Ecology and Evolution · Skim version

Life Histories and Evolutionary Trade-offs

About 2 min to skim · 2 figures · Rewritten on

Read the full lesson → Skim the whole course →

The guiding idea

If breeding can cost a bird its future, why do birds that lay more eggs often survive better from one year to the next?

What an individual takes in sets its budget, how it splits that budget among growth, upkeep, storage and reproduction is where trade-offs live, and selection favours the split that leaves the most descendants, given who dies at what age.

From the film: One Budget, Many Uses

  • Treat what an individual takes in and can use as one budget, split among growth, upkeep, storage and reproduction.
  • For one individual with a given budget, more to reproduction leaves less for itself: that negative link is a trade-off.
  • Two classic trade-offs: this year's young against the parent's own future, and many small offspring against a few large ones.
  • Selection acts on the split, favouring whichever split leaves the most descendants, given who dies at what age.
  • Low adult survival lowers the extra young one big bout needs to pay, so putting more into this year's bout can pay; how far still depends on how extra effort changes breeding and survival. Where adults survive well, or young survive poorly, holding back to breed again can pay.

From the film: Why the Trade-off Hides

  • Birds that take in more can afford more of everything, so larger clutches can go with better survival even when each bird faces a trade-off.
  • Van Noordwijk and de Jong's comparison: people with large incomes have bigger houses and newer cars, yet for any one income the two still trade off.
  • A natural correlation alone cannot show a trade-off or rule one out.
  • Adding chicks to nests chosen at random balances richer and poorer parents between the groups on average, so a later survival difference can be laid on the extra chicks, allowing for chance.
  • Across 30 bird species, enlarged broods lowered parents' survival a little on average (the cost per extra chick was uncertain), while naturally larger clutches went with better survival.
  1. Semelparity, iteroparity and the cost of reproduction

    AI-generated illustration: two horizontal lifelines. The upper one, with a salmon icon, ends shortly after a single gold reproduction marker; the lower one, with a songbird icon, carries three gold reproduction markers along its later part.
    In the simple model, breeding once breaks even only with p / c extra young: few when adults rarely survive, many when young rarely do. AI-generated illustration
  2. r and K, then the fast-slow continuum

    AI-generated illustration: a side view of a stream split by a small waterfall. Downstream, small guppies swim among larger predatory fish; upstream, guppies swim without large predatory fish, and a gold arrow shows two guppies moved from the downstream reach to the upstream one. A three-step strip below shows the source site, the move, and later sampling.
    Moving guppies to a site where predators eat mostly juveniles shifted deaths from adults to young, and within 11 years the population evolved later maturity and fewer, larger offspring, as theory predicts; density and food changed too. AI-generated illustration
  3. Testing a trade-off: correlation versus manipulation

  4. Going deeper

Read the full lesson → Skim the whole course →