Developmental Neuroscience · Skim version

Proneural Genes and Lateral Inhibition

About 3 min to skim · 3 figures · Rewritten on

Read the full lesson → Skim the whole course →

The guiding idea

Every cell in the cluster could become the neuron. Why does only one?

In the fly, proneural factors say which cells may become neural and Notch says which one does, by comparing each cell with its neighbours.

From the film: Equal Cells, One Winner

  • In the fly, proneural genes make a group of cells able to become neural, and Notch signaling then picks which one does.
  • Notch does not place the clusters; it narrows them, so placing a cluster and picking a cell within it are separate events.
  • The same logic applies on three maps: the fly embryo's ectoderm, the fly notum and the vertebrate neural tube.

From the film: The Casting Call

  • Proneural genes such as achaete and scute make cells in a cluster able to become neural: remove them and bristles are missing, and switch them on in extra places and extra bristles form.
  • Different proneural genes tend to start different kinds of sense organ: achaete-scute mostly external ones, atonal mostly chordotonal organs.
  • Proneural proteins are basic helix-loop-helix transcription factors that work as a pair with a partner, Daughterless in the fly and E proteins in vertebrates.
  • In the embryo regulatory DNA places the clusters, so proneural factors say who may become neural and Notch says who does.

From the film: The Loop, One Arrow at a Time

  • Delta on one cell activates Notch on its neighbour, which turns on Enhancer of split repressors that switch off proneural genes.
  • Each cell inhibits its neighbour, so A inhibits the cell that inhibits A; two inhibitions in a row act as positive feedback, and a small lead can grow.
  • In an idealised pair, with no Notch in either cell both become neural, and with Notch switched on in both neither does.

From the film: When Does the Tie Break?

  • Between two equal cells the tie breaks only if the loop is steep, so that a small difference comes back round the loop larger than it left.
  • On a steep loop the pair is bistable, with two stable outcomes and an unstable even state; on a shallow loop the pair settles back to even.
  • In a model sheet, touching-neighbour inhibition spaces winners, with about one cell in three winning, and does not by itself guarantee one winner per cluster.

From the film: Neighbours Compare

  • Fly embryos lacking Notch or Delta make far too many neuroblasts and too little epidermis, so these genes are called neurogenic.
  • In fly mosaics, cells mutant for Notch became neural on their own but cells mutant for Delta did not, so losing the receptor and losing the ligand are not the same.
  • In these mosaics, a cell's fate depended on its Notch activity relative to the cells beside it.

From the film: Vertebrates: a Brake, a Clock and Identity

  • In the vertebrate neural tube, Notch-Hes lateral inhibition works as a brake on how fast progenitors are used up, because a cell held back stays a dividing progenitor.
  • Hes1 oscillates in cultured cells and in mouse neural progenitors; in culture, steady Ascl1 pushed cells toward neurons while oscillating Ascl1 kept them dividing.
  • The Ascl1 and Neurog2 swaps in mouse forebrain were not mirror images, so a proneural factor carries part of a neuron's identity and the tissue and the cell's history shape the rest.
  1. The layout

    AI-generated illustration: three panels. In a cross-section of fly embryo ectoderm, one cell of a proneural cluster has moved inward as a neuroblast while its neighbours stay in the sheet as epidermis. In a top-down honeycomb of fly notum cells, one cell of a cluster carries a bristle as the sensory organ precursor. In a cross-section of the vertebrate neural tube, elongated progenitors line the wall and one cell leaves as a new neuron.
    Three maps carry the arguments in this lesson: the fly embryo's ectoderm, where one cell of a cluster moves inward as a neuroblast; the fly notum, where one cell of a cluster becomes the precursor of a bristle; and the vertebrate neural tube, where the cells are already neural. AI-generated illustration
  2. Step 1: a cluster becomes competent

  3. Step 2: one cell is picked

  4. When does the tie break? The loop must be steep

  5. The evidence: neighbours compare

    AI-generated illustration: three separate fly mosaic comparisons, each showing three adjacent cells. A ball on a stick marks Delta and a crescent marks Notch where two cells meet. A Notch-mutant middle cell beside normal neighbours adopts neural fate. A Delta-mutant middle cell beside normal neighbours does not autonomously adopt neural fate. A normal middle cell beside neighbours with lower Notch activity than its own adopts epidermal fate; the neighbours' smaller, paler crescents mark their lower Notch.
    Key: the ball on a stick is Delta and the crescent is Notch. In fly mosaics, Notch-mutant cells adopt neural fate autonomously beside normal cells, whereas Delta-mutant cells do not. A normal cell beside neighbours with lower Notch activity than its own adopts epidermal fate. These comparisons show that relative Notch activity influences fate in these mosaics (Heitzler and Simpson, 1991). AI-generated illustration
  6. Vertebrates: a brake and a clock

  7. Do proneural genes carry identity? The Ascl1 and Neurog2 swap

    AI-generated illustration: two schematic half-sections of the embryonic mouse forebrain, dorsal up, each a curved wall with a ventral swelling. With Ascl1 made in dorsal cells, a few cells of the dorsal wall take on ventral colouring. With Neurog2 made in ventral cells, the swelling makes neurons but stays ventral.
    The two swaps were not mirror images. Ascl1 made in dorsal cells switched on a subset of ventral markers there, while Neurog2 made in ventral cells restored neuron production and the ventral markers without switching on dorsal ones. AI-generated illustration
  8. Putting it together

  9. Going deeper

Read the full lesson → Skim the whole course →