Films · Developmental Neuroscience

A Veto, Not an Instruction

Watch A Veto, Not an Instruction · 2:60
Read the transcript of “A Veto, Not an Instruction”

Film transcript: A Veto, Not an Instruction

Numb goes into the daughter that does not hear Notch. Is Numb an instruction, or a veto? You now hold two facts. At each division, Notch decides between the daughters. And Numb goes into one daughter only. Put them side by side. At the first division, Numb goes to the inner precursor, which does not hear Notch. At the outer precursor's division, Numb goes to the hair cell. At the inner precursor's, it goes to the neuron. At every division, the Numb daughter is the Notch-off daughter. Two readings fit that. Perhaps Numb is an instruction. It tells the cell what to become. A cell without Numb cannot take that fate. Or perhaps Numb is a veto. It carries no message of its own.

It only blocks Notch. Then a cell with Numb takes whatever fate a cell without Notch would take. Both predict the numb mutant, where every daughter hears Notch. To tell them apart, take Notch away too. Which single mutant does the double mutant resemble? That reading is called epistasis analysis. The test case is MP2, a precursor in the fly's central nervous system. It makes two neurons, dMP2 and vMP2. Here the Notch signal comes from cells outside the lineage, not from the sister. Notch mutants make two dMP2 neurons. Numb mutants make two vMP2 neurons. What should a fly lacking both make, if Numb is an instruction? And if it is a veto?

If Numb were an instruction, the double mutant could make no dMP2. A veto has nothing to block once Notch is gone. So the double mutant should look like the Notch mutant. In 1996, Eric Spana and Chris Doe found two dMP2 neurons.

Numb is not needed to make dMP2. It is needed only to stop Notch. That earns the rule. The daughter that inherits Numb cannot hear Notch, so it takes the Notch-off fate of that division. The rule names a side, not a fate. The Notch-off fate may be the inner precursor, the hair cell or dMP2. In these lineages, both sisters go on to differentiate. So Notch is not the stem cell signal here. Numb needs its phosphotyrosine-binding domain to block Notch. It does not need that domain to form its crescent. Reaching one side and vetoing Notch are separate jobs. Numb is a veto, not an instruction. Without Notch, there is nothing to veto.

A stem cell has to keep making new cells and also keep itself. How does one cell divide into two sisters that are different from the moment they are born?

Continue in the lesson: Asymmetric Division: Numb and the Neuroblast →

2:59 · Free, with captions and a transcript. The lesson has the full text, the questions and the sources.

More films from this lesson

How this film was made. Narration: an AI narrator voice (Kokoro, af_heart) reading narration written from this lesson's text. Animation: AI-generated in code (Manim) by Claude, a schematic with no drawn molecular structures. Captions come from the narration script. See something wrong? Report it.