Resources for teachers / talk notes
Fast tools for us. Slow thinking for them.
STEMhop is a set of free courses, starting with biology: short readings, films of the experiments, simulations you can change, and questions with checked answers. You can use any of it with your students. This page goes with my talk “Fast Tools, Slow Thinking” at Teaching Life Sciences in the Age of AI (University of Virginia, October 24, 2026). It has the slides, a checklist you can print, prompts for your own use, and a practical guide.
New: classes. Give students a code, assign lessons (with their flashcard decks, if you like), and read a morning brief of how they reasoned before class, down to the flashcards they kept missing. Nicknames only, free, no AI. Make a class →
The talk
“Fast Tools, Slow Thinking.” Click the slides, then use the arrow keys (or the buttons below). The pictures in the deck are AI-generated, and the first slide says so.
In the slides, press f for full screen. On a phone, turn it sideways and use “Open full screen”. The PDF has the main slides only, as pictures; this page carries the same text below. A narrated version will be added after the workshop.
Where I’ve landed
I’ll say it first, so you can judge the rest against it. Two conclusions, and they are one idea.
Fast tools · for teachers
Teachers are essential, and they’re not going away anytime soon.
Any AI tutor should be under the teacher’s control, and every exchange should be visible to the teacher. That’s for safety. It’s also because being able to question a student’s reasoning is the real promise of this for teachers.
AI tools are for us: to make your lives easier and the students’ experience better.
Slow thinking · for students
Leaning on AI is really quite damaging for students, especially younger ones.
They need to be slow about their thinking so they can take an idea on board. The thinking stays slow for them.
Your students already use these tools: 54% of US teens used a chatbot for schoolwork in fall 2025 (Pew).
The problem
Every class spans a ladder. Students arrive on very different rungs, and we teach to the middle, because that is what one teacher’s attention and a single test can handle.
That leaves two tails. The left tail needs more help to reach the standard. The right tail is ready to go much further. Reaching the whole ladder is an attention problem, and it is the one the rest of this page tries to answer: fast tools can carry the volume, so your attention goes where it is needed, and the slow thinking stays with the students.
What I’d ask of any AI in a classroom
If someone shows you an AI tool for your classroom, whether it’s a vendor, your district, or me, these are the five questions I’d ask.
- The student tries first. It never gives the answer before they commit.
- The teacher sees every exchange.
- It meets each student at their level. And tells the teacher who is falling behind.
- It looks at reasoning. And gives second chances.
- Everything it makes is checked. Mistakes are fixed in public.
I’m still building toward several of these myself. The teacher-visible tutor and the check-as-you-go levels are not built yet. The pre-work, the fact-checking and the public corrections are.
Where this is going
Five shifts, each one about reaching the whole ladder. I think they will look obvious in ten years. For each, now is what is happening and next is where I think it goes. Where the next part is not built, I say so.
-
Shift 1: Meet every student where they are.
Slow thinking · for students
- Now
- In one grade, students’ levels vary widely. In Delhi, software that taught each student at their own level raised math scores 0.36 standard deviations in 4.5 months. That is one study; Teaching at the Right Level is strong in some places and modest in others, so I hold it loosely.
- Next
- Every student starts on their own rung: catching up from below, racing ahead from above, checked as they go, and the teacher told who is slipping.
For a teacher: You know who needs the review, or the stretch, before the test tells you.
A first step is built: a depth ladder on every high school Biology lesson, from grade 7 up to college, and a switch for how much help a student gets. The checking and routing are not.
-
Shift 2: Let curiosity lead the right tail.
Slow thinking · for students
- Now
- Interest in science falls from about age 9 to 17. Curiosity questions drop from about 2.4 per two hours in kindergarten to about 0.5 in grade 5.
- Next
- Keep teaching the core. A student’s own question can become an independent study, built on the fly, and exploring earns credit. In my class the same few students asked most of the questions, so the quiet ones need a way in too.
For a teacher: A question is the clearest look at what a student is really thinking about.
Questions are collected in my graduate course; nothing yet answers them all.
