# Sorting Living Things

> Every species sits inside eight main nested groups, from domain to species, and its two-part scientific name, the same in every country, labels its species group. You name the turkey vulture's eight groups, run a dichotomous key on Virginia organisms, and read the main levels of classification of ten species from a government database. Afterwards you can name the eight levels of classification, write a scientific name correctly, and use a key to identify a plant or animal.

Course: Life Science (Organizing and classifying life). Level: grades 7–12. About 40 minutes.
Lesson page (link this one when citing): https://stemhop.com/lessons/sorting-living-things/

Builds on: Leaf Detectives · Cells Are Everywhere

## What you'll learn

- You will explain how scientists organize living things into levels from most general to most specific (domain, kingdom, phylum, class, order, family, genus, species), what a species is, and how binomial nomenclature gives each species a two-part name.
- You will use a dichotomous key to identify Virginia plants and animals from traits you can see, including examples from the major animal phyla and the main plant divisions.
- You will read the eight main levels of classification of several Virginia organisms, from domain to species, and make a claim with evidence about which two organisms are grouped most closely.

**In Virginia, some people call vultures buzzards. In Britain, a buzzard is a hawk.** So which bird do they mean? The first film’s answer is a name built from nested boxes. Here you count the boxes, watch a wall move, then try a second tool that finds a name.

*Figure (AI-generated illustration).* One common name, two different birds. Their scientific names, Cathartes aura and Buteo buteo, tell a scientist anywhere which one you mean. Image: two perched birds side by side. On the left, a large dark turkey vulture with a small bare reddish head, labelled as the bird some Virginians call a buzzard. On the right, a brown common buzzard with a feathered head, labelled as the bird called a buzzard in Britain, a kind of hawk.

> **The one idea.** Scientists sort every species into eight main levels, nested like boxes, from domain, the most general, to species, the most specific. Its two-part scientific name is the genus name plus a second word, and the two words together label its species box. Scientists everywhere use the same name. The more boxes two living things share, the more closely they are grouped. A **dichotomous key** is a list of two-choice questions that leads to a name. It finds the name, but the order of its questions does not show how living things are grouped.
>
> *Scope:* a full classification can add extra levels, such as subspecies, to these eight main ones. The boxes here come from one government database on one day, and scientists can redraw a box when they learn more.

What do you think? Decide before you read.

1. Scientists group living things only by how they look. Agree Disagree **Scientists disagree:** Scientists compare body parts, and they also compare DNA. DNA can show that living things that look almost alike belong to different species. What scientists think **Scientists disagree:** Scientists compare body parts, and they also compare DNA. DNA can show that living things that look almost alike belong to different species.
2. A scientific name can never change once it is given. Agree Disagree **Scientists disagree:** Names can change when scientists learn more. That is why scientists write down the date they looked up a name. What scientists think **Scientists disagree:** Names can change when scientists learn more. That is why scientists write down the date they looked up a name.
3. If two living things sit next to each other in a dichotomous key, they must be close relatives. Agree Disagree **Scientists disagree:** A key names an organism from traits you can see. Reorder its questions and the neighbors change, but every name stays the same. So a key’s order alone does not show who is related. What scientists think **Scientists disagree:** A key names an organism from traits you can see. Reorder its questions and the neighbors change, but every name stays the same. So a key’s order alone does not show who is related.

## Explain: one name for each species

- species
- binomial nomenclature
- genus
- classification
- taxonomy
- domain
- kingdom
- phylum
- dichotomous key

The film’s test for a **species**, similar organisms that can mate in nature and have young that can also reproduce, is a useful rule for many organisms that reproduce with sex cells, but it has two limits. It cannot be used for organisms that reproduce without sex, such as many bacteria. And some different species do sometimes mate in nature.

The film’s way of naming, one two-part name for each species, is called **binomial nomenclature**. This way of naming spread after the Swedish botanist Carl Linnaeus used two-part names in a book about plants in 1753. The first word is the **genus**, a small group of closely related species, so one genus can hold several species. The second word, joined to the genus name, names one species in that genus. The black vulture’s full name is *Coragyps atratus*.

**Key idea:**

Each species has a two-part scientific name, the genus name then a second word, that scientists use in every country.

## Explain: eight boxes, from general to specific

**Classification** is a system for organizing and identifying organisms by the traits they share and how they are related. The science of naming and classifying living things is **taxonomy**. The film showed one **domain**, Eukarya; the other two domains are Archaea and Bacteria, whose cells have no nucleus. A **phylum** is a large group inside a kingdom, such as the arthropods, animals with a hard outer skeleton and jointed legs.

