Developmental Neuroscience · Skim version

Activity Before Experience: Spontaneous Retinal Waves

About 2 min to skim · 4 figures · Rewritten on

Read the full lesson → Skim the whole course →

The guiding idea

Weeks before vision begins, the retina already fires in waves. What are they for?

Timing is the address: a target cell keeps the inputs that fire in step with its other strong inputs, and because the inputs compete, the ones it keeps crowd out the rest.

From the film: Timing Is the Address

  • Timing is the address: a target cell keeps the inputs that fire in step with its other strong inputs, and they crowd out the rest.
  • Near neighbours in one eye fire almost together in a wave, while the other eye's waves match only by chance.
  • Hebb's rule alone only strengthens inputs, so separating the eyes also needs competition between inputs.

From the film: Block It, Tilt It

  • Blocking spikes with tetrodotoxin in fetal cats kept the two eyes' projections mixed, so spikes are needed.
  • In young ferrets, the more active eye's projection expanded and the other's shrank, so relative activity shifts territory.
  • Making waves more frequent in both eyes left the layers normal, so territory follows the difference between the eyes, not the total.

From the film: Correlation, Not Just Spikes

  • In beta2 knockout mice, plenty of uncorrelated spiking in the first week left the termination zones broad.
  • Normally patterned activity, not just spiking, is needed early for the map to sharpen.
  • In the frog tectum, a third eye makes stripes where none normally exist, and keeping them needs NMDA receptors.
  1. The problem: a rough first draft

    AI-generated illustration: two panels, each with two eyes sending axons to one LGN, drawn as an oval. Early, the branching endings of both eyes' axons are intermixed throughout the oval. In the adult, each eye's endings are sorted into its own bands, stacked like layers.
    Early in development the axons from the two eyes overlap in the LGN; in the adult they end in separate eye-specific territories, which in cats, ferrets and primates are distinct layers. Getting from one to the other is refinement. The drawing is schematic. AI-generated illustration
  2. Why activity? Two neighbours look the same to a gradient

    AI-generated illustration: one target cell in the LGN, before and after. Before, three inputs from neighbouring cells of eye A fire together and three inputs from eye B fire at another time, all the same size. After, the eye A terminals are larger and cover more of the cell, and the eye B terminals are gone, leaving dashed outlines and pulled-back axons.
    Timing is the address. Inputs from near neighbours in one eye fire together, and with competition the in-step inputs take over the cell while the out-of-step ones lose territory. Strengthening alone would leave the cell binocular. This is a sketch of the rule, and which eye wins a given cell depends on small early differences. AI-generated illustration
  3. What the waves look like

  4. What makes a wave, briefly

    AI-generated illustration: three panels showing the changing driver of retinal waves. In the first, two neighbouring ganglion cells are joined by a gap junction. In the second, starburst amacrine cells release acetylcholine onto nicotinic receptors on one another and on a ganglion cell. In the third, a bipolar cell releases glutamate onto a ganglion cell.
    The dominant driver of retinal waves changes with development in the mouse: gap junctions (with nicotinic receptors) first, then acetylcholine from starburst amacrine cells, then glutamate from bipolar cells. The panels show selected contributions, not complete circuits; the stages overlap, embryonic waves are less well studied, and every stage gives correlated firing among neighbouring cells. AI-generated illustration
  5. Block it: silence everything

  6. Tilt it: make the eyes unequal

  7. Disrupt the correlation, keep plenty of spikes

  8. Add an eye: the three-eyed frog

    AI-generated illustration: two panels, each with a normal eye and an extra eye sending axons into one tectal lobe, drawn as an oval. In the first, the two eyes' endings form alternating stripes. In the second, a pad of APV lies on the tectum and the endings are intermixed with no stripes.
    Two eyes sent into one frog tectal lobe form alternating stripes, where none normally exist. APV, which blocks NMDA receptors, desegregated the stripes in three-eyed tadpoles, and they returned after it was removed: in the frog tectum, keeping the stripes needs NMDA receptor activity. Whether the mammalian LGN uses the same detector is less clear. AI-generated illustration
  9. Putting it together

  10. Going deeper

Read the full lesson → Skim the whole course →