-
Shift 3: AI carries the volume, so your attention goes where it’s needed.
Fast tools · for teachers
- Now
- Teachers who use AI every week save about 5.9 hours a week, mostly on preparation.
- Next
- AI reads every answer and builds the review or the stretch. Each morning you see which few students need you, and why. This is not new: Just-in-Time Teaching did it in 1999 and stayed small, probably because reading 150 answers overnight takes too long. That is the part AI makes cheap.
For a teacher: A view of where each student’s thinking stands before class starts. Check any AI summary against the raw answers.
In use in my graduate courses; I read and send the notes myself.
-
Shift 4: A tutor the school owns, so you can see the thinking.
Slow thinking · for students
- Now
- A 2025 study gave students an unguarded GPT-4. Practice scores went up 48%; once the AI was taken away, exam scores fell 17%. A tutor with guardrails, one that would not hand over the answer, did not show that harm.
- Next
- The school gives every student a flexible tutor that asks before it tells. Because the school owns it, the teacher sees how each student uses it and thinks. Students bringing their own AI is a different problem. I haven’t solved it.
For a teacher: A tutor that slows the student down, and a window into what they said to it and why.
Not built yet. It is where I want to take the site.
-
Shift 5: How they got there counts more than the answer.
Slow thinking · for students
- Now
- We grade the answer, and a chatbot now gives any answer. Chegg, which sold homework answers, saw its revenue fall 39% in a year.
- Next
- The prediction, the reasoning and the revision become what we look at. The score becomes a by-product. In my graduate course, 22% of answers were revised after the reveal, and I can see that.
For a teacher: You stop guessing from the final product and start reading how a student actually thought.
Partly built: my pre-work records the trail.
Why we teach to the test, and how to loosen it
“When a measure becomes a target, it ceases to be a good measure.”
High-stakes exams are not new: China ran them for more than a thousand years, until 1905. Why does the number win? The answer is cheap to grade, and reasoning is expensive to read. So the answer becomes the measure, then the target, and teaching bends toward it. That gap, between what is cheap to measure and what we care about, is where it happens. The law bites hardest on one narrow, high-stakes number, and a single state test is exactly that. Three moves blunt it:
- Measure the thing itself. The reasoning, not a stand-in for it.
- Many small looks, not one big test. Low stakes, so nothing is worth gaming. A wrong answer argued well costs nothing in my pre-work.
- A person reads it. Judgment, not just a score.
Honestly: state tests and the MCAT are not going away soon. But if understanding is what we look at every day, the test becomes a by-product. That is my hope, not something I have proved.
Honest about the risks
It can go wrong, sometimes quietly. Seven ways I worry about:
- Free tools help the already-engaged most. Devices and broadband are not equal.
- Over-reliance, for students and for us. If we trust the summary, our own judgment gets weaker.
- A rung can harden into a label. Placement has to stay fluid.
- AI is wrong sometimes. A summary said a student had done nothing; an exam question can be ambiguous.
- A record of how a child thinks is sensitive. Who owns it, how long it is kept, and breaches.
- Goodhart applies to AI too. Optimize engagement or scores, and it bends the same way.
- One 2026 trial, not peer-reviewed: a course AI tutor lowered grades, most for first-generation students.
AI reads. You decide.
One lesson from my own exams
This spring I had AI help write exam questions for about 735 biochemistry students. After each exam, students could ask for a question to be reviewed: 28 requests after the first exam, 44 after the second and 41 after the third. Two questions were credited to everyone, because the wording was ambiguous. I then added a red-team review of the questions and banned “All of the above.” Models are getting better at clean wording and the right level, but they are not there yet, so a person reads every question. Details are under the sources; a tip is in the guide.
Do it yourself
A practical guide Ten things you can try, step by step Pre-work in Google Forms, reading a room in fifteen minutes, opening class with students’ own words, meeting students where they are, checking what AI makes, keeping any AI tutor yours, and a privacy checklist. Each one says what it is, what you need, the steps, and one thing to watch for.Courses for your classroom
All of these are free and need no account. Right now the site has 414 lessons in 13 courses. Take what is useful.
