# Variation and Survival

> When inherited variations affect reproductive success, populations change across generations. Run a model population under a pressure you control, then read real data on tuskless elephants in Mozambique and on how many young blue crabs and elephants produce. Afterwards you can explain where variation comes from, why only some offspring survive, and what before-and-after data can and cannot show.

Course: Biology (Evolution). Level: grades 7–12. About 40 minutes.
Lesson page (link this one when citing): https://stemhop.com/lessons/variation-and-survival/

Builds on: Meiosis and Variation · From DNA to Protein

## What you'll learn

- You will explain how mutations, gene flow and sexual reproduction (the shuffling of chromosomes in meiosis) create variation within a population and change its gene pool.
- You will explain that populations produce more offspring than the environment can support, that individuals with certain variations are more likely to survive and reproduce, and that reproductive strategies and rates (many young with little care, or few young with much care) affect survival.
- You will analyze before-and-after data on a trait in a population under an environmental pressure, and make a claim about what changed and why, separating what the data show from what they do not.

**In Mozambique’s Gorongosa National Park, soldiers on both sides of a civil war that lasted from 1977 to 1992 killed elephants for ivory. Before the war, about 1 in 5 of the females researchers sampled had no tusks; among the females that survived the war, about half had none.** No elephant had to lose her tusks for those group percentages to change.

> **The one idea.** When inherited variations affect reproductive success, populations change across generations.
>
> *Scope:* This rule describes natural selection. It works only when variants are inherited and the current conditions make the individuals that carry them leave different numbers of offspring. Mutation, gene flow and genetic drift (chance) can also change populations. Under some conditions, selection keeps a mix steady instead of changing it.

What do you think? Decide before you read.

1. Each elephant evolved during the war and stopped growing tusks. Agree Disagree **Scientists disagree:** Whether an elephant grows tusks depends on the genes she was born with. What changed was the population: researchers compared photos of females from before the war with females seen afterwards. Tuskless females were already present before the war and survived poaching more often, so their share of the population rose. What scientists think **Scientists disagree:** Whether an elephant grows tusks depends on the genes she was born with. What changed was the population: researchers compared photos of females from before the war with females seen afterwards. Tuskless females were already present before the war and survived poaching more often, so their share of the population rose.
2. Animals try to adapt, so they change when their environment gets dangerous. Agree Disagree **Scientists disagree:** Natural selection needs no wanting or trying. Variations arise by chance, from mutations and from the reshuffling of alleles in reproduction, whether or not they help. When the environment changes, individuals that happen to carry a helpful variation survive and reproduce more often. Field studies, such as moths released on tree branches, measure this difference in survival directly. What scientists think **Scientists disagree:** Natural selection needs no wanting or trying. Variations arise by chance, from mutations and from the reshuffling of alleles in reproduction, whether or not they help. When the environment changes, individuals that happen to carry a helpful variation survive and reproduce more often. Field studies, such as moths released on tree branches, measure this difference in survival directly.
3. When a species evolves, all of its members change at the same time. Agree Disagree **Scientists disagree:** Different variants usually keep living side by side. In Gorongosa, about half of the females that survived the war still had tusks, and most daughters born after the war had tusks. Evolution is a change in how common an inherited variant is in a population over generations, not every member changing together. What scientists think **Scientists disagree:** Different variants usually keep living side by side. In Gorongosa, about half of the females that survived the war still had tusks, and most daughters born after the war had tusks. Evolution is a change in how common an inherited variant is in a population over generations, not every member changing together.

## Explore: put a population under pressure

In this model, a population of animals carries an inherited trait, such as having tusks or not. You set how strong a pressure is, such as how often hunters take tusked animals, and whether new variations can arise by mutation. A graph tracks each trait’s share over many generations.

*Interactive on the lesson page:* Pressure on a population: tusks or no tusks

**Predict, then test.** The first film showed that with no pressure the shares change only by chance, with no consistent direction, and that a missing variant cannot be selected. In a population of limited size, chance alone can eventually remove one variant entirely. Measure what the film did not.

1. Set the pressure to zero and run it several times. How far does the share drift in 40 generations? Does one kind ever disappear?
2. Turn the pressure up to strong. Predict how many generations it takes for the share to change a lot. Then try a weak pressure and compare.
3. Start with no tuskless animals, strong pressure and new variation switched on. Predict how long tusklessness takes to spread once it first appears.

## Explain: where variation comes from

- variation
- allele
- gene pool
- mutation
- gene flow
- sexual reproduction
- natural selection
- selective pressure
- reproductive strategy

The first film drew the gene pool; here are the words for its parts.

**Variation** is the differences among individuals in a population. An **allele** is one version of a gene. The **gene pool** is all the alleles of all the individuals in a population. Three processes add to or reshape it.

- **Mutation** is a change in an organism’s DNA. It is the original source of new alleles. Many mutations have no effect, some harm, and a few help, depending on the environment.
- **Gene flow** is the movement of alleles from one population to another, when individuals move and breed or when pollen blows to another field. It can bring in an allele the population did not have.
- **Sexual reproduction** joins an egg and a sperm from two parents. You saw in [Meiosis and Variation](https://stemhop.com/lessons/meiosis-and-variation/) that meiosis shuffles chromosome pairs and swaps pieces between them. This makes new combinations of alleles that already exist, so each offspring is a new mix.

