Catching the Brake
Read the transcript of “Catching the Brake”
Film transcript: Catching the Brake
The first film tilted the per-capita line by assumption. In a real forest or on a real reef, how would you catch that line tilting? Start in the Yukon, near Kluane Lake. Snowshoe hares there rise and fall in a cycle of roughly a decade.
Charles Krebs and colleagues worked on blocks of forest. They added food, fenced out mammal predators, did both, or did neither. During the cycle's peak and decline, fencing out mammal predators raised hare density, and so did food. Doing both raised it far more than either alone. So food and predators both limited the hares. But were individuals doing worse at high density?
Counts of hares cannot say. For that you need a per-capita rate, measured at several densities. Mark Hixon and Mark Carr did this on small patch reefs in the Bahamas. A per-capita measure counts outcomes per individual, not heads. Here it is the fraction of young fish that died during the study on each reef. They stocked newly settled blue chromis, a small reef fish, at different densities. Some reefs got few young fish, some got many. They also crossed two kinds of predator.
Residents live on the reef. Transients swim in from open water and move between reefs. Then they plotted the fraction of young fish that died against starting density. A fraction dying is a per-capita measure, so it is teal. With both predator groups present, the line rose steeply. The more young fish that settled on a reef, the larger the share that died. That rising line is density-dependent mortality. Predators caused it on these reefs, at least when both kinds hunted there together.
Now take away one of the two predator groups, either one. Does the teal line still rise as density goes up? With only one group, no rise was detected. But one of those tests had low statistical power, too little data to catch a real slope reliably. Not detected is not the same as absent. Notice what made this a test of density dependence. Not more deaths in total, but a larger fraction of the fish dying. The hares and the chromis answer two different questions. Adding food and removing predators showed what limited the hares. The chromis showed density dependence, within one generation and across reefs. A brake is negative density dependence.
As density rises, deaths rise or births fall, so net per-capita growth falls. You find it only by measuring per-capita rates.
A population of 100 growing continuously at a constant per-capita rate of 0.2 per day reaches 739 in ten days, not 300. What has to change, per individual, for that growth to stop?
Continue in the lesson: Population Growth and Regulation →
3:19 · Free, with captions and a transcript. The lesson has the full text, the questions and the sources.
More films from this lesson
How this film was made. Narration: an AI narrator voice (Kokoro, af_heart) reading narration written from this lesson's text. Animation: AI-generated in code (Manim) by Claude, a schematic with no drawn molecular structures. Captions come from the narration script. See something wrong? Report it.