Ecology and Evolution · Skim version

Speciation: How Barriers to Gene Flow Evolve

About 2 min to skim · 3 figures · Rewritten on

Read the full lesson → Skim the whole course →

The guiding idea

Two monkeyflowers can be crossed by hand, yet they almost never exchange genes in the wild. What barriers hold them apart, and how did adapting to different places and pollinators build those barriers?

A new species forms when barriers that reduce gene flow evolve between populations that once interbred, and several partial barriers, whose leaks multiply, can together block nearly all of it.

From the film: Leaks That Multiply

  • A reproductive barrier is anything that reduces gene flow between populations.
  • When barriers act one after another and independently, each one blocks only the gene flow left by earlier barriers.
  • The fractions that get through multiply, so several partial barriers can block nearly all gene flow.
  • Barriers before the zygote are prezygotic; barriers after it, such as hybrids that fail to survive or are sterile, are postzygotic.
  • In the monkeyflowers, most of the isolation comes before any hybrid forms.

From the film: Isolation Follows Ecology

  • Divergent selection favours different traits in different habitats.
  • Selection acts on individuals and builds no barrier on purpose; isolation that arises as a side effect of adaptation is called ecological speciation.
  • In stickleback mating trials, fish of the same form from different lakes showed no strong isolation, while fish of different forms were strongly isolated.
  • When isolation repeats with the environment, lake after lake, drift alone is unlikely and divergent selection is the likely cause.
  • In the monkeyflowers, adaptation to elevation and to pollinators is itself the barrier.
  1. Measuring barriers, and why their leaks multiply

  2. Kinds of barrier: before and after the zygote

  3. How barriers evolve: divergent selection

    AI-generated illustration: two side-by-side panels with pairs of butterflies. On the left, two butterflies that live together are joined by a dashed arrow meaning they rarely mate, and their hybrid has a cluster of eggs, so it is fertile. On the right, two forms of one species are joined by a solid arrow, and their hybrid female has a crossed-out cluster of eggs, so it is sterile.
    Heliconius elevatus and H. pardalinus butleri fly together in the Amazon and rarely mated in captivity, but their hybrids were fertile. Two separate forms of H. pardalinus mated, yet their female first-generation (F1) hybrids were sterile. Sterile hybrids are one kind of barrier, not a requirement for being a species. AI-generated illustration
  4. Geography and mechanism are separate questions

    AI-generated illustration: three map-style schematics of populations shown as dots. In the first, a band such as a sea or mountain range divides one population into two parts; in the second, a few dots cross water to found a new population on an island; in the third, two kinds of dots share one area with no barrier.
    Allopatric speciation needs the populations apart, by vicariance (a new barrier divides one population) or dispersal (a few individuals found a new one elsewhere); sympatric speciation happens within one area. All three answer where, not how the barriers arose. AI-generated illustration
    AI-generated illustration: two side-by-side schematics of a round crater lake with a nearby larger lake and river. On the left one fish arrives and splits into two kinds inside the crater lake; on the right two kinds of fish arrive separately and meet there. A small inset compares two simple trees, one where the two lake fish are each other's closest relatives and one where each groups with a different outside population.
    Two cichlid species in one crater lake could have diverged there or arrived separately and met later (secondary contact), so living together proves neither. Comparing who is related to whom, with source populations sampled, helps tell the histories apart; in Nicaraguan crater lakes the analyses supported divergence beginning in sympatry, with some admixture from outside. AI-generated illustration
  5. Polyploidy: isolation in one step

  6. What counts as a species: criteria as evidence

  7. Going deeper

Read the full lesson → Skim the whole course →