Classification works a bit like a mailing address: country, state, city and street each narrow the search. But the comparison has a limit. Houses on one street are not related to each other, while species in one genus are.

*Interactive on the lesson page:* Tap to enlarge domain Eukaryakingdom Animaliaclass Avesfamily Cathartidaespecies Cathartes aura domain Eukaryablankblank

Scientists place the walls by comparing body parts, what organisms do, and DNA ([another lesson](https://stemhop.com/lessons/domains-kingdoms-and-dna/) explores DNA). New evidence can move a wall.

The first film’s counts, 6 shared boxes for the black vulture and 5 for the hawk, used one database. It puts vultures and hawks in one order, Accipitriformes.

**Predict.** Another bird checklist, from the American Ornithological Society, gives the New World vultures their own order, Cathartiformes. Under that checklist, does the turkey vulture share more boxes with the red-tailed hawk, or fewer?

> **Check your prediction.** Fewer: 4, down to class Aves, instead of 5. The order box now closes around the vultures alone, so the hawk leaves one box sooner. The birds did not change; one wall moved. So a count of shared boxes belongs to one classification at one time.

**Remember the one idea:** the more boxes two living things share, the more closely they are grouped.

**Key idea:**

The eight main levels, from most general to most specific, are domain, kingdom, phylum, class, order, family, genus and species.

## Explore: run a dichotomous key

In the model, pick a card for one of eight Virginia organisms and answer two-choice questions about what you can see, such as “fins or no fins,” until you reach a scientific name. A switch reorders the questions.

*Interactive on the lesson page:* Dichotomous key: name eight Virginia organisms

**Try this.**

1. Pick the blue crab. Predict how many questions it takes to reach its name, then test.
2. Note which organisms sit next to the brook trout. Predict what happens to them when you flip the switch, then check.
3. Pick the eastern oyster, but give one wrong answer on purpose. Predict where you will end up. Then test.

You just watched the trout’s neighbors change. The second film asks what that means.

**Film transcript: A Key Finds a Name, Not Relatives**

### Film transcript: A Key Finds a Name, Not Relatives

How could a few two-choice questions give you the name of a crab? You find it on the shore of the Chesapeake Bay, and you do not know what it is. A key can tell you. The first film put living things in nested boxes, to show how they are grouped. This film uses a different tool, called a dichotomous key. Both tools matter, but they do different jobs. A dichotomous key is a series of two-choice steps about traits you can see. Each step splits the path in two. You follow the choice that fits, until you reach a name. Our key holds seven animals, each from a different phylum.

Step one asks, fins or no fins? The crab has no fins, so we go on. Step two asks, jointed legs or no jointed legs? The crab has jointed legs. The path ends at a name, Callinectes sapidus, the blue crab. Look at the whole key. The trout comes off the path first, the crab second, and the oyster third. Now keep every question, but change their order. Ask about the two-part shell and the five arms before the jointed legs. Watch the branches redraw. Run the crab again. It takes more steps now. But the path ends at the same name, Callinectes sapidus. Every animal keeps its name. Only its neighbors change. The crab now sits right next to the sea star.

Has the crab become more closely related to the sea star? No. Drop the animals into the boxes from the first film. The crab is in phylum Arthropoda. The sea star and the oyster are each in a different phylum. The crab shares only two boxes with each of them, the domain and the kingdom. The crab shares just two boxes with the trout, too. In either order, the boxes stay the same. Moving a question cannot make two animals closer relatives. Why does this happen? This key asks about traits that are easy to see, not who is related. So its order alone does not show who is related. The boxes show how one classification groups them. To draw the boxes, scientists compare body parts, what living things do, and DNA.

From the film

- A dichotomous key names a living thing through a series of two-choice steps about traits you can see.
- Changing the order of a key's questions changes which living things sit side by side, but every name stays the same.
- The blue crab shares only two levels, domain and kingdom, with the sea star, the oyster and the trout.
- This key's questions follow traits that are easy to see, so its order alone does not show which living things are related; the boxes show how one classification groups them.

## Explain: use a dichotomous key

Here is the second film’s whole key, so you can run an animal the film did not. Each animal’s phylum is in brackets; you do not need it to run the key.

1. Has fins: brook trout (chordate). No fins: go to 2.
2. Has jointed legs: blue crab (arthropod). No jointed legs: go to 3.
3. Has a shell of two hinged halves: eastern oyster (mollusk). No two-part shell: go to 4.
4. Has arms in a five-part pattern around a center: sea star (echinoderm). No five-part arm pattern: go to 5.
5. Has a long body made of ring-like segments: earthworm (segmented worm). No segments: go to 6.
6. Fixed to one spot, body full of tiny holes: sponge. Swims, with a soft bell and trailing tentacles: sea nettle, a jellyfish (cnidarian).

