Films · Developmental Neuroscience

Comm: The Gate Is in the Axon

Watch Comm: The Gate Is in the Axon · 3:20
Read the transcript of “Comm: The Gate Is in the Axon”

Film transcript: Comm: The Gate Is in the Axon

In comm mutants, Slit is still at the midline, and Robo is still made. Yet almost no axon crosses. Why? The rule offers one answer. The axon hears Slit too early. If so, Comm's job is to keep Robo down before crossing. How would you test that with genetics alone? In 1998, Tear, Goodman and colleagues did two experiments. First, make a fly lacking both robo and comm. Will it look like comm, like robo, or something new?

It looks like robo. Follow it step by step. In a comm mutant, Robo is too high before crossing. Axons are repelled early and do not cross. In the double mutant there is no Robo1 at all. So there is no Robo1 to be too high. With Robo1 gone, losing Comm changes nothing. The embryo shows only the robo phenotype. This reasoning is called epistasis. When one gene only turns another down, the double looks like the gene turned down. That is the downstream gene.

Second experiment, the reverse. Make Comm in every neuron, at a modest level. What happens to the ladder? Robo protein falls, and the ladder looks like robo. Ipsilateral axons cross, and commissural axons recross. Extra Comm everywhere turns Slit hearing down everywhere. Much stronger Comm can give a more severe, slit-like collapse. So Comm is not a second cue. It sets how much Robo the axon has, and when.

How does it do that? In 2002, Keleman, Dickson and colleagues proposed a sorting model. Comm is made in commissural neurons for a short time, before and during crossing. Inside the neuron, it meets newly made Robo. It diverts it away from the surface, into late endosomes and lysosomes. There, Robo is destroyed. The growth cone crosses carrying little Robo.

Once the axon has crossed, the neuron stops making Comm. Robo reaches the growth cone. Now the Slit it just crossed repels it. Sorting is real. In living embryos, Comm stops a tagged Robo from reaching the axon tip. But it is not the whole story. Flies whose Robo cannot be sorted develop normally. Yet they still need Comm to cross. So Comm has at least one more way to hold Robo back. What that is remains debated. For prediction, you need only the result. While Comm is present, Robo1 stays low, and the axon hears Slit only weakly.

An axon is pulled toward the midline, crosses it, and then treats it as forbidden ground. What changed?

Continue in the lesson: Crossing the Midline Once: Slit, Robo and Comm →

3:20 · Free, with captions and a transcript. The lesson has the full text, the questions and the sources.

More films from this lesson

How this film was made. Narration: an AI narrator voice (Kokoro, af_heart) reading narration written from this lesson's text. Animation: AI-generated in code (Manim) by Claude, a schematic with no drawn molecular structures. Captions come from the narration script. See something wrong? Report it.