# What Do Plants Need?

> You and your child grow radish seedlings in four cups, then take away light, water or both and watch for two weeks. Your child finds out that a plant kept in the dark grows tall, thin and pale before it weakens, and that a plant with no water droops first.

Course: Biology Together (What plants need and how they work). Level: ages 5–10, with a parent or teacher. About 30 minutes.
Lesson page (link this one when citing): https://stemhop.com/lessons/what-plants-need/

Builds on: Wake Up a Seed

## Before you start

Hands-on timeAbout 30 minutes, plus 3 to 10 days for seeds to sprout, then 5-minute checks every day or two for about 2 weeks WhereIndoors Ages5 to 10, with an easier and a harder version below Grown-upAn adult pokes the drainage holes and opens the potting mix. Stay nearby while your child plants and waters; the child does the looking, drawing and measuring.

### What you need

- 4 small cups (paper or clear plastic, about 9 oz), with 3 or 4 holes poked in each bottom by an adult
- A tray or baking dish to stand the cups in
- Potting mix, enough to fill the cups
- A packet of radish seeds (grass seed also works but is slower)
- Water and a tablespoon
- A sunny windowsill, plus a cupboard or a large cardboard box for a dark place
- Masking tape and a marker for labels
- A fifth cup for a seed-in-the-dark test (optional)
- A ruler marked in centimetres (ages 8 to 10)
- Paper and a pencil, or the printed observation sheet below

Virginia science standards SOL 1.4 aSOL K.7 aSOL 4.2 aSOL 4.2 b

*Figure (AI-generated illustration).* At a glance: print this card or keep it open while you work. The full steps and safety notes are below. Image: at-a-glance card for What Do Plants Need? You need: Four small cups, Potting mix, Radish seeds, Water, Tray. Set up: 1, Seeds in four cups; 2, Sprout on a windowsill; 3, Two cups go dark; 4, Two cups get no water. Look for: Dark: usually tall, thin, pale; No water: usually droops. Safety: Adult opens potting mix. Wash hands after.

## The big idea

Put one cup of seedlings in a cupboard and leave one on a windowsill. Within a week they often look like different plants. The one in the dark grows tall, thin and pale yellow. The one in the light stays shorter, sturdier and green.

Plants need water, air, light, nutrients and a place with room to grow. This activity tests two of those needs, light and water, with a **fair test**: a test where only one thing changes and everything else stays the same. Same soil, same cups, same seeds. Each pair of cups you compare differs in just one thing, light or water.

*Figure (AI-generated illustration).* The test starts with four cups that were all grown the same way. Two stay on the windowsill and two move to the dark. In each place, one cup keeps its water and one gets nothing more. Image: two scenes side by side. On the left, a sunny windowsill with a tray holding two paper cups of tiny seedlings. On the right, the dark inside of a cupboard with a tray holding two more paper cups of tiny seedlings. The four cups are marked light plus water, light with no water, dark plus water and dark with no water.

Light matters because a green plant makes its own food. Its leaves use light energy to turn water and carbon dioxide, a gas from the air, into sugar, and they give off oxygen. This is **photosynthesis**. A seedling in the dark lives on food it has stored, some from its seed and some made earlier in the light. When that runs out it cannot make more. Plants do not get their food from soil. Soil holds the roots, water and small amounts of nutrients.

## What to do

1. **Set up.** An adult opens the bag and dampens the mix first (see the safety box). Then fill four cups with damp potting mix to about 2 cm below the rim. Label them “light + water”, “dark + water”, “light, no water” and “dark, no water”. Stand them on the tray.
2. **Plant.** Have your child press 4 or 5 radish seeds about 1 cm deep into each cup and cover them. Give each cup 2 tablespoons of water. With a class, give each group of four one tray of four cups.
3. **Grow them all the same.** Keep all four cups on a sunny windowsill. Water each the same amount whenever the top feels dry. Radish sprouts usually appear in 3 to 10 days, faster in a warm room. Wait until most seedlings are about 2 cm tall.
4. **Predict.** Before you change anything, ask your child what will happen to each cup. Write or draw their guesses on the sheet.
5. **Start the test.** Move the two “dark” cups, on a plate or a second tray, into the cupboard or under the box. Keep giving the two “water” cups 2 tablespoons when the top feels dry. Give the two “no water” cups nothing more. Change nothing else. If you have a fifth cup, plant fresh seeds in it, water it, and put it straight into the dark.
6. **Check every day or two.** Open the cupboard, look quickly, and put the cups back. Draw each cup. Ages 8 to 10 measure the tallest seedling in each cup in centimetres. Note the colour, the height, and whether the leaves droop.
7. **Notice the changes.** The dry cups usually droop within 2 to 5 days, sooner in small cups and warm rooms. Within about a week, the dark, watered seedlings are often taller, thinner and paler than the windowsill ones, and they lean or flop. Over 1 to 2 weeks they grow weaker. The “light + water” cup stays green and upright.
8. **Bring one back (optional).** Move a pale “dark + water” cup back to the windowsill. If it is not too weak, its leaves usually turn green over a few days.