Both are first editions, checked against published sources by AI models and now in classroom testing; every lesson has a “Report an error” link.
All courses
- Biology Together (ages 5 to 10) 30 lessons
- Life Science (grade 7) 34 lessons
- Biology (high school) 33 lessons
- Organismal Biology 26 lessons
- Cell Biology 26 lessons
- Genetics and Molecular Biology 26 lessons
- Ecology and Evolution 26 lessons
- Biochemistry 30 lessons
- Neuroscience 28 lessons
- Physiology 30 lessons
- Cell Signaling 44 lessons
- Developmental Neuroscience 51 lessons
- Sensory Systems 30 lessons
The courses after Biology were written for college students, so read ahead before assigning.
Try the five-minute demo as a student How it’s built
Prompts you can use
Copy a prompt, fill in the [square brackets], and paste it into whichever AI tool your district allows. Each one is built to protect slow thinking: students commit to a reason before they see an answer, the AI is told to judge the reasoning rather than the correctness, and it is told never to invent a source. Everything it writes is a draft for you to check.
These prompts are for you. I have deliberately not written one for students to paste into their own chatbots: you could not see those exchanges, and seeing every exchange is the point.
Privacy first. Strip names and IDs before pasting anything a student wrote, and use only tools your district has approved.
-
1. Predict-then-reveal pre-work on a Virginia SOL topic
Protects: Students commit to a guess and a reason before they see anything.
Show the prompt
You are helping me write pre-work for my [grade] biology class on this topic: [paste the Virginia SOL biology standard text or your own topic description]. Write 5 predict-then-reveal items. For each item give me: 1. A short scenario or data description a student can read in under a minute (no outside knowledge needed beyond what we have covered: [list what you have taught]). 2. A prediction question with 3 or 4 choices. Make the wrong choices tempting for a real, named misconception, and tell me which misconception each one targets. 3. A prompt that asks the student to write one or two sentences on why they chose it, BEFORE they see anything else. 4. A "reveal" paragraph with the real answer and a short explanation. 5. A one-line note for me on what a good reason looks like and what a weak reason looks like. Do not write any question whose answer is stated in its own stem. Rules for this task: - Grade or comment on the quality of the reasoning, not on whether the final answer is correct. A wrong answer argued well is a good answer. - Do not invent sources, citations, quotations, statistics or standards. If you are not sure something is true, say "I am not sure" instead of guessing. - Do not do the students' thinking for them. Ask questions or point to where to look; do not hand over the answer unless I ask for an answer key. - Keep it short and in plain language for a middle or high school class. - Anything you produce is a draft for me to check before it reaches a student.
-
2. Draft a misconception check
Protects: It finds the wrong idea the student is actually holding, instead of rewarding a lucky guess.
Show the prompt
My [grade] class is learning: [topic]. List the 5 most common student misconceptions about this topic that are documented in biology education. For each one: 1. State the misconception in the words a student would use. 2. Write one short question where a student holding that misconception would pick a specific wrong answer, and a student without it would not. 3. Write a one-sentence follow-up that asks the student to explain their thinking, without telling them they are wrong. If you are not confident a misconception is a well-documented one, mark it "less certain". Do not name studies or authors unless you are sure they exist. Rules for this task: - Grade or comment on the quality of the reasoning, not on whether the final answer is correct. A wrong answer argued well is a good answer. - Do not invent sources, citations, quotations, statistics or standards. If you are not sure something is true, say "I am not sure" instead of guessing. - Do not do the students' thinking for them. Ask questions or point to where to look; do not hand over the answer unless I ask for an answer key. - Keep it short and in plain language for a middle or high school class. - Anything you produce is a draft for me to check before it reaches a student.
-
3. Turn anonymous answers into a "where you split" summary
Protects: The room sees its own words, and learns in the first minute that the pre-work was read.
Student writing goes in here. Remove every name and ID first.
