Ecology and Evolution · Skim version

Molecular Evolution

About 2 min to skim · 2 figures · Rewritten on

Read the full lesson → Skim the whole course →

The guiding idea

Two species left no fossil of their split. Can their genes still tell you when it happened?

Neutral changes are fixed, on average, at the rate they arise, so the count of differences between two species grows steadily with time and can be dated from one calibrated split; a departure from that count is a clue to selection, not proof.

From the film: Why Genes Keep Time

  • A substitution is a mutation that has spread to every member of a lineage.
  • Differences between two species build up on both branches since their common ancestor.
  • On average, neutral mutations become substitutions at the rate they arise, whatever the population size: a bigger population makes more, but each is less likely to spread.
  • Sequences alone cannot tell a fast rate over a short time from a slow rate over a long one; an outside date, usually a fossil, is needed, and it can date another split only if the two share a rate.
  • The oldest fossil of a group gives a minimum age: the real split was earlier.

From the film: Reading Selection in Genes

  • A synonymous change keeps the amino acid; a nonsynonymous, or replacement, change alters it.
  • If synonymous changes are neutral, omega = dN/dS reads selection on the protein: below 1 suggests purifying selection, near 1 is consistent with neutrality, above 1 suggests positive selection.
  • The McDonald-Kreitman test compares the ratio of replacement to synonymous changes among variants within a species with the same ratio among differences fixed between species.
  • At Adh in fruit flies, fixed differences held more replacements than the variants predicted, which McDonald and Kreitman suggested reflected adaptive fixation.
  • Each test is a model inference: a departure from the neutral count is a clue to selection, not proof, and needs further checks before it counts as adaptation.
  1. Sequences as a record

  2. Why the clock ticks

  3. Reading time: calibration

  4. When the tick rate varies

    AI-generated illustration: two population fields of plain dots, a small one with six dots and a large one with twenty-four. A slightly harmful mutation, marked in gold, spreads to every dot in the small population but is removed in the large one. A bracket beneath notes that a large population makes more neutral mutations, each with a smaller chance of fixing.
    For slightly harmful mutations, drift can fix them in a small population while selection removes them in a large one, so their substitution rate depends on the effective population size. For strictly neutral mutations it does not: more mutations in a large population are offset by a smaller chance that each fixes. AI-generated illustration
  5. Reading selection in coding sequences

    AI-generated illustration: a row of six codon blocks, each with three small squares, above a string of six coloured beads for amino acids. Two insets compare a synonymous change, where one square turns gold but the bead keeps its colour, with a nonsynonymous change, where one square turns gold and the bead changes colour.
    In a coding gene, a nonsynonymous change alters the amino acid and a synonymous change does not, because the genetic code has several codons for most amino acids. That is why dS can serve as a built-in control for dN. AI-generated illustration
  6. When the signal misleads

  7. Going deeper

Read the full lesson → Skim the whole course →