Run a Fair Test With Your Child
Read the transcript of “Run a Fair Test With Your Child”
Film transcript: Run a Fair Test With Your Child
Does a plant really need sunlight if it already has water? Ask your child for a guess. A fair test is a test where only one thing changes and everything else stays the same. Four cups of radish seedlings can show you how. First, grow all four cups the same way. Same soil, same cups, same seeds, all on a sunny windowsill. Wait until most seedlings are about two centimetres tall. Before you change anything, ask your child what will happen to each cup. Write or draw the guesses. The safety notes are on the page. Now change things. Move two cups into the cupboard, where it is dark. Two cups keep their water. Two get nothing more. Change nothing else.
Next to the light and water cup, the dark and water cup differs only in light. The light, no water cup differs only in water. Now look and compare. Check every day or two, and draw each cup. The cups with no water usually droop within two to five days. Within about a week, the watered seedlings in the dark are often taller, thinner and paler. The cup with light and water stays green and upright. Look again at the dark seedlings. They are the tallest. Your child may call them the best. So ask about colour and strength, not only height. A seedling in the dark stretches on food it has stored. Once that food runs out, it grows weaker. Height alone is not health.
If a result surprises your child, it is still real, so do not throw it out. If your child wants extra water for one cup, do not change that cup. Add an extra cup to try the idea, and the first test stays fair. Here is the short version. Predict first. Change one thing at a time. Keep everything else the same. Look and compare. Keep every real result.
Does a plant really need sunlight if it already has water? Four cups and a cupboard give a fair answer.
Continue in the lesson: What Do Plants Need? →
2:05 · Free, with captions and a transcript. The lesson has the full text, the questions and the sources.
How this film was made. Narration: an AI narrator voice (Kokoro, af_heart) reading narration written from this activity's text. Animation: AI-generated in code (Manim) by Claude, a schematic with no drawn molecular structures. Captions come from the narration script. See something wrong? Report it.