Show the prompt
Below are anonymous answers from my class to this question: [paste the question]. Each answer includes the student's reason. All names and IDs have been removed. [paste anonymous answers, one per line] Please: 1. Group the answers by the idea behind them, not by whether they are right. Give each group a plain label. 2. For each group, tell me how many answers are in it and quote one short phrase from the students' own words (copy exactly; do not rewrite). 3. Point out the single most useful split in the room: the place where two reasonable groups disagree. 4. Suggest one question I could ask out loud that makes the two groups argue with each other without telling them who is right. 5. Tell me anything in the answers you could not interpret, rather than guessing. Only use what is in the answers above. If there are fewer than 8 answers, say that the picture is thin. Rules for this task: - Grade or comment on the quality of the reasoning, not on whether the final answer is correct. A wrong answer argued well is a good answer. - Do not invent sources, citations, quotations, statistics or standards. If you are not sure something is true, say "I am not sure" instead of guessing. - Do not do the students' thinking for them. Ask questions or point to where to look; do not hand over the answer unless I ask for an answer key. - Keep it short and in plain language for a middle or high school class. - Anything you produce is a draft for me to check before it reaches a student.
-
4. Check an AI summary against the raw answers
Protects: It catches the AI telling you a student did nothing when they did.
Student writing goes in here. Remove every name and ID first.
Show the prompt
I will give you (A) an AI-written summary of one student's pre-work and (B) the raw anonymous answers it was based on. Your job is to audit the summary. (A) Summary: [paste] (B) Raw answers: [paste] List every statement in the summary that is NOT supported by the raw answers, every statement that contradicts them, and anything important in the raw answers that the summary left out. Pay special attention to any claim of "no activity", "did not complete", or "struggled", and check each against the raw text. Quote the raw text that supports your finding. If everything is supported, say so. Rules for this task: - Grade or comment on the quality of the reasoning, not on whether the final answer is correct. A wrong answer argued well is a good answer. - Do not invent sources, citations, quotations, statistics or standards. If you are not sure something is true, say "I am not sure" instead of guessing. - Do not do the students' thinking for them. Ask questions or point to where to look; do not hand over the answer unless I ask for an answer key. - Keep it short and in plain language for a middle or high school class. - Anything you produce is a draft for me to check before it reaches a student.
-
5. A short focus note for one student, from their own answers
Protects: Each student gets a custom start, and it is built from their thinking, not from a template.
Student writing goes in here. Remove every name and ID first.
Show the prompt
Here is one student's pre-work: the questions, what the student predicted, the reason they wrote, and their confidence before and after. The name and ID have been removed. [paste one student's anonymous answers] Write a focus note to the student of 120 to 200 words, in a warm, direct voice, with three parts: - Where you are: one or two sentences on what the student seems to understand, based only on their answers. - One or two things you said: quote or closely paraphrase a specific point from their own reasoning that was good or interesting. - Two or three things to focus on in class: phrased as questions to think about, not as corrections. Do not say a student did or did not do the work unless it is clearly shown in the text above. If the text is too thin to write a note, say so and write nothing else. I will add the student's name, compare the note with their raw answers, and send it myself. Rules for this task: - Grade or comment on the quality of the reasoning, not on whether the final answer is correct. A wrong answer argued well is a good answer. - Do not invent sources, citations, quotations, statistics or standards. If you are not sure something is true, say "I am not sure" instead of guessing. - Do not do the students' thinking for them. Ask questions or point to where to look; do not hand over the answer unless I ask for an answer key. - Keep it short and in plain language for a middle or high school class. - Anything you produce is a draft for me to check before it reaches a student.
-
6. Send a wrong answer back to a specific lesson section
Protects: A miss becomes a pointer to where to look, not a verdict.
Show the prompt
Here is a question I use and the lesson or reading it belongs to. Question and choices: [paste] Lesson or reading text (or its list of section headings): [paste] For each WRONG choice: 1. Describe the thinking that would lead a student to pick it. 2. Name the one section of the lesson (by its heading) that a student should reread, and say in one sentence what to look for there. Do not give the answer. 3. Write a one-line question the student can ask themselves after rereading. Use only the section headings and text I pasted. If no section addresses a wrong choice, say so; do not make one up. Rules for this task: - Grade or comment on the quality of the reasoning, not on whether the final answer is correct. A wrong answer argued well is a good answer. - Do not invent sources, citations, quotations, statistics or standards. If you are not sure something is true, say "I am not sure" instead of guessing. - Do not do the students' thinking for them. Ask questions or point to where to look; do not hand over the answer unless I ask for an answer key. - Keep it short and in plain language for a middle or high school class. - Anything you produce is a draft for me to check before it reaches a student.
