Films · Neuroscience

Visible Is Not the Same as Needed

Watch Visible Is Not the Same as Needed · 2:15
Read the transcript of “Visible Is Not the Same as Needed”

Film transcript: Visible Is Not the Same as Needed

LIP firing looks like the running total. But does the decision actually need LIP? A recording shows what activity goes with a choice. Only changing the activity can test whether the choice depends on it. MT passed a first test. Researchers passed weak current into small clusters of MT neurons that shared a preferred direction. The monkeys chose that direction more often, as if that motion had been added to the dots. Katz, Yates, Pillow and Huk then silenced each area in turn, in rhesus monkeys. They used muscimol, a drug that activates GABA-A receptors and quiets nearby neurons. Predict each outcome. If LIP is the accumulator, what happens when you silence MT?

And when you silence LIP? Silencing MT impaired motion discrimination. Silencing LIP produced no measurable impairment of the motion decisions, in the tasks tested. Did the injection simply miss? The same monkeys did a free-choice task, with no right answer. After LIP inactivation, they chose targets in the affected part of space less often. And their eye movements to that side landed less accurately. So the drug had acted on LIP. That control is what makes the null result readable. Still, a null result cannot rule out other areas compensating. Other studies did find deficits after parietal inactivation. So the result is debated. In one study, the biases faded while the area was still silenced.

That suggests other areas compensated. Which areas a decision needs remains an open question. If a decision adds up evidence, the adding happens somewhere, perhaps in several places. But a neuron that shows the running total is not always the place it is needed.

On average, a parietal neuron's firing climbs toward a similar level just before a monkey announces its choice. In one study, silencing that area left the choice no worse. What was the neuron doing?

Continue in the lesson: Attention, Executive Control and Decisions →

2:15 · Free, with captions and a transcript. The lesson has the full text, the questions and the sources.

More films from this lesson

How this film was made. Narration: an AI narrator voice (Kokoro, af_heart) reading narration written from this lesson's text. Animation: AI-generated in code (Manim) by Claude, a schematic with no drawn molecular structures. Captions come from the narration script. See something wrong? Report it.