Biology · Skim version

Evidence for Evolution

About 1 min to skim · 3 figures · Rewritten on

Read the full lesson → Skim the whole course →

The guiding idea

If whales live their whole lives in water, why do some fossil whales have legs, and why do living whales still carry small hip bones?

Independent evidence that agrees strengthens an explanation of common descent.

From the film: How Rocks Put Fossils in Order

  • In an undisturbed stack, lower rock layers formed before higher layers.
  • Radioactive dating can add ages in years to a relative rock order.
  • Dated volcanic layers above and below a fossil bracket its age but do not give it exactly.
  • The fossil record has gaps because most living things never fossilize.
  • Independent evidence that agrees strengthens an explanation of common descent.

From the film: Four Tests of Whale Ancestry

  • Shared DNA insertions group whales with hippos among the even-toed hoofed mammals.
  • Living structures and embryos can preserve evidence of shared ancestry.
  • Vestigial does not mean useless: a reduced inherited structure can keep a job.
  • Living relatives share ancestors; one did not become the other.
  • Independent evidence that agrees strengthens an explanation of common descent.
  1. Explore: stack rock layers and count DNA differences

  2. Use rock order, then test its limits

    AI-generated illustration: a cliff face cut through flat rock layers. A small fossil shell sits in the bottom layer, a single fossil bone in the middle layer, a thin grey ash band lies just above it, and shark teeth sit in the top layer. An arrow beside the cliff points upward. Five numbered circles point to these parts.
    1. top layer with shark teeth
    2. volcanic ash layer
    3. fossil whale bone
    4. oldest bottom layer
    5. older to younger
    Relative dating: in an undisturbed stack of rock layers, each layer settles on the ones below it. Name the five numbered parts, then say which fossil is oldest and how the ash layer could help date the bone. AI-generated illustration
  3. What a DNA percentage does—and does not—measure

  4. What the other evidence can and cannot show

    AI-generated illustration: a living whale in side view with a small pair of hip bones shown deep inside its lower body and no legs attached. An inset zooms in on one hip bone with a muscle band attached.
    A vestigial structure: living whales carry small hip bones that hold up no legs, yet in males they still anchor muscles used in mating. AI-generated illustration
    AI-generated illustration: two simple outlines of a dolphin embryo. The earlier one has a small hind-limb bud near its rear; in the later one the bud is gone and only a dashed outline marks where it was.
    Spotted dolphin embryos start hind-limb buds, then the buds stop growing and break down. The embryo is not replaying its ancestors; it starts a limb and then stops. AI-generated illustration
  5. Elaborate: read DNA comparisons and fossil ages

  6. Evaluate: check your thinking

  7. Going deeper

Read the full lesson → Skim the whole course →