-
7. One idea at three levels
Protects: The science stays the same while the depth changes, so a student who moves up or down a level is not learning something that later has to be taken back.
Show the prompt
Take this one idea from my [grade] class: [the idea, in one sentence]. Write it three times: for grade 7 Life Science, for high school Biology, and for a first-year college course. The science must be the same at all three levels. A lower level may leave things out, but it must not say anything the next level would have to take back. If a simple wording would be wrong (not just incomplete), choose different wording and tell me why. After each version add two lines: - "Leaves out:" what this level skips. - "New words:" vocabulary that appears at this level for the first time. Finally, write one question about the idea that a student could answer using any of the three versions, so the whole class can discuss it together. Do not invent studies, numbers or examples I cannot check. If you are unsure of a claim, mark it "check this". Rules for this task: - Grade or comment on the quality of the reasoning, not on whether the final answer is correct. A wrong answer argued well is a good answer. - Do not invent sources, citations, quotations, statistics or standards. If you are not sure something is true, say "I am not sure" instead of guessing. - Do not do the students' thinking for them. Ask questions or point to where to look; do not hand over the answer unless I ask for an answer key. - Keep it short and in plain language for a middle or high school class. - Anything you produce is a draft for me to check before it reaches a student.
-
8. Supports without changing the task
Protects: Every student does the same thinking. Only the help differs, and none of the help gives away the answer.
Show the prompt
Here is a task for my [grade] class, exactly as students will see it: [paste the task] Do not change the task and do not make it easier. Write three supports a student can choose to use, and keep the task identical with all of them: 1. A word bank of the terms a student needs, with no definitions or hints that give away the answer. 2. Sentence frames that organize the thinking (for example "I predict ... because ..."), with no science content filled in. 3. A list of labels for a diagram, in alphabetical order, for students to place themselves. Do not place them. Then check your own work: list anything in the supports that tells a student what the answer is, and rewrite it so it does not. Rules for this task: - Grade or comment on the quality of the reasoning, not on whether the final answer is correct. A wrong answer argued well is a good answer. - Do not invent sources, citations, quotations, statistics or standards. If you are not sure something is true, say "I am not sure" instead of guessing. - Do not do the students' thinking for them. Ask questions or point to where to look; do not hand over the answer unless I ask for an answer key. - Keep it short and in plain language for a middle or high school class. - Anything you produce is a draft for me to check before it reaches a student.
-
9. A rubric that grades reasoning, not correctness
Protects: A wrong answer argued well earns full credit for thinking.
Show the prompt
Write a 4-level rubric for grading student reasoning on this task: [paste the prediction question]. The rubric must score the reasoning only. It must give the same credit to a wrong prediction with a careful reason as to a right prediction with a careful reason. Describe each level in one sentence a student could understand, using observable features such as: names a mechanism, uses evidence given in the problem, states what would change their mind, or notices a competing explanation. Then give me two short example student reasons for each level: one attached to a correct answer and one attached to a wrong answer. Mark the examples as invented illustrations. Rules for this task: - Grade or comment on the quality of the reasoning, not on whether the final answer is correct. A wrong answer argued well is a good answer. - Do not invent sources, citations, quotations, statistics or standards. If you are not sure something is true, say "I am not sure" instead of guessing. - Do not do the students' thinking for them. Ask questions or point to where to look; do not hand over the answer unless I ask for an answer key. - Keep it short and in plain language for a middle or high school class. - Anything you produce is a draft for me to check before it reaches a student.
-
10. A "state the rule and what would prove it wrong" item
Protects: Students must say what evidence would change their mind, which is the opposite of recalling a fact.
