Developmental Neuroscience · Skim version

Sensitive Periods in Behavior: Song, Language and Sight

About 2 min to skim · 3 figures · Rewritten on

Read the full lesson → Skim the whole course →

The guiding idea

A young songbird that never hears an adult sing grows up singing a simple, abnormal song. Why can't it catch up later?

The same experience can have a lasting effect at one age and little effect at another.

From the film: One Input, Many Ages

  • The same experience can leave a strong, lasting mark at one age and little mark at another.
  • In white-crowned sparrows, song heard early is copied well months later, while recordings played to older birds had little effect.
  • To define a window, measure what lasts against the age at which the input was given.

From the film: Who Closes the Window?

  • In zebra finches, hearing a tutor seems to help close the window, though later studies gave mixed results.
  • Missing input delays the closing of the window but does not abolish it.
  • NMDA receptors in the anterior forebrain are needed while the song is memorized, but where the memory is stored is not shown.

From the film: What Lasts Is Not What Can Be Learned

  • Delayed access to a first language does affect later proficiency, and missing early language, not only age, seems to leave a lasting mark.
  • In second-language grammar, scores fall steadily with later age of arrival from childhood, a graded outcome rather than a sudden step.
  • What lasts can start to fall before the ability to learn does, so a curve of what lasts is not a curve of learning ability.
  • Different visual abilities have separate sensitive periods.
  1. Song: listen first, practice later

    AI-generated illustration: a three-step strip of a young songbird. In the sensory phase it listens to a singing adult and holds the song in memory; in the sensorimotor phase it sings and hears its own voice, comparing it with that memory; as an adult it sings a song that matches. An inset shows a bird deafened before practice singing an abnormal song.
    Song learning splits into a sensory phase, when the bird memorises a template, and a sensorimotor phase, when it practises and corrects itself. A bird deafened before practice sings abnormally even though it heard a tutor: it must hear itself. AI-generated illustration
  2. How sharp is the window?

  3. Who closes the window?

  4. Which circuit matters while song is learned?

    AI-generated illustration: a schematic songbird head with the song circuit drawn as named boxes. A motor route runs from HVC to RA to brainstem motor neurons to the syrinx. A second route leaves HVC for area X, the thalamus and LMAN, and rejoins the motor route at RA. An inset notes that LMAN lesions disrupt song development in juveniles but leave stable adult song intact.
    Two routes leave HVC: a motor pathway that produces song, and an anterior forebrain loop through area X, the thalamus and LMAN that rejoins it at RA. LMAN lesions disrupted song development in juveniles but not stable song in adults, so this loop matters while song is learned. AI-generated illustration
  5. Language: what the age effects do and do not show

  6. Sight: separate windows for separate abilities

    AI-generated illustration: an infant on a parent's lap faces a screen carrying a striped patch on one side and a plain grey patch of equal brightness on the other. The infant looks toward the stripes, and an observer behind the screen judges the gaze through a peephole. An inset shows gratings of finer and finer stripes.
    In forced-choice preferential looking, an observer who cannot see which side holds the stripes judges from the infant's gaze, and the finest grating the infant reliably looks at gives its acuity. AI-generated illustration
  7. Putting it together

  8. Going deeper

Read the full lesson → Skim the whole course →