Neuroscience · Skim version

Designing a Causal Circuit Experiment

About 1 min to skim · 2 figures

Read the full lesson → Skim the whole course →

The guiding idea

Light alone changed firing and turning behaviour in mice with no opsin at all. What does your light-on versus light-off comparison actually show?

A recording tells you that activity goes with a behaviour.

From the film: What Did the Light Change?

  • Light can change firing and behaviour even when no opsin is present.
  • Driving activity tests sufficiency; suppressing it tests necessity under the tested conditions.
  • Crossing construct with light separates an opsin-linked effect from an effect of light itself.
  • A causal claim must name the cells, projection, timing and measured behaviour.

From the film: How Much Evidence Is Enough?

  • In this design, the animal—not each repeated trial—is the independent experimental unit.
  • A standardized effect compares a group difference with the variability around it.
  • Smaller effects require larger samples for the same power target.
  • Association and held-out prediction do not by themselves establish causation.
  1. From a manipulation to a claim

  2. Read the two-by-two as two differences

    AI-generated illustration: Four mice with head-mounted optical fibres in a two-by-two grid: opsin or fluorophore only, crossed with light on or light off; the opsin-plus-light arena is outlined in gold.
    Cross opsin or fluorophore with light on or off, calculate the light effect within each construct group, and compare those two effects. AI-generated illustration
  3. Effect size, power and the experimental unit

    AI-generated illustration: Left, the trials from eight mice are poured into one loose heap as if each were independent; right, each mouse is outlined in gold together with its own column of trials.
    Each animal contributes one independent cluster; its trials can still be modelled at trial level while remaining grouped in the analysis. AI-generated illustration
  4. Association, prediction and causation in human imaging

  5. Going deeper

Read the full lesson → Skim the whole course →