Show the prompt
For this topic in my [grade] biology class: [topic], write 3 "keystone" prompts. Each one asks the student to do two things in writing: 1. State, in their own words, the general rule or idea behind what we just studied. 2. Describe a finding or experimental result that would prove their rule wrong. For each, give me a short note on what a strong answer contains and one common weak answer. Do not write model answers longer than two sentences. Base everything on standard introductory biology; flag anything that is a simplification. Rules for this task: - Grade or comment on the quality of the reasoning, not on whether the final answer is correct. A wrong answer argued well is a good answer. - Do not invent sources, citations, quotations, statistics or standards. If you are not sure something is true, say "I am not sure" instead of guessing. - Do not do the students' thinking for them. Ask questions or point to where to look; do not hand over the answer unless I ask for an answer key. - Keep it short and in plain language for a middle or high school class. - Anything you produce is a draft for me to check before it reaches a student.
-
11. Turn a "where I'm stuck" note into a next question
Protects: The student says in writing where they are stuck before anything is explained. You get a question to ask back, not an answer to hand over.
Student writing goes in here. Remove every name and ID first.
Show the prompt
A student wrote this note about where they are stuck. Name and ID removed. Topic: [topic] Stuck note: [paste] Do not explain the topic. Instead: 1. Say in one sentence what you think the student is actually confused about, and how sure you are. 2. Write two questions I could ask them that would help them find the way out themselves. 3. Suggest one thing in our materials for them to reread ([list your readings]), described by heading, not by page number. If the note is too vague to work with (fewer than about 25 words, or no specific confusion), tell me what to ask the student to add. Rules for this task: - Grade or comment on the quality of the reasoning, not on whether the final answer is correct. A wrong answer argued well is a good answer. - Do not invent sources, citations, quotations, statistics or standards. If you are not sure something is true, say "I am not sure" instead of guessing. - Do not do the students' thinking for them. Ask questions or point to where to look; do not hand over the answer unless I ask for an answer key. - Keep it short and in plain language for a middle or high school class. - Anything you produce is a draft for me to check before it reaches a student.
-
12. Two or three questions to ask a student out loud
Protects: A short conversation checks whether the reasoning is the student's own, without a test and without a detector.
Student writing goes in here. Remove every name and ID first.
Show the prompt
Below is one student's written reasoning about this question: [paste the question]. The name and ID have been removed. [paste the student's reasoning] I want to talk with this student for about two minutes. Write 2 or 3 questions I can ask out loud. Each one should: - ask the student to explain one step in their own words, or say what finding would change their mind; - be easy for a student who did the thinking, and hard for a student who pasted someone else's answer. This is a conversation, not a test. Do not tell me whether the reasoning is right, and do not write answers. If the writing is too short to build questions from, say so instead. Rules for this task: - Grade or comment on the quality of the reasoning, not on whether the final answer is correct. A wrong answer argued well is a good answer. - Do not invent sources, citations, quotations, statistics or standards. If you are not sure something is true, say "I am not sure" instead of guessing. - Do not do the students' thinking for them. Ask questions or point to where to look; do not hand over the answer unless I ask for an answer key. - Keep it short and in plain language for a middle or high school class. - Anything you produce is a draft for me to check before it reaches a student.
-
13. Sort your students' own questions into a curiosity list
Protects: Students' questions become part of the course instead of disappearing.
Student writing goes in here. Remove every name and ID first.
Show the prompt
Below are questions my students asked this week about [topic], with names removed. Some are about the lesson; some go beyond it. [paste the anonymous questions, one per line] 1. Group them: questions about the lesson itself; questions that connect to medicine, health or everyday life; questions that go deeper into the science; questions nobody can answer yet. 2. For each group, pick the one question that would make the best 3-minute opener for my next class, and say why. 3. For questions that go beyond what we teach, suggest where a student could look to explore it (describe the kind of source; do not invent specific titles or links). 4. Do not answer the questions yourself. The point is for the class to work on them. Rules for this task: - Grade or comment on the quality of the reasoning, not on whether the final answer is correct. A wrong answer argued well is a good answer. - Do not invent sources, citations, quotations, statistics or standards. If you are not sure something is true, say "I am not sure" instead of guessing. - Do not do the students' thinking for them. Ask questions or point to where to look; do not hand over the answer unless I ask for an answer key. - Keep it short and in plain language for a middle or high school class. - Anything you produce is a draft for me to check before it reaches a student.
