Developmental Neuroscience · Skim version

The Death Machinery in Neurons

About 3 min to skim · 3 figures · Rewritten on

Read the full lesson → Skim the whole course →

The guiding idea

Stop a starving neuron from making new proteins, and it lives longer. Why?

The killers of a developing neuron are already built, and a survival signal keeps brakes on them: one in the worm's core pathway, two in the NGF-dependent sympathetic neuron.

From the film: A Neuron Must Work to Die

  • A young sympathetic neuron deprived of NGF does not just run down, because it runs a program that needs new RNA and protein.
  • Stopping protein synthesis delays the death of deprived neurons.
  • Apoptosis shrinks the cell and condenses its chromatin, while necrosis spills the contents and inflames the tissue.

From the film: Cells Marked with an X

  • In the worm, the same named cells die in every animal, so a death can be screened for as a phenotype.
  • Loss of ced-3 or ced-4 saves doomed cells, while loss of ced-9 kills cells that should have lived.
  • If removing the killer cancels the effect of removing the brake, the brake works through the killer.

From the film: The Same Parts in Us

  • Each worm death protein has a mammalian counterpart: caspases, Bcl-2 family proteins and Apaf-1.
  • Bax is a gate in the outer mitochondrial membrane that the worm has no clear counterpart for.
  • The match is imperfect: Apaf-1 needs cytochrome c, and the worm brake holds CED-4 directly.

From the film: The First Brake: The Mitochondrial Gate

  • Brake 1 is a gate at the mitochondrion, and NGF loss opens it through new gene expression.
  • Loss of NGF raises c-Jun and BH3-only proteins such as Bim, which free Bax and let cytochrome c escape.
  • Without Bax the gate stays shut and the neuron survives, though as a shrunken cell.

From the film: The Second Brake: Competence to Die

  • Cytochrome c injected into neurons kept in NGF does not kill them, so the gate is not the only brake.
  • Brake 2 is XIAP on the caspases, and deprivation lifts it without any new protein.
  • A neuron dies by apoptosis only when the gate is open or skipped and the caspase brake is off.

From the film: Take the Machinery Away

  • Deleting caspase-3 or caspase-9 changes how these neurons die, not whether they die.
  • In Bax-dependent populations, caspases decide how and Bax decides whether.
  • Neurons saved by Bax deletion are not normal, and NGF is also needed for axons to grow into many targets.
  1. Two ways to die

  2. Cells marked with an X

  3. The same parts in us

    AI-generated illustration: two pathways in rows. Worm: EGL-1 blocks CED-9, which blocks CED-4, which activates CED-3, and the cell dies. Mammalian neuron: Bim blocks Bcl-2 and Bcl-xL, which block Bax; Bax leads to cytochrome c, then Apaf-1, caspase-9 and caspase-3, and the cell dies. Dotted lines join each worm protein to its counterpart, and a dashed box around Bax and cytochrome c is marked as having no clear worm counterpart.
    The worm's death genes have mammalian counterparts: EGL-1 and BH3-only proteins such as Bim release the brake, CED-9 and Bcl-2 are the brake, CED-4 and Apaf-1 gather the killer, and CED-3 and the caspases do the killing. The mammalian gate, Bax and the release of cytochrome c, has no clear worm counterpart. AI-generated illustration
  4. The first brake: from a lost signal to cytochrome c

  5. The second brake: competence to die

    AI-generated illustration: the cell body of a young sympathetic neuron in two states. With NGF present, a protective protein holds Bax shut, cytochrome c stays inside the mitochondrion, and XIAP clamps the caspases. With NGF removed, Bim sits on the protective protein, Bax is inserted in the mitochondrial outer membrane, cytochrome c streams out to a wheel-shaped apoptosome, the XIAP clamp is gone and the caspases are free.
    A young NGF-dependent sympathetic neuron has two brakes on apoptosis. Brake 1 is the mitochondrial gate, where protective BCL-2 proteins keep Bax shut until Bim opens it; brake 2 is XIAP on the caspases, which falls during deprivation. The neuron dies only when both are off. AI-generated illustration
  6. Cleaning up: the corpse sends a signal

    AI-generated illustration: a plasma membrane band shown first for a healthy cell with gold phosphatidylserine beads only on the inner face, then for a dying cell where caspases cut holding enzymes, a scramblase mixes the faces, and gold beads appear on the outside where a microglial receptor and an annexin V block bind them.
    A healthy cell keeps phosphatidylserine on the inner face of its membrane. In the cells where this has been studied, caspases cut the holding enzymes and switch on a scramblase, so phosphatidylserine appears outside as an "eat me" signal that phagocyte receptors, and the lab label annexin V, recognise. AI-generated illustration
  7. Take the machinery away

  8. Putting it together

  9. Going deeper

Read the full lesson → Skim the whole course →