Developmental Neuroscience · Skim version

Too Many Neurons: Naturally Occurring Cell Death

About 2 min to skim · 2 figures · Rewritten on

Read the full lesson → Skim the whole course →

The guiding idea

In Hamburger's raw counts, a chick embryo has just over 20,000 motor neurons in the column that serves its leg at the peak, and about 40% of them die over the next three days. Nothing is wrong with the embryo. How could anyone tell those neurons died, and what decides how many stay?

Make too many, then let the target keep what it can support: in the chick limb experiments, changing the target changed how many of the neurons already present survived.

From the film: Too Many, Then Fewer

  • Many developing neurons are made in excess, and the target helps set how many survive.
  • In the chick limb experiments, changing the target changed how many neurons survived but not detectably how many were made.
  • Some neurons die on a schedule that the target does not set.

From the film: Count Across Time

  • A low count at the end cannot tell neurons that were never made from neurons that were made and then lost, so you must count across time.
  • In Hamburger's raw counts, about two in five leg motor neurons died after the peak near day six.
  • An extra leg did not add motor neurons before the normal loss; more target meant fewer deaths, not more births.

From the film: A Dial With a Ceiling

  • The target turns a dial: more target, fewer deaths, up to a ceiling set by the neurons present.
  • In mice, about the same fraction of transplanted interneuron precursors died at every dose tested, and they died at their own age.
  • An early wave of chick cervical motor neuron death is not controlled by the target and needs new RNA and protein.
  1. Too small, or lost?

  2. Counting the death itself

  3. More target

  4. A dial with a ceiling

  5. How a developing neuron dies

    AI-generated illustration: two three-step strips compare necrosis, where a neuron swells, bursts and inflames the tissue, with apoptosis, where it shrinks, its nucleus condenses and darkens, phosphatidylserine appears on the outer surface, and it breaks into fragments engulfed by a microglial cell. A membrane inset is schematic.
    Necrosis typically follows injury, with swelling, membrane rupture and inflammation, though injury can also trigger apoptosis. Most developing neurons die by apoptosis instead: the nucleus condenses, the cell fragments, and microglia read phosphatidylserine flipped to the outer membrane leaflet as an eat-me signal, so few dying cells are visible at any moment. AI-generated illustration
  6. How much, and where

  7. Why make neurons just to kill them?

    AI-generated illustration: two panels. In Matching, six neurons send axons to one target, which sends limited support back along three of them; those three survive and the other three break up. In Error correction, four retinal cells send axons to matching positions in the superior colliculus, except one whose axon ends in the wrong position, and that cell breaks up.
    Two jobs for overproduction and death. Matching: a target supplies limited support, so the number of neurons that survive is set without a plan. Error correction: in the newborn rat, retinal ganglion cells whose axons reach the wrong part of the superior colliculus are removed preferentially, though pruning branches or synapses fixes many other wiring errors. AI-generated illustration
  8. Where the target account stops

  9. Putting it together

  10. Going deeper

Read the full lesson → Skim the whole course →