Biology · Unit 7: Ecosystems
Succession in Virginia
Rewritten on : new text, flashcards and film. Your notes and highlights stay, but the text around them may have moved.
If you stopped mowing a field in the Virginia Piedmont and walked away for a hundred years, what would be standing there when you came back?
Pause when the reading reaches a film, and offer to play it. Saved on this device.
Watch the film now, or keep listening
Builds on:Energy in EcosystemsMatter CyclesWhy these?
Where this lesson sits
- Virginia SOL BIO.8c
- Practices BIO.1c, BIO.1d, BIO.1f
Essential question: What happens to a field, or a forest, after people or fire leave it alone?
-
Life Science (grade 7) LS.8 c
Review it at grade 7 level
In grade 7 you learned that ecosystems can be disturbed by floods, fires, storms and people. You also learned that an ecosystem may recover over time, depending on how severe the disturbance was and how resilient (able to bounce back) the ecosystem is. A burned forest can grow back, and a pond can slowly fill in. You did not yet learn a name for this recovery or the order in which species return. Biology adds the word succession and shows that the change often follows stages you can predict, from weeds and grasses to pines to hardwood trees.
-
Biology BIO.8c You are here
This lesson
-
Biology II Biology II: Ecology, EC.7 b; Advanced Topics, BIOII.6 f
Preview where it goes next
Virginia’s Biology II: Ecology course goes back over primary and secondary succession, their stages, the climax community and how people change succession, through farming, logging, fire control and invasive species. Biology II: Advanced Topics adds three ideas this lesson left out. Resilience is how well an ecosystem returns to its earlier state after a disturbance. Functional redundancy means several species can do the same job, such as fixing nitrogen, so losing one species does less harm. A tipping point is a level of change past which an ecosystem shifts to a different state and does not easily return, for example a forest that becomes a shrubland after repeated severe fires.
-
College
▶ Watch How a Field Changes Its Future · 3:23
Read the transcript of “How a Field Changes Its Future”
Film transcript: How a Field Changes Its Future
If mowing stops, why does a sunny field not stay a field? Watch one Virginia Piedmont field. The mower leaves. Seeds already in soil stir, while others arrive by wind or birds. Many populations live here together, forming a community. Ecological succession is change, over years to centuries, in which species live in an area. It often follows a general pattern, but not a fixed schedule. Weeds and grasses grow quickly in the open field. Broomsedge and blackberry rise above shorter plants.
Pine seedlings appear where seed trees are nearby. Their crowns climb into the bright space, and the sunny field begins changing its own future. The pines grow taller and their crowns join. A canopy now blocks much of the sunlight. Near the ground, the light meter falls. New pine seedlings grow poorly there. Some young hardwoods cope with shade better and survive below. Two seedlings now stand under the same canopy. One is pine and one is hardwood. Which is more likely to persist in the shade? Make your prediction.
The pine seedling lags, while the hardwood survives. Later, an old pine dies and opens a bright gap. The hardwood grows faster into that space. No plant planned this change. Growth altered conditions, changing which plants survived well. Organisms change conditions, so suited species can become more common. Here, pine growth changed light. In other places, plants also change soil. The pattern comes from survival and growth, not from a goal or a finish line. Now compare two starting surfaces. An abandoned field still has soil, nutrients, seeds, and roots. This begins secondary succession. Bare rock has no soil.
Primary succession begins there, with pioneer species that can start building soil. On bare rock, the pioneers are usually lichens and mosses. Glacial gravel can begin with other hardy plants. Soil develops slowly before many rooted plants can establish. Starting with soil is why secondary succession usually reaches forest faster. Back in the old field, pines may give way to hardwoods as light changes. In most of Virginia, the older model names oak-hickory forest as the late stage. Yet nearby seeds, soil, climate, and disturbance can change the route and timing. Follow the changing conditions, not only the plant names. That move explains why one stage can favor another.
It also keeps a common path from becoming a promise about every field.
From the film
- Organisms change conditions, so suited species can become more common.
- Ecological succession is change over years to centuries in the species living in an area.
- Secondary succession starts with soil, while primary succession starts without it.
- The old-field path is a tendency, not one fixed timetable for every place.
The first film built one path from field to forest. Now test where that path holds.
