Ecology and Evolution · Skim version

Natural Selection in Ecological Context

About 1 min to skim · 2 figures · Rewritten on

Read the full lesson → Skim the whole course →

The guiding idea

On lichen-covered trees, birds find dark moths more easily than pale ones. Is that evolution yet, and what else would you need to know?

Natural selection is a difference in reproductive success among variants that already exist, caused by an agent in an environment; inheritance carries the sorting forward, so it becomes evolution only when that variation is inherited.

From the film: Selection Has an Agent

  • Natural selection is a difference in reproductive success among variants that already exist, caused by an agent in an environment, such as a predator.
  • Which variant is favoured depends on the environment: on sooty bark birds took more pale moths, on lichen more dark ones.
  • Fitness is relative: what matters is how one morph does compared with another in the same place.
  • Selection sorts within one generation; inheritance carries the sorting forward, so it becomes evolution only if the sorted variation is inherited.

From the film: Two Enemies, One Gall

  • For a trait with a range of values, plotting relative fitness against the trait shows the mode of selection.
  • Favouring one end is directional, favouring the middle is stabilizing, and favouring both ends is disruptive.
  • In goldenrod galls, wasps took more larvae in small galls and birds more in large ones, so intermediate galls survived best.
  • Because wasp attack outweighed bird attack in those fields, selection also favoured larger galls: one trait carried two components.
  1. Measuring the fitness difference

  2. Peppered moths and birds

  3. Gall flies: two modes in one trait

  4. Disruptive: crowded sticklebacks

  5. Frequency-dependent: rare guppies

    AI-generated illustration: two stream pools side by side with four male guppies each. In the left pool three are plain and one is spotted; in the right pool three are spotted and one is plain. The rare fish in each pool is ringed in gold. An inset shows the plain and spotted patterns once each.
    Reversing which pattern was rare between pools, with male guppies set at about 3 common to 1 rare, let rarity be told apart from the pattern itself. The drawing simplifies the study's two tail-colour patterns to plain and spotted. AI-generated illustration
  6. Sexual selection: the widowbird tail

    AI-generated illustration: three male long-tailed widowbirds on grass stems, identical except for the tail: the left has a shortened tail, the middle a normal very long tail, and the right a longer tail whose added section is drawn in gold.
    Random assignment made the tail the one planned difference: in Andersson's experiment in Kenya, males matched in groups of four had tails shortened, left normal (two control groups), or lengthened with added feather. AI-generated illustration
  7. Going deeper

Read the full lesson → Skim the whole course →