Films · Neuroscience

From Where to What

Watch From Where to What · 2:18
Read the transcript of “From Where to What”

Film transcript: From Where to What

The map tells you where a region is. How do you find out what it does? You need an experiment. Each kind licenses a different claim. First, a lesion. A deficit after damage, compared with controls, shows the tissue contributes to the task. But damage rarely respects borders, so which part mattered can be unclear. Second, a recording. Firing that goes with a choice shows covariation, not that the brain uses it. Third, imaging. Functional MRI measures blood oxygenation, not spikes. In anaesthetized macaque visual cortex, it followed local field potentials better than spiking. Field potentials mostly reflect synaptic and dendritic currents near the electrode.

So an activation does not mark a region as the seat of anything. Fourth, stimulation adds activity. Monkeys judged which way noisy dots moved. An electrode sat among area MT neurons that all fire most for one direction of motion, their preferred direction. On random trials, weak current flowed while the dots were shown. If the monkey uses these neurons, which way should stimulation push its choices?

Toward the neurons' preferred direction. In 86 of the 89 experiments with a significant effect, that is what happened. That shows a causal contribution in this task. It does not make area MT the seat of motion, or show it is required. So a lesion shows contribution, not which part mattered. A recording shows covariation, not use. Imaging shows where a blood signal goes, not which neural signal. Stimulation shows contribution, not that the region is required. Reese and Karnovsky also added something and watched. But their tracer showed only where it stopped, a different kind of claim. Claim only what the evidence licenses.

Inject a protein tracer into a mouse's blood and, in the cerebral cortex, it goes no farther than the cells lining the capillaries. Why there?

Continue in the lesson: The Map: How the Nervous System Is Organized →

2:18 · Free, with captions and a transcript. The lesson has the full text, the questions and the sources.

More films from this lesson

How this film was made. Narration: an AI narrator voice (Kokoro, af_heart) reading narration written from this lesson's text. Animation: AI-generated in code (Manim) by Claude, a schematic with no drawn molecular structures. Captions come from the narration script. See something wrong? Report it.