## Questions to ask while you do it

Ask your child to guess first, then check.

- “What do you think will happen to a plant that gets water but no light?”
- “I wonder which cup will droop first. Why that one?”
- “The dark plant is the tallest. Is it the healthiest? How could we tell?”
- “I wonder if a seed needs light to sprout. How could we find out?”
- “What do you think will happen if we put the pale plant back in the sun?”
- “Where do you think a plant gets its food?”

## What children often think

- A child might say “Plants eat dirt.” You could try Ask, "If plants ate soil, what would happen to the soil in the pot?" It hardly goes down as the plant grows. Plants make their own food in their leaves from air, water and light. Soil holds the roots and gives water and small amounts of nutrients.
- A child might say “More water is always better.” You could try Ask how they could test it, then add a cup that stands in a dish of water all the time. Over a week or two its leaves may yellow or droop. Roots need air as well as water, and soaked soil holds very little air.
- A child might say “The dark one grew tallest, so it’s the best.” You could try Ask your child to look at colour and strength as well as height. Is it green? Can it stand up? A seedling in the dark stretches on food it has stored, and it grows weaker once that food runs out.
- A child might say “Seeds need light to sprout.” You could try Try the fifth cup, kept in the cupboard from the day you plant. Radish seeds sprout in the dark, using food stored in the seed. Light matters once the seedling has leaves and its stored food runs low.

## Why it works

A seed carries stored food. It uses that food to sprout and push up its first leaves. Radish seeds do this in light or in dark, though a few kinds, such as some lettuce, need light to sprout. After that, a green plant makes nearly all of its own food by photosynthesis. **Chlorophyll**, the green colouring in leaves, captures light energy. The plant uses that energy to join carbon dioxide with water, making sugar and giving off oxygen.

In the dark, seedlings grow in a different way, called **etiolation**. A seed that sprouts in the dark, like the one in the fifth cup, grows a long pale stem with tiny yellow leaves, because little chlorophyll forms. Green seedlings moved into the dark do something similar: the stem keeps stretching and new growth is pale, while the green leaves slowly turn yellow. In nature this stretching can carry a buried or shaded seedling up to light. In a cupboard there is no light to reach, so the seedling uses up its stored food and then weakens and dies.

*Figure (AI-generated illustration).* What you will usually see in about a week. Seedlings grown in the dark are often taller, thinner and paler than those on the windowsill, and a cup with no water droops. Image: two paper cups of seedlings side by side. The left cup holds tall, thin, pale yellow seedlings that lean over; the right holds short, sturdy green ones. A small inset shows a cup of dry soil with drooping green seedlings.

Water has several jobs too. It is one of the raw materials for sugar, it keeps the cells firm so stems stand up, and it carries nutrients up from the roots.

## Easier and harder

### Ages 5 to 7

Use only two cups, both watered: one on the windowsill and one in the dark. That gives one clear difference. Skip measuring. Have your child draw both cups every few days, using crayons that match the real leaf colours. At the end, hold the two plants side by side and ask which one looks stronger and why.

### Ages 8 to 10

Let your child plan the test: what will change, what stays the same, and what to measure. Measure the tallest seedling in each cup in centimetres every two days and keep a table. At the end, make a bar graph with one bar per cup. Ask whether one cup for each condition is enough. Two cups of each makes the result more trustworthy.

## If it doesn’t go as planned

No sprouts after 10 days usually means a cold room or old seeds; try a fresh packet in a warmer spot. Fuzzy mould on the soil means it is staying too wet. An adult throws that cup away, as the safety box says, and you can start a new one with a little less water. If the “no water” cups do not droop, the mix may hold a lot of water; give it a few more days. If light leaks into the cupboard, use a box with no gaps. If the windowsill seedlings are also tall and floppy, the window is too dim; next time, use your brightest window.

## Observation sheet

Observation sheet

### What do plants need?

NameDate

Each time you check, draw or measure each cup.

| Day | Light + water | Dark + water | Light, no water | Dark, no water |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
|  |  |  |  |  |
|  |  |  |  |  |
|  |  |  |  |  |
|  |  |  |  |  |
|  |  |  |  |  |
|  |  |  |  |  |
|  |  |  |  |  |
|  |  |  |  |  |

Draw the light + water plant

Draw the dark + water plant

I think the plant in the dark will:

What really happened:

stemhop.com · Biology Together

---

From STEMhop (https://stemhop.com), free lessons by Christopher Deppmann. Lesson text © the authors. Practice questions: https://stemhop.com/lessons/what-plants-need/
