Power Peaks at a Middle Load
Read the transcript of “Power Peaks at a Middle Load”
Film transcript: Power Peaks at a Middle Load
A muscle lifts nothing. It shortens as fast as it can, and it does no external work. Another muscle holds a load it cannot move. It also does no external work. At both extremes, the external work is zero. So where does a muscle deliver its power? In 1938, A. V. Hill asked what sets how fast an activated muscle shortens. Hill used isolated frog sartorius muscles at about 0 degrees Celsius. He tetanized each muscle. Then he let it shorten against a series of loads on a lever. A thermopile recorded the heat. He read the speed from the record of shortening, not from the total distance shortened. Heavier loads gave slower shortening. Speed fell with load along a curve called a rectangular hyperbola, not along a straight line. A viscous brake would give a straight line.
So Hill's result ruled out a passive viscous-elastic muscle. Here is the curve for a made-up model muscle, not measured human values. Its isometric force is 100 newtons. With no load, it shortens at 0.40 metres per second. At 100 newtons, it does not shorten. Power is force times speed, in watts. With no load, the speed is greatest, but the load is zero, so the power is zero. When the load equals the force the muscle can hold, the speed is zero, so the power is zero again. This is external power, not ATP use. An isometric muscle does no external work, yet it keeps splitting ATP. In between, power peaks. In this model, the constant is one quarter of the isometric force.
Then the peak sits near 0.31 of the isometric force. That is a load of 30.9 newtons. The speed there is about 0.12 metres per second, and the peak power is about 3.8 watts. The exact fraction depends on the curvature. Now stretch the same model fibre. Assume force falls along a straight line, from full force at 2.2 micrometres of sarcomere length to zero at 3.65 micrometres. At 3.00 micrometres, the isometric force is 44.83 newtons. At fixed speed and curvature, peak power falls by the same factor, 0.448. The speed at peak power stays at 0.309 of top speed. Hill's rule gives no molecular mechanism, and its constants are frog values at about 0 degrees Celsius.
External power is zero at both extremes and peaks at a middle load.
A muscle lifting nothing and a muscle holding a load it cannot move both do zero external work. Where is the power?
Continue in the lesson: Skeletal Muscle: Length, Load and Speed →
2:41 · Free, with captions and a transcript. The lesson has the full text, the questions and the sources.
How this film was made. Narration: an AI narrator voice (Kokoro, af_heart) reading narration written from this lesson's text. Animation: AI-generated in code (Manim) by Claude, a schematic with no drawn molecular structures. Captions come from the narration script. See something wrong? Report it.