- ecological succession
- community
- disturbance
- primary succession
- secondary succession
- pioneer species
- abiotic factors
- biotic factors
- climax community
- biodiversity
A community is all the populations of different species living in one area. Ecological succession is the change, over years to centuries, in which species live there. The change often follows a general pattern: some plants tend to come early and others late.
What do you think? Decide before you read.
-
Scientists disagree: Ecologists mark plots and come back to the same spot years later. At Glacier Bay, Alaska, plots marked in the early 1900s have been resurveyed, and the plants in them kept changing. Even an old forest loses trees to storms and gains new ones in the gaps.
What scientists think
Scientists disagree: Ecologists mark plots and come back to the same spot years later. At Glacier Bay, Alaska, plots marked in the early 1900s have been resurveyed, and the plants in them kept changing. Even an old forest loses trees to storms and gains new ones in the gaps.
-
Scientists disagree: The late stage depends on climate, soil, nearby seeds and how often disturbances strike. In most of Virginia it has usually been oak-hickory forest, but at Glacier Bay many sites become spruce forest. Resurveys there found that some plots have stayed willow or alder thickets for many decades, held there by the plants that arrived first.
What scientists think
Scientists disagree: The late stage depends on climate, soil, nearby seeds and how often disturbances strike. In most of Virginia it has usually been oak-hickory forest, but at Glacier Bay many sites become spruce forest. Resurveys there found that some plots have stayed willow or alder thickets for many decades, held there by the plants that arrived first.
-
Scientists disagree: In a North Carolina experiment, young oak saplings became more common where cutting plus fire opened the forest; the details come later in this lesson. Fire can also do harm, so ecologists ask which fire, how often, and for which species.
What scientists think
Scientists disagree: In a North Carolina experiment, young oak saplings became more common where cutting plus fire opened the forest; the details come later in this lesson. Fire can also do harm, so ecologists ask which fire, how often, and for which species.
Explore: run a field through the decades
The simulation shows a plot from above. Choose bare rock, an abandoned field or a burned forest, then step forward a decade at a time. A button burns or clears half the plot.
In this sketch an abandoned field follows the lesson’s Piedmont old-field summary (a regional summary with no dates). A burned forest and a cleared patch borrow the old-field timeline; the lesson gives none for them, so a real burned forest may differ. Bare rock follows one Glacier Bay plot (Q2) plus park estimates; other plots and places differ. The alder at about 80 years (park estimate) and the Q2 spruce at 81 years are separate estimates. Light and soil are relative levels, not measurements. Nothing is random.
Rule to keep: each stage changes the light and the soil, and those changes favor the next group of plants. A disturbance that leaves the soil restarts secondary succession.
Try this.
- Start with an abandoned field. Predict which plant group will cover the most ground after 10 years and after 100 years, then step forward and check.
- Start with bare rock instead. Predict whether it will reach forest sooner or later than the field did. Test it and count the decades.
- Watch the light and soil readings as you step. Which one changes first, and which plant group seems to follow it?
Predict 1. Let the field reach forest, then burn or clear only half. Predict what grows first there, and whether that half’s soil reading drops to the bare-rock level or stays where it was. Then test it.
What the starting surface changes
Succession often starts after a disturbance, an event such as fire, flood, storm or plowing that removes much of a community. What remains helps decide which kind of succession follows.
Primary succession is succession on bare rock or new land where there is no soil. Bare rock, sand and silt left by a melting glacier and fresh lava are examples. The first organisms there are pioneer species. On bare rock they are usually lichens and mosses. They help break down the rock, and when they die they add the first thin layer of soil. On the gravel and silt a glacier leaves, hardy plants such as Dryas also come early, and plants such as alder add nitrogen to the poor new soil.
Secondary succession is succession after a disturbance that leaves the soil in place. Examples are an abandoned farm field, a burned forest and a flooded meadow, where the soil still holds nutrients, seeds and roots.
| Primary succession | Secondary succession | |
|---|---|---|
| Starting point | Bare rock or new land, no soil | Soil remains after a disturbance |
| Virginia or nearby example | Bare rock outcrops and landslide scars; a glacier’s retreat in Alaska | Abandoned Piedmont field, burned forest |
| First arrivals | Lichens and mosses on rock; hardy plants on glacial gravel | Weeds, grasses, seeds already in the soil |
| Speed | Usually centuries | Usually decades to a century or more |
- pioneer species
- soil
- pines
- climax community
- disturbance
- blank
- soil
- pines
- blank
- blank
Word bank: climax community, disturbance, pioneer species
- blank
- blank
- blank
- blank
- blank
Check your labels
- pioneer species
- soil
- pines
- climax community
- disturbance
How a Virginia field can become a forest
Abiotic factors are nonliving parts of an ecosystem, such as light, water, temperature and soil. Biotic factors are living parts, such as plants, animals, fungi and microbes. Plants change abiotic factors by growing and dying. Those changes can help later plants, while plants already present can also hold newcomers back.