-
14. Fact-check a generated passage, claim by claim
Protects: Humans verify what AI drafts. This prompt makes the check visible instead of trusting a smooth paragraph.
Show the prompt
Below is a passage that was written by an AI tool for my students. Treat it as untrusted. [paste passage] 1. Split the passage into separate factual claims, numbered. 2. For each claim, label it: "well established", "imprecise or oversimplified", "probably wrong", or "I cannot tell". 3. For anything not "well established", say what is wrong or missing and propose a corrected sentence. 4. Do not give a source, a date, a name, or a number unless you are certain of it. When you are not, write "needs a source" and tell me what to search for. 5. At the end, list the 3 claims I should check against my textbook first. Be suspicious. Assume there are at least three problems in the passage, and say honestly if you find fewer. Rules for this task: - Grade or comment on the quality of the reasoning, not on whether the final answer is correct. A wrong answer argued well is a good answer. - Do not invent sources, citations, quotations, statistics or standards. If you are not sure something is true, say "I am not sure" instead of guessing. - Do not do the students' thinking for them. Ask questions or point to where to look; do not hand over the answer unless I ask for an answer key. - Keep it short and in plain language for a middle or high school class. - Anything you produce is a draft for me to check before it reaches a student.
-
15. Move up a level of abstraction
Protects: It is about ambition, not about speed. Use the time saved to ask a bigger question, not to do the same lesson faster.
Show the prompt
I have just finished building this: [describe a lesson, a unit, or an activity you already have]. Help me go up one level of abstraction. Suggest 5 more ambitious versions of the same goal, for example: one lesson becoming a whole unit, a standard question becoming a question that points each student back to the specific section they need, or a one-class activity that other teachers could reuse. For each, tell me: 1. What I would have to build. 2. Which part still needs a human expert to check before students see it. 3. The biggest way it could go wrong. Be realistic about what one teacher can maintain. Do not invent tools or products; if you suggest software, describe the kind of tool rather than naming a product. Rules for this task: - Grade or comment on the quality of the reasoning, not on whether the final answer is correct. A wrong answer argued well is a good answer. - Do not invent sources, citations, quotations, statistics or standards. If you are not sure something is true, say "I am not sure" instead of guessing. - Do not do the students' thinking for them. Ask questions or point to where to look; do not hand over the answer unless I ask for an answer key. - Keep it short and in plain language for a middle or high school class. - Anything you produce is a draft for me to check before it reaches a student.
From the workshop
Shared by the workshop organizers. Each opens in a new tab.
- Workshop slides (opens in a new tab)
- Participant-generated resources folder (opens in a new tab)
- VDOE Life Science and Biology resources (opens in a new tab)
- High School Biology folder (opens in a new tab)
- How-to guide for getting started with generative AI (opens in a new tab)
- Prompt library (opens in a new tab)
- Virginia Science Standards of Learning (opens in a new tab)
- GoOpenVA science plans (opens in a new tab)
Also free: The Molecule Hunters
The Molecule Hunters: How Biochemists Decoded the Chemistry of Life was written with more than 500 UVA biochemistry students. It has 133 profiles of 190 scientists, every one began as an AI deep-research dossier, and the students checked them. It is free as a PDF, an EPUB and an audiobook. Errors found after publication go on a live fact-check page, each with what the book says, what the record shows, and the source.
The book (opens in a new tab) Live fact-check page (opens in a new tab)
Sources
Every number in the talk, with its source and year, grouped by slide. Where a number is my own data, from one small graduate class, or comes from a secondary report, the page says so.
Tell us
Found a mistake, or want a lesson that is not here? The form is anonymous; no sign-in, and email is optional.
Report an error or request a lesson
These pages use only facts from the talk, its fact files, or this site’s own repository. More: contact.