration
  3. Cis or trans: the F1 test

  4. Enhancers on trial: a second switch, and why the first keeps breaking

  5. What stays open

  6. Going deeper

Read the full lesson → Skim the whole course →