The first film followed the biggest change in an old field: shade under a closing pine canopy. It left out the timing. Here is the usual path published for old Piedmont fields just south of Virginia.
- The first years. Weeds such as horseweed and asters grow fast in full sun. By about the third year, broomsedge, a tall grass, often covers the field.
- Pines move in. Where seed trees grow nearby, pine seedlings and blackberry appear after about five years. Pines grow fast in full sun, and within a few decades the field becomes a young pine forest.
- Shade builds. Under the closed pine canopy, young hardwoods grow slowly. The most shade-tolerant trees, such as red maple, do best there. Oaks and hickories can survive some shade, but they grow best where a gap lets in light.
- Hardwoods take over. As the old pines die over the next several decades, the hardwoods below fill the gaps. After a century or more, hardwoods dominate, and one Virginia source puts a mostly hardwood forest at about 200 years.
Predict 2. The summary says pines begin arriving during years 3 to 18, but a young pine forest dominates during years 19 to 30. Why are those not the same event?
Check your prediction
The 3-to-18-year row is when pines are coming in; the 19-to-30-year row is a young pine forest. Pines appear first and take years to grow tall enough to dominate. This summary does not record the first seedling in any dated field.
The climax community is the late stage that the model predicts will stay fairly stable without a major disturbance. For most of Virginia, the model names deciduous oak-hickory forest. A USDA Forest Service inventory estimated that in 2021 the oak-hickory forest type covered about 61 percent of Virginia’s forest land, and loblolly-shortleaf pine about 19 percent. Being common today does not make oak-hickory a fixed endpoint. In many eastern forests left without fire, red maple and other shade-tolerant trees are replacing oaks because young oaks need more light than a closed canopy provides.
If young oaks need gaps and red maple does not, what opens the canopy? The second film turns from one field to the disturbances that open gaps across a landscape.
Read the transcript of “Why Succession Stays Open”
Film transcript: Why Succession Stays Open
The first film followed plants changing the conditions around them. Why does a whole landscape rarely settle into one single final stage? Pull back from that field until the whole Virginia landscape fills the frame. Different patches carry different histories. A storm opens one canopy gap. Floodwater covers another patch. Fire crosses a third. People keep mowing one field. Each disturbance removes organisms differently, and each leaves different soil, roots, and seeds. Compare an unbroken canopy with the new storm gap. Which patch will receive more light at ground level? Watch the two light meters, then make your prediction.
The gap meter rises. Saplings already waiting below grow faster in the bright opening, while older trees remain around it. The forest now holds stages side by side. A disturbance can redirect part of succession without resetting the whole landscape. Storms, insects, floods, fires, and people keep making new starting points. Some patches change quickly. Others remain similar for decades.
Together they form a moving patchwork, not one community marching toward a shared finish line. Older models called a fairly stable late stage the climax community. For most of Virginia, that model names oak-hickory forest. It remains useful as a prediction. It is not a claim that forests stop changing. Without fire, shade-tolerant red maple can replace oaks in many eastern stands. Elsewhere, disturbance may favor certain species. The result depends on the disturbance, nearby organisms, and the conditions that remain. How can ecologists tell whether a path is common? One source presents a regional summary. It sketches the usual Piedmont route from old field to forest.
That summary gives a pattern, not one field's dated history. Another source marks one permanent plot and returns to the exact place. At Glacier Bay, resurveys found that plots did not share one timetable. Early arrivals sometimes held later plants back. One plot gives detail, not a universal schedule. Use each source for the claim it can support. A regional summary describes a broad tendency. A dated plot tests what happened at one place. Agreement can strengthen the model.
Differences reveal where its scope must narrow. Succession also changes biodiversity, the variety of living things in an area. A species count can rise or fall between stages. Scientists must name the measure and the patch they sampled before comparing results. Do not ask only, What stage comes next? Ask what changed, what remained, and what evidence tracks the change. This connects succession to causes while leaving room for different routes.