Over generations, mutation and gene flow change what is in the gene pool. Natural selection and chance (genetic drift) also change how common each allele is.

**Predict.** A mutation happens in a skin cell on an elephant’s trunk. Could her calf inherit it?

> **Check your prediction.** No. In most animals, only mutations in the cells that make eggs or sperm pass to offspring.

*Interactive on the lesson page:* Tap to enlarge gene poolmutationgene flowmeiosis and fertilizationone generation later gene poolmutationblankblankblank 

**Key idea:**

Mutation makes new alleles, gene flow moves alleles between populations, and sexual reproduction reshuffles alleles into new combinations, so populations are usually varied.

Variation is the raw material; the second film shows what a pressure does with it in Gorongosa.

**Film transcript: Reading Selection in a Population**

### Film transcript: Reading Selection in a Population

The first film followed inherited variants across generations. How can data show that selection, rather than chance, shaped a population shift? Return to the same teal and gold map, now tied to Gorongosa elephants. Teal marks tuskless females, and gold marks tusked females.

Historical film and photographs give the prewar group. Later sightings give the survivors. The bars use the reported group sizes and percentages. The teal share is higher among survivors. What changed? Did individual elephants lose tusks, or do the two groups contain different shares of elephants born with each trait?

Track two schematic animals between panels. A gold animal stays gold, and a teal animal stays teal. The survivor group contains more teal because tuskless females survived poaching more often. Ivory poaching was a selective pressure because it affected the variants differently. Tusked elephants were killed more often. The data support a change in the population's makeup, not a choice or transformation by elephants. A severe population crash can also change shares by chance.

Researchers modeled the crash with equal survival for tusked and tuskless females. The observed rise was far beyond what that chance model usually produced. Daughters born later kept tusklessness above the prewar share. That pattern fits an inherited trait and a response to selection. It still does not identify the exact allele or prove what happened to every elephant. Now widen the picture. Populations usually produce more young than their environments can support. A female blue crab carries an enormous egg mass. An elephant mother invests years in a calf. Most crab young die before reproducing. These are endpoints on a range, not two rigid boxes.

One strategy makes many young with less investment in each. The other makes fewer young with more care. Many species fall between them. For selection, count offspring that survive and reproduce. Strength, effort, and need are not the score. The conditions decide whether an inherited variant changes reproductive success. When inherited variations affect reproductive success, populations change across generations. In Gorongosa, the trait pattern, selective pressure, survival difference, and daughters all support that rule together. Before-and-after data show a pattern. The selective pressure, survival estimate, chance comparison, and later daughters make the selection explanation stronger.

Good evidence supports a claim while keeping its limits visible. Read the bars as population snapshots, not biographies. Read the filter as a comparison, not a promise. Then ask whether inherited differences changed who left the next generation.

From the film

- When inherited variations affect reproductive success, populations change across generations.
- Populations usually produce more young than their environments can support.
- A trait-frequency shift describes groups, not an individual changing during life.
- Comparisons against chance strengthen a claim that selection shaped a population.

## Explain: what the film left out

The second film showed the Gorongosa bars and the chance test in outline; here are the terms and details behind them.

**Natural selection** is the process by which individuals with certain inherited variations survive and reproduce more than others, so those variations become more common in later generations.

A **selective pressure** is anything in the environment that makes some variants more likely to survive or reproduce than others: predators, disease, drought or human hunting. In Gorongosa it was ivory poaching. In this park tusklessness is seen only in females; no tuskless male has been recorded there.

Beyond the chance test, the researchers estimated that tuskless females survived about five times as well as tusked females. They concluded that poaching most likely caused strong selection for tusklessness.

*Figure (AI-generated illustration).* Tuskless females were already part of the Gorongosa population before the war. Poachers killed tusked elephants more often, so tuskless females survived more often. Image: two female African elephants side by side on a savanna, one with a pair of tusks and one with no tusks at all.

A female blue crab in the Chesapeake Bay may carry about 750,000 to 8 million eggs, according to the Virginia Institute of Marine Science. Only a small fraction become adults.

A **reproductive strategy** is a species’ pattern of how many young it makes and how much it invests in each. Neither end of the range is always better; each can leave surviving offspring under some conditions.

|  | Blue crab | African savanna elephant |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Young per breeding | Hundreds of thousands to millions of eggs | Usually one calf |
| Care | Mother carries the eggs until they hatch | Mother nurses the calf, and births are years apart |
| Survival of each young | Very low | Higher |

*Figure (AI-generated illustration).* Two ends of a range of reproductive strategies: a blue crab carries hundreds of thousands to millions of eggs, while an elephant usually raises one calf with years of care. Image: a female blue crab carrying a large orange egg mass on the bay floor, and an elephant mother with one small calf on grassland, joined by a double-headed arrow. An inset shows the egg mass as many tiny eggs.

