Same Protein, Different Switch
Read the transcript of “Same Protein, Different Switch”
Film transcript: Same Protein, Different Switch
This lake stickleback has almost no pelvis, yet its Pitx1 protein is unchanged. So what broke, if the protein did not? The likely answer is a kind of switch. Marine sticklebacks carry a pelvis: a bony girdle with a pair of long spines. It is the fish's version of your hips and legs. In Paxton Lake, British Columbia, the bottom-feeding fish have a greatly reduced pelvis. Most have no pelvic bones at all. The gene most strongly tied to that difference is Pitx1. Its protein is a transcription factor. It binds DNA and switches other genes on or off. In the lake fish examined, that protein was unchanged. Pitx1 is not only a pelvis gene. It is also used in the jaw.
Mice with no working Pitx1 die, and they have malformed hind limbs among other defects. Suppose the lake fish had broken the protein itself. Where would you expect the damage to show? Everywhere the gene works. A protein with no function would fail in the jaw and the pelvis at once. The mouse shows how costly that can be. The lake fish do not look like that.
The way out is an enhancer. An enhancer is a short stretch of noncoding DNA that switches a gene on in particular tissues. One gene can have several. One can serve the jaw, another the pelvis. Their jobs can overlap. So where is Pitx1 RNA in a lake fish larva? A labelled probe pairs with the RNA and leaves a gold mark wherever it is. In Paxton larvae, gold sits in the mouth and lower jaw. Where the pelvis forms, there is none. So suppose the jaw switch still works, but the pelvic switch does not. Then that body part shrinks, while the gene keeps its other jobs. Compare the two fish once more. Both make the same Pitx1 protein. Both use it in the jaw.
Of the tissues compared, only the pelvic use differs. The pelvic use changed, and the jaw use was spared. Other tissues were not all checked. This is the best-studied route to a reduced pelvis in sticklebacks. It is not the only one. A missing gold mark also leaves a question open. Is the break in this gene's own DNA, or in another gene?
Some lake sticklebacks have almost no pelvis, yet their Pitx1 protein is unchanged. If the protein did not break, what did?
Continue in the lesson: Evolution of Development →
3:00 · Free, with captions and a transcript. The lesson has the full text, the questions and the sources.
More films from this lesson
How this film was made. Narration: written from this lesson's text and read by an AI narrator voice (Kokoro, af_heart). Animation: AI-generated in code (Manim) by Claude, a schematic with no drawn molecular structures. Captions come from the narration script. See something wrong? Report it.