From the film
- Disturbance can redirect succession, leaving a patchwork of stages.
- A climax community is a model of a fairly stable late stage, not a finish line.
- The result depends on the disturbance, nearby organisms and conditions that remain.
- A regional summary and one dated plot support different strengths of claim.
Disturbance keeps the story open
The second film did not say whether fire by itself helps young oaks. A North Carolina experiment gave forest plots no change, cutting, fire alone, or cutting plus fire.
Predict 3. If fire by itself helped young oaks, what should the fire-alone plots show compared with the untreated plots? Read the result below and check.
Disturbance is not always harmful. Only cutting plus fire reduced the total trunk area of the big trees, and young oak saplings were more common where the most was lost. Fire alone did not. The smallest oak seedlings showed no clear treatment difference, so the effect depended on treatment and plant size.
Succession also changes biodiversity, the variety of living things in an area. A species count can rise or fall from stage to stage (the second film), so scientists say which measure they used.
Two timelines, two kinds of evidence
The second film contrasted a regional summary with one dated plot. The table puts numbers on both: a published summary for old fields in the North Carolina Piedmont, and records from one plot at a glacier. The last column names each row’s kind of evidence.
| Place and kind of succession | Years after the start (years) | What dominates or first appears | Kind of evidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| Piedmont old field (secondary) | 1 | Horseweed | Regional summary |
| Piedmont old field (secondary) | 2 | Asters | Regional summary |
| Piedmont old field (secondary) | 3 to 18 | Broomsedge; pines arriving | Regional summary |
| Piedmont old field (secondary) | 19 to 30 | Young pine forest | Regional summary |
| Piedmont old field (secondary) | 30 to 70 | Mature pines over young hardwoods | Regional summary |
| Piedmont old field (secondary) | 70 to 100 | Pines giving way to hardwoods | Regional summary |
| Piedmont old field (secondary) | more than 100 | Oak-hickory forest | Regional summary |
| Glacier Bay plot Q2, Alaska (primary) | 0 (year 1879) | Bare ground left by the ice | Dated record, one plot |
| Glacier Bay plot Q2, Alaska (primary) | 81 (year 1960) | Oldest spruce found there began growing | Tree-age estimate, one plot |
| Glacier Bay, park narrative (primary) | about 80 | Alder shades the ground | Park estimate, not measured |
| Glacier Bay, park narrative (primary) | about 200 | Sitka spruce forest | Park estimate, not measured |
Sources: rows 1 to 7, Duke Forest (Duke University), forest succession page, a summary for the North Carolina Piedmont that gives no observation dates or field names; rows 8 and 9, Buma and colleagues, Ecology (2019), Cooper plot Q2 in the West Arm of Glacier Bay, the only one of eight plots that became spruce-dominated and never had alder (across the plots, the oldest spruce dates ran from 1949 to 1982, and one plot had none); rows 10 and 11, National Park Service, plant succession in Glacier Bay page (updated 2021), a general story that the dated plots do not all follow.
Predict 4. At plot Q2, calculate the elapsed time before the oldest spruce found there began growing. Write the subtraction before checking the CER model.
Predict 5. Plot Q2 was the only one of eight plots to become spruce-dominated without ever having alder. What claim about all of Glacier Bay can Q2 not support?
Check your prediction
Q2 cannot show that Glacier Bay plots usually get spruce at about 81 years, or that spruce follows alder there. It supports a narrow claim about one dated place.
Then answer three questions.
- In the old field, about how many years after abandonment do pines begin arriving, and about when do hardwoods take over?
- Why might an old field’s first pines arrive much sooner than spruce on bare ground?
- Which rows come from one dated place, and which are a summary or an illustration? Why does that matter for how much you trust each row?
Claim, evidence, reasoning
Make a claim that answers the essential question: what happens to a field, or bare ground, after people or ice leave it alone? Use the table.
Start with: After the disturbance ends, the plants that live there blank, and the change is faster when blank.
Start with: In the old field, pines arrive by about year blank and hardwoods take over after about blank years, while at Glacier Bay plot Q2 the oldest spruce found there began growing after blank years.
Start with: This happens because each stage changes abiotic factors such as blank and blank, and an old field starts with blank that bare ground lacks.