**Key idea:**

Populations usually produce more young than can survive, and individuals whose inherited variations suit the conditions leave more offspring, so those variations become more common.

## Elaborate: read the elephant and crab data

| Measure | Value | Units | Group or place |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Tuskless females, before the war | 18.5 (54 females) | percent | Gorongosa, before 1977 |
| Tuskless females, war survivors | 50.9 (108 females) | percent | Gorongosa, survived 1977 to 1992 |
| Tuskless daughters, first generation after the war | 33 (91 females) | percent | Gorongosa, born about 1995 to 2004 |
| Elephants in the park, all ages and sexes | 2,542 | elephants | Gorongosa, 1972 count |
| Elephants in the park, all ages and sexes | 242 | elephants | Gorongosa, 2000 count |
| Time between births, mean | 4.5 | years | Amboseli, Kenya (255 females) |
| Time between surviving calves, median | 3 | years | Gorongosa (124 intervals) |
| Blue crab egg mass, low end of reported range | 750,000 | eggs | Chesapeake Bay |
| Blue crab egg mass, high end of reported range | 8,000,000 | eggs | Chesapeake Bay |

Sources: tusk percentages and park counts from Campbell-Staton and colleagues, Science (2021), Figure 1. Amboseli births from Moss, Journal of Zoology (2001), a study begun in 1972. Gorongosa calf intervals from Poole and Granli, Pachyderm (2022), field trips 2011 to 2019. Egg mass range from the Virginia Institute of Marine Science, a summary range, not one dated sample.

**Predict.** Is the rise from 18.5 percent to 50.9 percent a change of 32.4 percentage points, or 32.4 percent?

> **Check your prediction.** It is 32.4 percentage points: 50.9 − 18.5 = 32.4. As a percent change it is 32.4 ÷ 18.5, a rise of about 175 percent.

1. Why might the daughters’ share (33 percent) be lower than their mothers’ generation (50.9 percent)?
2. Compare the two elephant interval values. Why might they differ?

Claim, evidence, reasoning

Make a claim about why tuskless females became more common in Gorongosa, using these data.

Claim Your answer to the question, in one sentence.

Start with: Tuskless females became more common because blank.

Evidence The data that support your claim.

Start with: Before the war blank percent of sampled females were tuskless, and among survivors blank percent were.

Reasoning Why the evidence supports the claim, using the science.

Start with: Poachers killed tusked elephants more often, so blank, and because tusklessness is inherited, blank.

> **Compare with a model answer.** Tuskless females became more common because poaching for ivory killed tusked elephants more often, so tuskless females were more likely to survive. In the prewar sample, 18.5 percent of 54 females were tuskless; among 108 war survivors, 50.9 percent were, a rise of 32.4 percentage points. The share among daughters born after the war, 33 percent, is still above the prewar 18.5 percent, which fits an inherited trait. The data have limits: the samples are small, the percentages count a visible trait rather than alleles, and they cannot prove what happened to each elephant or which gene causes the trait.

Saved in this browser only.

### Design problem

Plan an ethical study to test whether hunting, not chance, explains the rise in tuskless females in a park. You cannot assign hunting to elephants. What groups would you compare, what would you count, and what could mislead you?

> **One way to do it.** - **Question:** Did tuskless females become more common in parks with heavy poaching than in parks with little poaching?
> - **Comparison groups:** several parks with heavy poaching and several with little poaching, with photos or counts from before and after the same years.
> - **What you count:** the number of adult females with and without tusks in each park and period. Report the number of animals, not only the percentage.
> - **Constants:** the same definition of “tuskless”, the same age range of females, and observers trained the same way.
> - **Sample size and repeats:** as many recognized females as possible, and more than one park in each group, because one small sample can change by chance.
> - **What could mislead you:** old photos may show some animals more than others, and tuskless elephants may be easier or harder to spot. Recording each known individual once helps.
> - **Ethics:** observe and photograph only; never harm animals to test an idea.
>
> A larger rise in heavy-poaching parks than in low-poaching parks would support selection by hunting.

## Going deeper

### How quickly can a population change?

Pressure can be strong or weak. A strong pressure, like heavy poaching, can change a trait’s frequency within a few decades when inherited variation is present. A weak pressure changes it slowly over many generations. Biologists argue about how often evolution happens in quick bursts and how often it creeps along; you will meet those two ideas in [Natural Selection and New Species](https://stemhop.com/lessons/natural-selection-and-speciation/).

### Why do two sample sizes appear?

Campbell-Staton and colleagues give 52 prewar females in the paper’s text, but Figure 1 labels 54. The table follows the figure.

## Evaluate: check your thinking

The Gorongosa case fits the rule: inherited tusklessness was already present, and poaching changed which females survived to leave the next generation.

**Science practices you used:** making predictions and testing them with a model, reading a table of percentages and sample sizes, calculating a change in percentage points, planning an ethical observational study, and naming the limits of small samples and of a model.

---

From STEMhop (https://stemhop.com), free lessons by Christopher Deppmann. Lesson text © the authors. Practice questions: https://stemhop.com/lessons/variation-and-survival/
