Ecology and Evolution · Skim version

Competition

About 2 min to skim · 2 figures · Rewritten on

Read the full lesson → Skim the whole course →

The guiding idea

One competitor grows twice as fast as the other. Why does it not always win?

In the Lotka-Volterra competition model, two competitors coexist stably when each can grow when it is rare and the other is at its carrying capacity: each limits itself more than it limits the other.

From the film: Can It Grow When Rare?

  • Competition lowers each species' per-capita growth, and alpha converts the other species into units of one's own kind.
  • The invasion test asks whether a species can grow when it is rare and its competitor is at carrying capacity.
  • In the model, with both species present: if both pass, they coexist stably; if only one passes, it excludes the other from that place; if neither passes, the start decides.
  • The growth rate r is not in the rule, so it changes how fast and by what route the populations move, not which verdict the model gives: the faster grower need not win.
  • In this model, both coexist stably when each can grow when rare: each limits itself more than it limits the other.

From the film: What Keeps Chthamalus High?

  • At Millport, Chthamalus lives above Balanus, and longer immersion, predators or crowding by Balanus could each explain that boundary.
  • Connell removed Balanus from a randomly chosen half of each mapped patch and left the other half untouched as the comparison, so better survival on the cleared half is strong evidence that Balanus limited Chthamalus.
  • Chthamalus kept free of Balanus survived well at the levels he studied, and Balanus killed it by smothering, undercutting and crushing it.
  • So at Millport, competition from Balanus set the lower limit of Chthamalus, whose fundamental niche reaches lower than its realized niche.
  • It is one shore and one pair of species; its strength is the design, not the generality. Randomized, controlled removal: better survival is evidence the neighbour was limiting.
  1. Kinds of competition

  2. Lotka-Volterra: the invasion test in numbers

  3. Exclusion is a model conclusion

  4. Connell’s barnacles: what the film left out

    AI-generated illustration: a top-down view of one mapped rock patch split into two halves. In one half four small barnacles stand alone on cleared rock; in the other the same four are touched and surrounded by larger crowded barnacles. A small inset shows a separate patch under a mesh cage.
    Clearing Balanus from a random half of each mapped patch, beside an untouched half at the same height and weather, gives strong evidence that Balanus limits Chthamalus survival; cages on some patches kept out the whelk Thais. AI-generated illustration
  5. Partitioning and character displacement

    AI-generated illustration: a single spruce tree in side view with one small warbler perched near the top and another among the dense middle branches, each surrounded by a gold shaded band marking where it fed.
    Warblers share one spruce by feeding in different parts of it, Cape May warblers mostly in the tops and black-throated green warblers in the dense middle branches; watching shows partitioning, but it does not test whether competition caused it. AI-generated illustration
  6. Going deeper

Read the full lesson → Skim the whole course →