Neuroscience · Skim version

Language and Lateralization

About 2 min to skim · 2 figures · Rewritten on

Read the full lesson → Skim the whole course →

The guiding idea

Leborgne could say almost nothing beyond one syllable, yet he appeared to follow much of what was said to him. What exactly had broken?

You can say only what reaches the language network of the hemisphere that speaks, by an unbroken route, so the pattern of what fails points to the stretch that most likely broke.

From the film: One Route to Speech

  • You can say only what reaches the language network of the speaking hemisphere, by an unbroken route.
  • In this simplified sketch, the pattern of what fails on fluency, comprehension, repetition and naming points to the stretch of the route that most likely broke.
  • Naming is impaired in almost every aphasia, so it rarely tells the syndromes apart.
  • The pattern points to a broken stretch of the route, not to one small patch of cortex.

From the film: Cutting the Bridge

  • A key flashed in the left visual field reaches only the right hemisphere, so with the callosum cut it has no route to speech, yet the left hand can find it.
  • The visual hemifield matters, not the eye, and each hand is controlled mainly by the opposite hemisphere.
  • The disconnected right hemisphere understands some spoken language, so it is mute more often than it is deaf to language.
  • The hand-by-field rule has exceptions, and whether the surgery creates two minds is still unsettled.

From the film: Which Side Speaks, and How Sure?

  • Language is on the left in most people, but which hemisphere speaks is a probability, not a certainty.
  • Left-handedness raises the odds of right-sided language; it does not make it typical.
  • The chance that a right-dominant person is left-handed depends on the base rate, so for one person handedness gives odds, not an answer.
  1. Three puzzles about speaking

  2. One route to speech: four tests find the break

    AI-generated illustration: A side view of the left hemisphere with the front to the left. A gold node at the back of the temporal lobe marks the word's sound form; one two-way road runs forward through the temporal lobe to meaning, and another arcs up through parietal cortex to a frontal planner near Broca's area, which drives the motor strip.
    In this simplified sketch, a ventral road leads from a word's sound form to meaning, and a dorsal road arcs through parietal cortex to the frontal planner, which drives the motor system. AI-generated illustration
  3. Cutting the bridge: split-brain patients

    AI-generated illustration: A top-down schematic of a split-brain patient fixating a dot while a key flashes to the left. Light from the key reaches the right hemisphere from both eyes, with the nasal fibres crossing at the chiasm; the corpus callosum is cut, the speaking left hemisphere receives nothing, and the left hand, run by the right hemisphere, finds the key behind a screen.
    With the callosum cut, a key flashed in the left field reaches only the right hemisphere, so the usually speaking left hemisphere has nothing to name, but the left hand, run by the right hemisphere, finds the key. AI-generated illustration
  4. Which hemisphere speaks: a probability

  5. How precise is the map? Lesions and living brains

  6. Design problem

  7. Going deeper

Read the full lesson → Skim the whole course →