Compare with a model answer
After a disturbance ends, the plants that live in a place change in a general order, and the change is faster when soil is already present. In the Piedmont summary, pines arrive in years 3 to 18 and hardwoods take over after about 100 years. At Glacier Bay plot Q2, the oldest spruce found there began growing about 81 years after the ice left. Each stage changes light and soil, and the old field starts with soil and seeds that bare rock lacks. One limit is that the old-field rows are a regional summary with no dates, and the Glacier Bay rows come from a single plot, so other places may follow other schedules. The two places also differ in climate and tree species, so this comparison alone cannot show that soil is the cause.
Saved in this browser only.
Design problem
The first film showed pine seedlings growing poorly in shade, while young hardwoods cope better. Plan a fair test of whether shade slows the growth of pine seedlings more than oak seedlings, using seedlings in pots, shade cloth and a ruler.
Saved in this browser only.
One way to do it
- Question and hypothesis: If seedlings grow under shade cloth, then pine seedlings will grow less than in full sun, and oak seedlings will be slowed less, because pines need bright light.
- Independent variables: light (full sun or shade cloth) and kind of seedling (pine or oak).
- Dependent variable: increase in height, in centimeters, after 8 weeks.
- Constants: the same pot size, the same soil from one bag, the same water on the same schedule, seedlings of similar starting height, the same place outdoors.
- Control: the seedlings in full sun are the comparison group for each kind of tree.
- Repeated trials and sample size: at least 10 seedlings in each of the four groups, with the mean height gain calculated for each group.
- Safety and ethics: buy seedlings from a nursery instead of digging them from the wild, wear gloves for soil, and plant the seedlings out afterward.
Bigger gains in sun than in shade, with a larger drop for pines, would support the hypothesis. Height is one measure; weighing each seedling after drying it (its dry mass) would make the test stronger.
Evaluate: check your thinking
When mowing stops in a Piedmont field, secondary succession runs from weeds and broomsedge to pines to hardwoods. Oak-hickory is the model’s climax community in most of Virginia, but without fire red maple can replace oaks. Remember the rule: organisms change conditions, so suited species can become more common; disturbance can redirect succession, leaving a patchwork of stages.
Science practices you used: making predictions with a model and testing them, reading a table that mixes measured and summarized data, judging how strong each kind of evidence is, and planning a fair test with a control and repeated trials.
Your notes
Select any text in the lesson to highlight it or add a note to it. Your highlights and notes are saved in this browser and collected in your notebook.
This browser is not letting the site save anything (a private window or strict privacy settings), so highlights and notes will be lost when you leave the page.
How we measure it
Permanent-plot resurvey
Ecologists mark a plot so that they, or later scientists, can find the exact spot again and record what grows there years or decades later. Comparing the same place over time tests a succession timeline directly instead of guessing it from sites of different ages.
Quadrat survey
A quadrat is a small square frame laid on the ground, and every plant inside it is counted and identified. Using the same number and size of squares in each field lets you compare how many kinds of plants two fields hold.
Statewide forest inventory
The USDA Forest Service visits thousands of sample points across a state and records the trees at each one. From those samples it estimates what share of the state's forest land belongs to each forest type, such as oak-hickory or pine.
Where this lesson fits
Before thisReview first
- Energy in EcosystemsThis course · Lesson 30
You need the idea that producers like plants capture sunlight, and why light drives which plants thrive in shade.
- Matter CyclesThis course · Lesson 31
Soil nutrients and nitrogen built up by early plants feed later stages, using the cycling idea from there.
After thisStudy next
- The Chesapeake Under PressureThis course · Lesson 33
It uses disturbance and changed conditions to explain how a landscape shifts and recovers, as in this lesson.
Elsewhere on the siteFilms, simulations and method films in other courses
- Bring the eagles backSimulation · Life Science
Bringing eagles back shows how an ecosystem recovers after a disturbance is removed, as in succession.
- What Let the Eagles Return?Film · Life Science
It shows an ecosystem recovering after harm is removed, like recovery after a disturbance.
Suggested by an AI model from the lessons themselves, then checked. How we use AI
Finish line
Test yourself
8 questions
Practice and MCAT-style, with explained answers.
Next · Lesson 33
The Chesapeake Under Pressure
How can fertilizer spread on a field far upstream leave crabs and fish short of oxygen at the bottom of the Chesapeake Bay?
Continue →