Films · Sensory Systems

Only When the Feedback Matches

Watch Only When the Feedback Matches · 2:41
Read the transcript of “Only When the Feedback Matches”

Film transcript: Only When the Feedback Matches

When you turn your head, your inner ear reports the turn. Does your brain treat it like a turn someone gave you? Start with the receptors. In alert monkeys, canal afferents report active and passive turns alike. In freely moving mice, Pacinian touch afferents also fire strongly to the animal's own movements. So the receptors pass self-caused input to the brain. Whether it is damped further along, that mouse study did not test. Back to the monkey. Central vestibular-only neurons respond to head motion, not to eye movement. An active turn barely changes their firing. The same turn applied passively changes it strongly. Neck proprioceptors report how the head moves on the body.

The cancellation needed them to match the command's prediction. Brooks and Cullen then added passive motion during an active turn, activating the same proprioceptors. Predict. With the feedback no longer matching, what do the central neurons report?

They report the whole movement, active and passive parts together. The cancellation fails. So in these neurons, cancellation is central, and it holds only while the feedback matches. People show a related pattern. Self-produced touch is rated less ticklish than the same touch from outside. In one study, people moved a robot arm with one hand. A second robot touched their other palm. Predict. Add a delay between the movement and the touch. What happens to the tickle?

It feels more ticklish with a delay. Rotating the hand's movement against the touch's direction does the same. A forward model, predicting a command's sensory result, is one candidate explanation, not a settled one. Mice show a related signal. Some visual cortex neurons respond when the visual flow fails to match running. One reading: a failed prediction. Back to the one idea. Some pathways subtract a prediction of what your own movement causes. Take this with you. In these monkey neurons, the subtraction ran only while the feedback matched the prediction.

Your senses disagree, and some of what they report is only the result of your own movement. How does a nervous system decide which sense to trust, and what to subtract? Subtracting self-generated input is one candidate explanation for why you can hardly tickle yourself, though the full answer is not settled.

Continue in the lesson: Combining Senses and Predicting Them →

2:41 · Free, with captions and a transcript. The lesson has the full text, the questions and the sources.

More films from this lesson

How this film was made. Narration: an AI narrator voice (Kokoro, af_heart) reading narration written from this lesson's text. Animation: AI-generated in code (Manim) by Claude, a schematic with no drawn molecular structures. Captions come from the narration script. See something wrong? Report it.