Developmental Neuroscience · Skim version

Competition: How Neurons Win a Target

About 2 min to skim · 2 figures · Rewritten on

Read the full lesson → Skim the whole course →

The guiding idea

If the target makes too little NGF for every neuron, which neurons get to live?

In mouse sympathetic neurons, a limited supply of NGF sets roughly how many neurons survive, and the neurons' own feedback on NGF signaling decides which.

From the film: Too Little to Go Around

  • A limited NGF supply sets roughly how many sympathetic neurons survive.
  • Among otherwise alike neurons, a small lead can grow only if its signal rises faster than in proportion to the lead.
  • In the proposed model, the neurons' own feedback decides which ones survive, and winners speed the death of losers.

From the film: Why Sharing Fails

  • With proportional sharing, a small lead stays frozen, so feedback on receptor level alone does not make a winner.
  • A lead can grow only when the reward rises faster than the lead.
  • Arrival order alone cannot explain how a small lead grows while the target keeps releasing NGF.

From the film: The Bax Trick

  • Mice lacking Bax keep their sympathetic neurons with or without NGF, so ganglia can be compared.
  • NGF raises and maintains its own receptor, TrkA, in these neurons.
  • By the two-neuron arithmetic, the TrkA receptor loop alone is only half of the answer.

From the film: Only Both Loops Split Them

  • NGF also controls how long its own signal lasts; Coronin-1 is one mechanism, and there may be others.
  • In the published simulations, only feedback on both receptor level and signal duration split the neurons into winners and losers.
  • The lab described four stages: naive, sensitization, competitive advantage and selection.

From the film: Winners Push Losers

  • In the proposed model, well-supported neurons make BDNF and NT-4, which push weakly supported neighbours toward death through p75.
  • Strong TrkA signaling likely protects the winners by keeping survival pathways such as AKT high.
  • Without p75, the loss of neurons is delayed; whether any are permanently spared is less settled.

From the film: Same Factor, Second Job

  • In mice lacking both Bax and NGF, sympathetic neurons survive but innervation is missing from some targets, reduced in others and near normal in a few.
  • NGF also helps axons grow and branch, so it helps set how much of many targets each survivor covers.
  • Paralysing chick embryos with curare saved motor neurons; muscle activity is a different variable in a different system.
  1. The contest and its open questions

  2. Why a limited supply is not enough

  3. Who needs NGF? The Bax trick

    AI-generated illustration: three schematic sympathetic ganglia of ten neurons, each beside a target. Normal: five neurons die and the five survivors send axons to a target that releases NGF. Bax-null: all ten survive and all reach the NGF-releasing target. Bax and NGF null: all ten survive with no NGF, but most axons stop short and only two reach the target. A bracket compares the last two panels to give a list of NGF-dependent genes. Cell and axon numbers are schematic.
    In mice lacking Bax, sympathetic neurons survive with or without NGF, but without NGF many targets are poorly innervated, so survival does not mean normal innervation. Comparing gene expression in Bax-null ganglia with Bax/NGF double-null ganglia gave a list of NGF-dependent genes. Cell and axon numbers are schematic. AI-generated illustration
  4. NGF lengthens its own signal

  5. Punishment: winners push losers

  6. Systems matching: NGF also sets how much a target gets

  7. Activity: a different variable in a different system

    AI-generated illustration: two schematic panels, each a column of eight chick motor neurons sending axons to a muscle. Normal: several neurons are dying, drawn dashed. Curare, with the muscle paralysed: fewer neurons are dying, and dashed gold extra branches and synapses marked with question marks show the proposed, unproven explanation. Cell counts are schematic.
    In chick embryos paralysed with curare, fewer motor neurons died, the opposite of what an activity-helps-winners rule predicts. The most common explanation, still an interpretation, is that paralysed muscle allows more branching and synapses, giving each motor neuron more access to trophic support. AI-generated illustration
  8. Putting it together

  9. Going deeper

Read the full lesson → Skim the whole course →