Reading Selection in Genes
Read the transcript of “Reading Selection in Genes”
Film transcript: Reading Selection in Genes
Where selection acts, changes depart from the neutral count. Purifying selection can make them lag; positive selection can make them run ahead. So how could you catch that in a real gene? Here is the trick. Find two kinds of change in the same gene that neutrality says should behave alike. If they part ways by more than chance allows, selection may be at work. Take a coding gene, read three letters at a time. The genetic code has several codons for most amino acids. So some changes keep the amino acid. These are synonymous. Other changes alter the amino acid. These are nonsynonymous, or replacement, changes. If synonymous changes are neutral, they are a built-in control for the replacements.
Count each kind along a branch, per site where it could happen. Call them dN and dS. Their ratio is called omega. Below one, replacements were fixed more slowly than silent changes. That suggests purifying selection removed some.
Near one is consistent with neutrality. Above one suggests positive selection. A second test uses variation inside a species. In 1991, John McDonald and Martin Kreitman applied it to the Adh gene of fruit flies. The gene makes alcohol dehydrogenase. Sort every change into a table. The columns are replacement and synonymous. One row holds variants within a species. The other holds differences fixed between species. Under neutrality, a variant within a species is a passing stage, on its way to fixation or loss. So both rows should hold the same ratio of replacement to synonymous changes. The variants row fills first, and it is mostly synonymous.
If replacements were neutral, what should the fixed row look like? Neutrality predicts the same ratio. Instead, the fixed row held more replacements than the variants predicted. McDonald and Kreitman suggested this reflected adaptive fixation. Here each kind of change is the control for the other. So this test needs no clock and no dated split. Both tests are model inferences, and each model can fail. A signal like this still needs further checks before it counts as adaptation.
Both tests ask the same question. Did one kind of change keep pace with the neutral count? A departure is a clue to selection, not proof.
Two species left no fossil of their split. Can their genes still tell you when it happened?
Continue in the lesson: Molecular Evolution →
3:12 · Free, with captions and a transcript. The lesson has the full text, the questions and the sources.
More films from this lesson
How this film was made. Narration: an AI narrator voice (Kokoro, af_heart) reading narration written from this lesson's text. Animation: AI-generated in code (Manim) by Claude, a schematic with no drawn molecular structures. Captions come from the narration script. See something wrong? Report it.