Ecology and Evolution · Skim version

Drift, Gene Flow and Competing Explanations

About 2 min to skim · 2 figures · Rewritten on

Read the full lesson → Skim the whole course →

The guiding idea

Sixteen flies bred each generation, yet the flies drifted as if there were only nine. Why?

Across replicate populations, drift spreads allele frequencies apart without pushing their average; gene flow and consistent selection push the average.

From the film: Mean and Spread

  • Genetic drift is change in allele frequency from the chance sampling of parents; it needs no difference in fitness.
  • Across replicate populations, drift spreads allele frequencies apart without pushing their average.
  • Gene flow pulls replicates that start alike and receive the same immigrants toward the immigrants' frequency by the same amount.
  • Consistent selection, favouring the same allele everywhere, pushes the average toward it, while drift still scatters each population.
  • How fast the replicates spread depends on the effective population size, Ne, not simply the number of animals you count.

From the film: 107 Bottles

  • Buri started 107 fruit-fly lines at an allele frequency of 0.5 and kept 16 parents in each, generation after generation.
  • Over 19 generations the lines spread toward 0 and 1, and many ended with only one allele.
  • The frequency pooled over all the lines showed no systematic change: spread without a push on the average, the pattern drift predicts.
  • From how fast the lines spread, Buri estimated an effective size of about 9, below the 16 flies in each bottle.
  • One line on its own wanders and tells you little about cause; replicates show whether the average was pushed.
  1. Drift is sampling error

  2. Buri’s 107 fly lines: drift as a distribution

  3. Founders and frontiers: anoles on islands, bacteria on agar

    AI-generated illustration: a larger source island on the left with broad shrubs and brown anole lizards, with gold arrows to seven small islands on the right, each with slender vegetation and one male and one female lizard. An inset compares a broad source branch with a thin twig on the small islands.
    Seven small Bahamian islands with narrow vegetation, each founded by one random brown anole pair from a single source: founder effects show as islands that differ, selection as a shift they all share. Schematic, not to scale. AI-generated illustration
    AI-generated illustration: a round colony on an agar plate whose speckled two-colour centre gives way to sharp single-colour wedges radiating outward, with a thin gold band marking the growing edge. Two insets show the mixed start and a zoom on the few pioneer cells at the rim.
    Only a thin band of pioneer cells at the edge founds each new stretch of colony, so chance in that band, not the mass of cells behind it, decides which colour is carried outward, even in an enormous population. Schematic. AI-generated illustration
  4. Gene flow: swamping or rescue

  5. Three explanations for one pattern

  6. Going deeper

Read the full lesson → Skim the whole course →