Developmental Neuroscience · Skim version

Ocular Dominance and the Critical Period

About 3 min to skim · 2 figures · Rewritten on

Read the full lesson → Skim the whole course →

The guiding idea

Why does closing one eye of a kitten for a week rewire its cortex, when closing both eyes shifts the balance much less?

While the cortex develops, the two eyes compete for the cells they share, and each cell keeps the eye, or both eyes, that help it fire.

From the film: One Cell, Two Eyes

  • The two eyes' pathways stay apart through the LGN and the layer 4 stripes of primary visual cortex.
  • Above and below layer 4, many cells in cats and monkeys can be driven by both eyes, and the eyes compete for these shared cells.
  • An ocular-dominance histogram sorts cells into seven groups, and in a normal adult cat it is a hump leaning toward the contralateral side.

From the film: Six Days at Four Weeks

  • In kittens, closing one eye for a few days in the fourth or fifth week moves most of the histogram toward the open eye.
  • Susceptibility in kittens rises from about the fourth week and declines through the third month, while months of closure in an adult cat leave the cortex looking normal.
  • The closed eye's retina still responds, so the loss is in the brain, not the eye.
  • Closure also changes the territory each eye's axons hold, not only how cells respond.

From the film: Two Closed Eyes

  • Closing both eyes shifts the balance between the eyes far less than closing one.
  • What cost the single closed eye its cells was mainly the open eye's advantage, so the eyes compete for the cells they share.
  • Going without vision is not harmless, since some cells respond abnormally or not at all.

From the film: Out of Step

  • In strabismic kittens each eye sends a normal amount of activity, yet most cells answer to one eye or the other and few to both.
  • Amount matters, but only activity in step with the cell's strong responses helps an eye keep it.
  • The cell keeps the eye, or both eyes, that help it fire, and which eye leads differs from cell to cell.

From the film: Silence Is Not Noise

  • Silencing one eye of kittens with tetrodotoxin shifts cortical responses toward the eye that kept firing, so an imbalance of activity is enough to cause a shift.
  • In kittens, lid suture weakens the closed eye's responses more than tetrodotoxin does.
  • A sutured eye's leftover activity is out of step with the cells it drives, while a silent eye is not active at the wrong moments, so silence is not the same as noise.

From the film: The Window and the Patch

  • A sensitive period is a window of unusually strong effect of experience, and a critical period is one in which the experience is essential and its effects last.
  • The window differs between species, so name the species with every number.
  • Amblyopia usually arises when the two eyes give the young brain unequal input, and patching the good eye tilts the contest toward the weak eye.
  • Treatment generally works best in young children, though trials have found that some older children still improve.
  1. The layout

    AI-generated illustration: a schematic wiring diagram into the left hemisphere. The right eye, contralateral, is drawn in clay and the left eye, ipsilateral, in slate. Each eye's axons end in its own layers of the LGN. LGN axons end in layer 4 of primary visual cortex in alternating clay and slate stripes, one set for each eye. Gold binocular cells above and below layer 4 each receive input from one stripe of each eye.
    The two eyes' pathways stay apart through the LGN layers and the layer 4 stripes of primary visual cortex. Above and below layer 4, many cells combine the two eyes. These shared, binocular cells are what the eyes compete for. AI-generated illustration
  2. Measuring ocular dominance

  3. One closed eye

  4. Disuse or competition?

  5. Out of step

    AI-generated illustration: two panels. With aligned eyes, two inputs reach one cortical cell with their pulses in step. With strabismus, the pulses are out of step and two separate cells each receive only one eye's input.
    With aligned eyes, a moving edge excites both eyes' inputs to a shared cell at nearly the same moments. With misaligned eyes each eye can still send a similar amount of activity, but the two signals are unrelated. Most cells then answer to one eye or the other and few to both, while neither eye takes over. AI-generated illustration
  6. Silence is not the same as noise

  7. The window and the patch

  8. Putting it together

  9. Going deeper

Read the full lesson → Skim the whole course →