Ecology and Evolution · Skim version

How to Test an Evolutionary Explanation

About 2 min to skim · 3 figures · Rewritten on

Read the full lesson → Skim the whole course →

The guiding idea

A drought killed most of an island's finches, and the survivors had bigger beaks. Is that evolution yet?

A nonrandom difference in survival shows selection, not yet evolution.

From the film: Three Claims in One Drought

  • The 1977 drought on Daphne Major sorted the finches: survivors had larger beaks than the population before it.
  • That gap measures selection through survival; if the survivors breed about equally, it is the selection differential S. It is not yet shown to be evolution.
  • For one trait, the breeder's equation R = h² × S predicts how far the chicks' average moves: only part of the way, a fraction h² of S.
  • If heritability were zero and the environment stayed the same, the chicks' average would not move, however strong the selection.
  • Selection happened, the trait is inherited, the offspring changed: each claim needs its own evidence.

From the film: Changing the Cause on Purpose

  • Comparing natural sites shows an association, because the sites differ in more than one way.
  • Moving guppies from one source into a reach with a different predator changed the setting on purpose.
  • About 11 years later, the moved guppies matured later and larger, the predicted direction.
  • An experiment can test a cause, but this one is still one stream and one introduction, and the new reach differed in more than its predator.
  • When a past event cannot be rerun, historical inference tests rival explanations against the traces it left.
  1. Claim 1: selection happened

  2. Claim 2: the trait is inherited

    AI-generated illustration: a finch nest holding two chicks, one labelled chick and one outlined in gold and labelled extra-pair young. A dark male labelled feeding male, social father feeds a chick while a female perches at left, and a second dark male labelled genetic father sits on a branch at right. Two insets compare a pedigree from behaviour, where the feeding male is linked to both chicks, with a pedigree from DNA, where he is linked to one chick and a gold dashed line links the other chick to the genetic father.
    The natural shortcut is to take the birds feeding a chick as its parents. Keller and colleagues checked it with DNA: some offspring were extra-pair young, whose social father was not the genetic father, and removing them raised the father-offspring estimates of inheritance by 21 percent on average. AI-generated illustration
  3. Claim 3: the offspring changed

  4. The direction of selection can reverse

    AI-generated illustration: three scenes of dry island ground in time order. In the 1977 drought, large hard seeds lie beside a large-beaked finch; after the wet El Niño of 1982 and 1983, small soft seeds and seedlings appear; in the 1985 drought, small soft seeds lie beside a small pointed-beaked finch. Two insets compare a larger beak with a small pointed beak.
    The same island, two droughts, opposite outcomes. In 1977 the food left was dominated by large hard seeds and larger birds survived best; after the wet El Niño of 1982 and 1983 it was dominated by small soft seeds, and in 1985 small birds with pointed beaks survived disproportionately well. AI-generated illustration
  5. Three kinds of evidence, and what each can carry

    AI-generated illustration: two stream reaches side by side. In the left one a predator fish faces adult guppies; in the right one a different predator fish faces small juvenile guppies. A gold arrow from a net shows guppies moved from left to right, with a timeline arrow reading 11 years later. Two insets contrast the predators' targets.
    One source population, moved into a reach whose predator eats juveniles: the change of setting was made on purpose. The design tests that change; because the new reach also differed in more than its predator, it does not by itself isolate the predator. AI-generated illustration
  6. What a dataset cannot show

  7. Going deeper

Read the full lesson → Skim the whole course →