Developmental Neuroscience · Skim version

Neural Induction: The Default Model

About 2 min to skim · 2 figures · Rewritten on

Read the full lesson → Skim the whole course →

The guiding idea

Pull a square of frog skin-to-be apart into single cells, and it becomes neural. Why? Because BMP signaling, which makes skin, falls in those cells. In the embryo, the organizer's secreted proteins make it fall.

BMP says skin: in early frog animal caps, turning its signal down far enough lets competent cells become neural, provided their other required inputs, including early FGF signaling, are intact.

From the film: The Map and the Question

  • Ectoderm can become skin or nervous system, and an animal cap left intact becomes epidermis.
  • BMP says skin: in early frog animal caps, turning its signal down far enough lets competent cells become neural, provided other needed inputs such as FGF are intact.
  • BMP's effect comes down to one dial, the activity of Smad1 in the nucleus.

From the film: Break the Receptor, Add the Ligand

  • In frog animal caps, jamming a receptor with a dominant-negative copy makes neural tissue, with no mesoderm detected that could have induced it.
  • Blocking a receptor, not adding a signal, made neural tissue.
  • Adding BMP4 protein back to separated cap cells restores epidermis and keeps neural genes off.

From the film: One Dial

  • In these four cap conditions, where Smad1 output was high the cells made skin, and where it was low they made neural tissue.
  • Separated cells still have signaling BMP receptors, but MAPK activity can damp Smad1, so dilution is probably not the reason they turn neural.
  • The rule names the dial, Smad1 in the nucleus, and not BMP in the fluid.

From the film: The Organizer's Catchers

  • The organizer makes at least three proteins that catch BMP outside the cell: Noggin, Chordin and Follistatin.
  • Noggin protein turns intact caps neural, with anterior markers, without dorsal mesoderm.
  • In Xenopus tropicalis embryos, depleting all three catchers lost the neural plate, so the frog embryo needs them; early FGF signaling is needed too.

From the film: A Fly Turned Over

  • The fly's Dpp and Sog are the counterparts of the frog's BMP4 and Chordin, and frog Chordin works in the fly and fly Sog in the frog.
  • In both animals, nervous system forms where the antagonist keeps the BMP signal low.
  • The fly's map is inverted relative to the frog's: Dpp is dorsal and the nerve cord forms ventrally.

From the film: Where the Rule Stops

  • The rule says neural, not where: Noggin-treated caps made only anterior markers.
  • In chick, Chordin outside the future neural plate did not induce early neural markers, so lowering BMP is not enough on its own there; early FGF signaling and Wnt state matter.
  • In mouse, embryos lacking both chordin and noggin still form neural tissue but have severe forebrain defects.
  1. The layout

  2. Three cap experiments

  3. One dial

  4. The organizer’s catchers

  5. The same contest in a fly, upside down

    AI-generated illustration: two simplified dorsal-to-ventral bars compare frog and fly. In the frog, BMP4 signaling is high ventrally, Chordin is dorsal and the neural tube forms dorsally; in the fly, Dpp is dorsal, Sog is made in the ventral half (ventrolateral neuroectoderm, not the ventral-most mesoderm) and the nerve cord forms ventrally, so the arrangement is inverted. The bars are schematic.
    The fly's Dpp and Sog are the counterparts of the frog's BMP4 and Chordin, but their sides are swapped. In the vertebrate, BMP4 signaling is high ventrally and the neural tube forms dorsally; in the fly, Sog in ventrolateral neuroectoderm keeps Dpp signaling low, and this ectoderm gives rise to the ventral nerve cord. The drawing is simplified: the ventral-most fly cells are mesoderm. AI-generated illustration
  6. Where the rule stops

  7. Putting it together

  8. Going deeper

    AI-generated illustration: along a flat row of ectoderm cells running from dorsal on the left to ventral on the right, Chordin made at the organizer binds BMP and carries it away; a Tolloid-family protease cuts Chordin far from the organizer and releases BMP, which collects on the ventral cells.
    In the model, a Chordin-BMP complex travels farther than free BMP. Where a Tolloid-family protease cuts Chordin the BMP is set free, piling up on the ventral side while signaling stays low dorsally. AI-generated illustration

Read the full lesson → Skim the whole course →