Ecology and Evolution · Skim version

Predation and Community Effects

About 2 min to skim · 2 figures · Rewritten on

Read the full lesson → Skim the whole course →

The guiding idea

If predators eat prey, why do predator numbers keep climbing after the prey have started to fall?

Every kill is entered in two ledgers, a death for the prey and food that, on average, predators turn into births, so each population's per capita growth rate is set by the other's numbers, and a predator can affect species it rarely or never eats, and can even help some species it also eats.

From the film: Two Ledgers, One Kill

  • Each kill is a death for the prey and food that, on average, predators turn into births, so each population's per capita growth rate is set by the other's numbers.
  • Prey increase while predators are fewer than P* = r/a; predators increase while prey are more than N* = m/(ea).
  • Predators keep rising after prey have peaked, so predator peaks come after prey peaks, though the model builds in no delay.
  • In the classical Lotka-Volterra model each start with both populations present and away from the equilibrium keeps its own closed loop, so the start sets the size of the cycle.

From the film: Fifteen to Eight

  • Paine kept the sea star Pisaster ochraceus off one patch of shore at Mukkaw Bay, Washington, beside an untouched control.
  • Without Pisaster, mussels, the strongest competitors for space on the rock, spread, and the species holding space on the rock fell from 15 to 8.
  • Pisaster's effects ran through the mussels it ate to the species they compete with: it kept space open, including for some species it also ate.
  • A keystone species has an effect on its community that is large relative to its abundance.
  • This was one removal patch and one control: a strong local result, not yet a general law.
  1. Two ledgers, written as equations

  2. What the classical cycle leaves out

  3. What one shore can and cannot show

  4. Cascades through killing and through fear

    AI-generated illustration: two side-by-side shallow-sea cross-sections near small islands. On the left, three sea otters float above a few urchins and a dense kelp bed; on the right there are no otters, the seafloor is covered with urchins and only a little kelp remains. A question mark sits on the line between them, and an inset shows a sea urchin.
    Amchitka, with many otters, had few urchins and dense kelp; Shemya, without otters, had many urchins and little kelp. No one removed otters, so the contrast fits a cascade but leaves room for other differences between the islands. AI-generated illustration
    AI-generated illustration: three identical mesh field enclosures, each with three grasshoppers on grass and herbs: no spider, a hunting spider, and a spider with glued mouthparts. Grass is notched where there is no spider; herbs are holed where there are spiders. Two insets compare a spider's normal jaws and fangs with jaws sealed by glue.
    Spiders with glued mouthparts could be sensed but could not kill, yet with either kind of spider grasses were damaged less and herbs more, while grasshopper densities did not differ significantly: a cascade carried by risk, not deaths. AI-generated illustration
  5. How far one system generalizes

  6. Going deeper

Read the full lesson → Skim the whole course →