Ecology and Evolution · Skim version

Mutualism, Parasitism and Coevolution

About 2 min to skim · 2 figures · Rewritten on

Read the full lesson → Skim the whole course →

The guiding idea

The same root fungus can help a plant in poor soil and cost it in rich soil. Is it a mutualist or a parasite?

An interaction's sign is set by each partner's net of benefit minus cost, so it can shift when conditions or the partner's own evolution push a net across zero.

From the film: The Net Decides the Sign

  • An interaction is scored by its net effect on each partner: benefit minus cost, compared with life without the partner.
  • The sign follows the net, so the same root fungus can help a plant in poor soil and cost it in rich soil.
  • A net of zero can hide a large benefit and a large cost that cancel.
  • A partner that takes the reward and skips the service can be held back if the host cuts its reproduction enough, a host sanction.
  • Coevolution means each partner evolves in response to the other; a good fit alone does not show it.

From the film: Reading Evolution Across Time

  • A time-shift assay pairs parasites with hosts from the past, the same time and the future; if neither partner's heritable traits changed, every pairing should give about the same infection rate.
  • In an arms race, a parasite infects past hosts best and future hosts worst, and the difference grows with the time gap: a one-way trend points to escalation.
  • In fluctuating selection, parasites do best on hosts of about their own time, and infection rises and falls as the gap grows: a wave points to tracking. Both shapes are evidence, not proof: coevolution also needs heritable change in both partners.
  • In rotifer-alga chemostats, algae able to evolve gave long cycles with predator and prey peaks largely out of step, and defended algae were poorer competitors for nutrients.
  • Those runs showed prey evolution changing population cycles, not coevolution: predator evolution was not tested.
  1. Signs are measured nets

  2. Keeping a mutualism honest

    AI-generated illustration: two identical soybean root segments, each with one nodule inside a clear gas chamber; the left chamber is labelled Air and the right, tinted gold, Argon. A zoomed nodule below shows the same rod-shaped bacteria in both cases.
    Kiers and colleagues kept one Bradyrhizobium strain and removed only its service with argon; rhizobia in nodules that could not fix reproduced about half as well. AI-generated illustration
  3. When is it coevolution?

  4. Arms races, cycles and the length of the record

    AI-generated illustration: cross-section of a pond with a water flea above and four layers of mud below, each holding dormant egg cases and tiny parasite spores, older layers lower down. A three-step inset shows an egg lifted out, hatched in a dish, and spores added.
    Pond sediment keeps dated layers of dormant Daphnia eggs and parasite spores, so hosts and parasites from different years can be revived and tested against each other. AI-generated illustration
  5. Rotifers and algae: evolution inside a population cycle

  6. Going deeper

Read the full lesson → Skim the whole course →