Biochemistry · Skim version

Vitalism: How Chemistry Captured Life

About 1 min to skim · 3 figures · Rewritten on

Read the full lesson → Skim the whole course →

The guiding idea

Before biochemistry could begin, one idea had to die — this is its seventy-year retreat.

Before biochemistry could begin, one idea had to die: that the molecules of life can only be made by life.

From the film

  • Vitalists claimed that life's chemistry required a special vital force.
  • Wöhler made urea without a body, but his starting materials left a loophole.
  • Kolbe narrowed that loophole using materials chemists counted as lifeless.
  • Buchner's filter and antiseptic showed yeast fermentation needed no living cell.
  • Testing a claim that chemistry needs life requires proving life is gone.
  1. The wall

  2. Wöhler’s flask, 1828

  3. Kolbe narrows the loophole, 1845

    AI-generated illustration: two production chains, one above the other. In Wöhler's 1828 chain, blood, horn and hoof, circled in gold, are heated in a crucible beside potash and iron filings, giving a jar of cyanate salt and then a flask of urea crystals. In Kolbe's 1845 chain, charcoal and sulfur, circled in green, pass through a red-hot furnace tube and three flasks to a flask wired to a stacked-plate battery, ending in a flask of acetic acid, with nothing living anywhere.
    Where each chain begins. Wöhler's cyanate traced back to blood and horn, so a skeptic could say life was still in the starting materials. Kolbe started from charcoal and sulfur, which chemists then counted as elements (charcoal is usually made from wood), and finished with a battery. That made the provenance objection hard to sustain. AI-generated illustration
  4. Berthelot’s fats, 1854

  5. The last redoubt: fermentation

    AI-generated illustration: two identical flasks of grape juice on a bench. The left flask, kept free of yeast, has a cotton plug; a zoom shows yeast cells caught in the cotton while air passes through, and its juice is still. The right flask has an open neck, yeast cells drift in, and its juice is full of yeast and bubbles under a layer of foam.
    Pasteur showed that sterile grape juice kept free of yeast stayed inert, while juice that yeast could reach foamed into alcohol: fermentation appeared only alongside living yeast. (Keeping out yeast, not keeping out air, is what stopped it; yeast ferments without air.) AI-generated illustration
  6. Buchner’s flask, 1896–97

    AI-generated illustration: brewer's yeast is ground with sand in a mortar, squeezed in a screw press into a clear yellowish juice, and the juice with added sugar gives off a stream of bubbles. Under the title Controls, two more flasks of juice still bubble: one under a funnel whose filter holds back the yeast cells, and one with chloroform dripping in from a bottle.
    Buchner's press juice, 1896. Yeast ground with sand and pressed gave a juice with almost no intact cells, and sugar added to it fermented. Juice passed through a sterile filter that holds back every cell still fermented, and so did juice saturated with chloroform, an antiseptic. Those two controls are what showed no living cell was needed. AI-generated illustration
  7. The retreat in one table

  8. Why this is Chapter Zero

  9. Going deeper

Read the full lesson → Skim the whole course →