Organismal Biology · Skim version

Size, Scale and Surface

About 2 min to skim · 2 figures · Rewritten on

Read the full lesson → Skim the whole course →

The guiding idea

A flatworm has no lungs and no heart. Why can't a mouse manage the same way?

When a body grows without changing shape, its middle ends up farther from its outer surface, and diffusion time grows with the square of that distance; in a simple model of a solid ball of tissue fed from air at its surface, oxygen runs out at the centre beyond a radius of about 1.5 mm for slow tissue and a few tenths of a millimetre for busy tissue, so bodies stay thin, add internal exchange surfaces or use bulk flow.

From the film: Why a Mouse Needs Plumbing

  • When a body grows without changing shape, its surface grows four times for every eight times its volume, so each bit of inside has less surface.
  • The inside also ends up farther from the surface, and diffusion is quick across a cell but slow across a body: twice the distance takes four times as long.
  • In a simple model of a solid ball of tissue fed from its surface, oxygen from air runs out at the centre once the radius passes about 1.5 mm for slow tissue, or a few tenths of a millimetre for busy tissue.
  • For the same shape fed only from outside, a bigger body means a longer path, so bodies stay thin, add inner surface or pump fluid; in thick, busy animals, bulk flow does most of the carrying and diffusion finishes the last few micrometres.

From the film: Does Every Gram Cost the Same?

  • Rubner found that bigger dogs make more heat in total but less heat per kilogram.
  • Metabolic rate is fitted as a constant times body mass to a power b, and b is positive but below 1 in most comparisons of adult mammals and birds: bigger burns more in total, but less per kilogram.
  • On the widely used fit with b = 3/4, a mouse burns about seven times as much per kilogram as a human: a fitted prediction, not a single measurement.
  • The exponent is a fitted number that changes with the animals, their state and the method, and its cause is still debated.
  1. A bigger cube has less skin per unit of inside

    AI-generated illustration: a small cube beside a larger cube built from eight small cubes in two layers of four, with the outer surfaces tinted gold and brackets showing the side of each. A small inset repeats the pair with an arrow between them.
    An ideal cell of side 20 um holds eight times the volume of one of side 10 um but only four times the outer surface, so the surface-area-to-volume ratio halves. These cubes are illustrative, not measured cells. AI-generated illustration
  2. Diffusion: fast over micrometres, slow over centimetres

  3. How deep can diffusion reach?

    AI-generated illustration: on the left a flat leaf-shaped planarian and a thin slab with arrows entering both faces, on the right a broad green leaf blade with a midrib and a similar thin slab. A small inset shows a round solid blob with arrows entering only at its surface and a gold dot at its centre.
    Flattening answers the surface problem in both kingdoms: in a planarian and in the lamina of a leaf, no cell is far from the outside. A compact, rounded body of the same material would leave its inside far from any surface. AI-generated illustration
  4. Four answers in two kingdoms

  5. Body mass and metabolism: Rubner, Kleiber and the debate

  6. Does a lower rate per kilogram rescue a big body?

  7. Going deeper

Read the full lesson → Skim the whole course →