Films · Cell Signaling

Gain Acts Alone, Loss Needs Both

Watch Gain Acts Alone, Loss Needs Both · 2:42
Read the transcript of “Gain Acts Alone, Loss Needs Both”

Film transcript: Gain Acts Alone, Loss Needs Both

A cell should divide only when it is told to. So every signaling pathway has an on step and an off step, The signal flips a switch on, and the off step flips it back. Now suppose the switch sticks. The cell divides on its own. There are two ways to make that happen: jam an on step or remove an off step. First, jam the on step. Ras is on while it holds GTP. Normally a helper called a GAP makes Ras break down that GTP, and the switch turns off. One changed amino acid, as in Ras G12V, slows this. Ras breaks down its GTP slowly, even with a GAP. A gene that can turn a cell cancerous is an oncogene. Second, remove the off -step. Neurofibramin is a GAP for Ras.

It is the off -step. Lose neurofibromin, and Ras GTP is not cleared. No on -step is jammed here. An off -step is missing. A gene whose loss lets cells grow when they should not is a tumour suppressor. Now count the copies. You carry two copies of nearly every gene, one from each parent. Suppose one copy of the Ras gene is changed. The altered protein signals without being told to. The normal protein from the other copy cannot stop it. So the cell divides. This is a gain of function, and it is dominant. It shows even when the other copy is normal. An off switch is different. One good copy usually makes enough protein to do the job. Lose one copy of the gene, and the off step still works.

Both copies must go before the off step fails. Alfred Knudson proposed two hits for retinoblastoma. The two hits turned out to be the two copies of one gene. So a stuck switch follows two rules, whichever way it sticks. A jammed on step acts when one copy is altered. A lost off step usually needs both copies gone. Gain acts alone. Loss needs both.

A chicken virus causes cancer with one gene. The chicken already had that gene.

Continue in the lesson: Oncogenes: When the Switch Sticks →

2:42 · Free, with captions and a transcript. The lesson has the full text, the questions and the sources.

More films from this lesson

How this film was made. Narration: an AI narrator voice (ElevenLabs, Sarah) reading narration written from this lesson's text. Animation: AI-generated in code (Manim) by Claude, a schematic with no drawn molecular structures. Captions come from the narration script. See something wrong? Report it.