Films · Ecology and Evolution

Changing the Cause on Purpose

Watch Changing the Cause on Purpose · 3:03
Read the transcript of “Changing the Cause on Purpose”

Film transcript: Changing the Cause on Purpose

The seeds that were left are the leading suspect. But nobody can rerun 1977. So how do you test what did the selecting? Go to the mountain streams of Trinidad, where guppies live. In some stream reaches, the main predators eat adult guppies. In others, the main fish predator mostly takes small juveniles. Guppy populations from the two kinds of site differ in life history. That means when they mature, at what size, and how many young they produce. So did the predators shape those traits? The pattern fits that idea. But a comparison across natural sites shows only an association, not a cause. The sites differ in other ways too. Stream size, food, light and history all change from one site to the next.

Comparing the sites cannot pull those apart. So change the proposed cause on purpose. Guppies from a site with predators of adults were moved to a site whose predator mostly eats juveniles. The moved population then evolved in its new reach. David Reznick, Heather Bryga and John Endler compared it with its source population 11 years later. Notice what is different now. The moved guppies and their source started as one population. The researchers made the change, instead of finding sites that already differed. In the new site, adults are safer and the young are the ones being eaten. Should the moved guppies now mature earlier, or later?

Later, and at a larger size. The moved population had changed its life history in the direction life-history theory predicted. It matched the natural comparison. A manipulation can rule out some explanations that an observation leaves open. But this is still one stream and one introduction. And the new reach differed in more than its predator. So it showed that the change of setting caused evolution more firmly than it showed exactly how. So there are three tools, each for its own question. Observation of natural variation shows an association. An experimental contrast tests a cause, because the cause was changed on purpose. But nobody can move a past event.

That needs the third tool. Historical inference tests rival explanations against the traces the past has left. Each tool answers a different question.

A drought killed most of an island's finches, and the survivors had bigger beaks. Is that evolution yet?

Continue in the lesson: How to Test an Evolutionary Explanation →

3:03 · Free, with captions and a transcript. The lesson has the full text, the questions and the sources.

More films from this lesson

How this film was made. Narration: an AI narrator voice (Kokoro, af_heart) reading narration written from this lesson's text. Animation: AI-generated in code (Manim) by Claude, a schematic with no drawn molecular structures. Captions come from the narration script. See something wrong? Report it.