Ecology and Evolution · Skim version

Biodiversity and Ecosystem Function

About 2 min to skim · 2 figures · Rewritten on

Read the full lesson → Skim the whole course →

The guiding idea

Grassland plots sown with sixteen species generally out-grew plots with one, yet the species inside them were, on average, less steady from year to year. How can the total be steadier than its parts?

A grassland plot's production is the sum of its species, and in experiments that assigned richness at random, more species generally raised that sum and steadied it from year to year; how much steadier depends on the species' sizes and swings and on how far they rise and fall together.

From the film: A Field Is a Sum

  • A plot's total production is the sum of what each of its species produces.
  • A mixture yields extra when it beats the yield expected from its monocultures; with an even sowing that benchmark is the average monoculture, not the best.
  • Extra yield can come from species doing better together on average (complementarity) or from high-yielding species gaining the most relative to their yield alone (selection); a richer draw is more likely to include such species, and both can act at once.
  • With four equal species swinging independently, their swings partly cancel and the total is twice as steady as one species.
  • If all the species rose and fell together, nothing would cancel; assigning richness at random keeps soil or water from systematically lining up with richness.

From the film: Ten Years at Cedar Creek

  • At Cedar Creek, 168 plots were sown in 1994 with 1, 2, 4, 8 or 16 species drawn at random from a pool of 18, with the same seed mass in every plot.
  • Because richness and composition were assigned at random, soil differences and the experimenter's choices are not expected to explain the consistent rise in biomass with richness.
  • Partitioned year by year over 1996 to 2005, the extra yield shifted from selection toward complementarity, and by the end selection was strongly negative.
  • In richer plots species varied proportionally more from year to year on average, yet the plot's total varied proportionally less.
  • The analysis found no evidence of a covariance effect; statistical averaging and a higher mean explained the steadier total.
  1. The question: does richness change what an ecosystem does?

  2. Building communities at random: Cedar Creek and BIODEPTH

    AI-generated illustration: three steps left to right: a narrow strip of grassland being clipped at ground level with shears, the cut plants drying on a tray in an oven, and the dried plants on a laboratory balance.
    Each year's biomass came from clipping the aboveground vegetation in sampling strips, drying it and weighing it. AI-generated illustration
    AI-generated illustration: a schematic top-down field of equal square plots in five columns holding one, two, four, eight and sixteen plant tufts, with a key tray of eighteen plant types and an arrow marking the random draw; one plot is outlined and marked nine by nine metres.
    Assigning richness at random, with equal seed in every plot, means a consistent difference between richness levels is not expected to come from soil or from species the experimenter picked. Simplified; the real experiment had 168 plots. AI-generated illustration
  3. Splitting the extra yield (worked problem)

  4. Stability: how to score it, and when cancelling fails

  5. Beyond the plots

  6. Going deeper

Read the full lesson → Skim the whole course →