Developmental Neuroscience · Skim version

Seeing Neurons: Golgi, Cajal and the Neuron Doctrine

About 2 min to skim · 3 figures · Rewritten on

Read the full lesson → Skim the whole course →

The guiding idea

Are neurons separate cells that touch, or one fused network? The neuron doctrine says separate, and it took a new stain, a lot of embryos and the electron microscope to show it. Two men looked at the same stained brain and saw two different organs. Who was right, and how could anyone tell?

The nervous system is built of separate cells, neurons, that pass signals to one another across specialized contacts, and that is why development has to build connections between cells.

From the film: A Touch Is Not a Fusion

  • A touch is not a fusion: whether two touching branches are one cell or two is decided at the membrane where they meet.
  • Evidence that bears directly on that membrane, by seeing it or by testing what crosses it, can settle the question.
  • A gap of about 20 nanometres at a chemical synapse sits inside the light microscope's blur of about 200 nanometres, so touching and fused branches look alike.
  • In vertebrates, development has to wire separate cells to the right partners.

From the film: One Stain, Two Readings

  • Golgi's black reaction fills a few cells completely, so one neuron and its branches can be traced.
  • Sparse staining shows whose branch is whose, but it cannot show touch or fusion, because both partners are rarely stained and the gap is below what light can show.
  • Golgi read the tangle of axon branches as a continuous net, while Cajal read the free endings he kept finding as evidence of separate cells.
  • Embryo evidence and the direction of signal flow made separate cells more likely without settling the question.

From the film: The Gap, Seen

  • Electron micrographs of the chemical synapses examined in the 1950s showed two membranes staying separate across a cleft, which settled the question.
  • Electrical synapses join some neurons through gap junction channels, but each cell keeps its own membrane.
  • A small tracer can pass gap junctions to coupled neighbours while a large dextran stays in the injected cell, so coupling is not fusion.
  • A few animals really do have fused neurons, such as the squid giant axon and the comb jelly nerve net.
  1. Touch or fusion: a question about 20 nanometres

    AI-generated illustration: left, a light-microscope view of two black Golgi-stained branches meeting, their meeting point lost in one grey smudge. Right, the smudge zoomed to scale: a disc about 200 nanometres across, inside which an axon ending and a partner cell face each other across a gold gap about 20 nanometres wide, one tenth of the disc.
    The gap at a chemical synapse, about 20 nanometres, sits inside the light microscope's blur of about 200 nanometres, so touching and fused branches give the same smudge. No light-microscope image of one contact could settle the question. AI-generated illustration
  2. To see one cell, stain almost none

    AI-generated illustration: two panels of the same kind of tissue patch. A Nissl stain marks every cell body but leaves branches almost invisible; a Golgi stain fills a few separate neurons, showing cell body and many branches in black against a pale yellowish background. The Golgi cells are drawn as tidy examples; real processes are often cut off at the section edge.
    Nissl stain marks every cell body and nucleus but leaves axons and dendrites almost invisible. Golgi's black reaction fills a few cells, showing the cell body and many branches, though processes that leave the section are cut off. Why one neuron takes the stain and its neighbour does not is still unknown. AI-generated illustration
  3. One slide, two readings

  4. Evidence from development: fibres grow out of single cells

  5. The direct test: look at the membrane

  6. A pore is not a fusion

    AI-generated illustration: left, two cells each with its own membrane, joined by three small gap junction channels; the injected cell holds both a small tracer and large dextran beads, and only the small tracer has reached the neighbour. Right, a syncytium, one cell with three nuclei and one shared cytoplasm, where the large dextran has spread to the far end.
    Coupled neurons each keep their own membrane: a small tracer can pass through gap junction channels to a neighbour, but a large dextran stays in the injected cell. In a true syncytium, one shared cytoplasm, the large tracer would spread too. A touch is not a fusion, and neither is a pore. AI-generated illustration
  7. Putting it together

  8. Going deeper

Read the full lesson → Skim the whole course →