**Predict.** A garden snail has no fins, no jointed legs and one shell. Run it through this key. Where does it end up?

> **Check your prediction.** Nowhere. Its one shell is not two hinged halves. It has no five-part arms and no segments. At step 6 it is neither fixed in place with holes nor a swimming bell. A key works only for the organisms built into it.

Keys work for plants too. This one covers four plants, one from each of four main plant groups.

1. Has a woody twig: go to 2. No woody twig: go to 3.
2. Needles in bundles, with cones: loblolly pine. Broad leaves and a flower cluster with four showy bracts: flowering dogwood.
3. Large fronds with spore cases: fern. Tiny leafy plant with a capsule on a thin stalk: moss.

*Figure (AI-generated illustration).* The plant key sorts these four by traits you can see, starting with a woody twig or not. Plants are not drawn to scale. Image: four plants in a row. A tiny leafy moss with a capsule on a thin stalk; a fern with one frond turned to show rows of brown spore cases; a loblolly pine twig with needles in bundles and a cone; and a flowering dogwood twig with broad leaves and a flower cluster ringed by four white bracts. Brackets group the moss and fern as having no woody twig, and the pine and dogwood as having one.

| Plant group | Example | True tubes for water and food (xylem and phloem) | Seeds |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Mosses | moss | No | No; spores |
| Ferns | fern | Yes | No; spores |
| Conifers | loblolly pine | Yes | Yes, not inside a fruit |
| Flowering plants | flowering dogwood | Yes | Yes, inside a fruit |

**Key idea:**

A dichotomous key names an organism from traits you can see, but its order alone does not show how organisms are related.

## Elaborate: read real classifications

| Organism | Kingdom | Phylum (division) | Class | Order | Family | Genus | Species |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Turkey vulture | Animalia | Chordata | Aves | Accipitriformes | Cathartidae | *Cathartes* | *Cathartes aura* |
| Black vulture | Animalia | Chordata | Aves | Accipitriformes | Cathartidae | *Coragyps* | *Coragyps atratus* |
| Red-tailed hawk | Animalia | Chordata | Aves | Accipitriformes | Accipitridae | *Buteo* | *Buteo jamaicensis* |
| Common buzzard (Britain) | Animalia | Chordata | Aves | Accipitriformes | Accipitridae | *Buteo* | *Buteo buteo* |
| Northern cardinal | Animalia | Chordata | Aves | Passeriformes | Cardinalidae | *Cardinalis* | *Cardinalis cardinalis* |
| Brook trout | Animalia | Chordata | Teleostei | Salmoniformes | Salmonidae | *Salvelinus* | *Salvelinus fontinalis* |
| Blue crab | Animalia | Arthropoda | Malacostraca | Decapoda | Portunidae | *Callinectes* | *Callinectes sapidus* |
| Eastern tiger swallowtail | Animalia | Arthropoda | Insecta | Lepidoptera | Papilionidae | *Papilio* | *Papilio glaucus* |
| Flowering dogwood | Plantae | Tracheophyta | Magnoliopsida | Cornales | Cornaceae | *Cornus* | *Cornus florida* |
| Loblolly pine | Plantae | Tracheophyta | Pinopsida | Pinales | Pinaceae | *Pinus* | *Pinus taeda* |

**How to read the table.** The group names come from each species’ record in the Integrated Taxonomic Information System (ITIS), a government database, looked up on 23 October 2026. ITIS starts at kingdom; all ten are in domain Eukarya, so count domain as level 1. Some records have extra levels that are not shown. People who study plants often say division instead of phylum. You need not learn the long names; just compare them across rows.

**Why your textbook may look different.** ITIS puts the pine and the dogwood in one division, Tracheophyta, the plants with xylem and phloem. Many textbooks instead split plants into the four groups in the plant table. Books can also group animals differently, as with the vultures’ order. Going deeper has another example.

1. Find the blue crab and the eastern tiger swallowtail. What is the most specific level they share?
2. Which two birds share a genus? Write both scientific names correctly.
3. How many of the ten organisms are in phylum Chordata? What percent of the table is that? Use the frame: “\_\_\_ of 10 organisms is \_\_\_ out of 100, so \_\_\_ percent.”

**Predict.** Before you count: in this table, which is grouped closer to the turkey vulture, the common buzzard or the red-tailed hawk?

> **Check your prediction.** Neither: it is a tie. Each shares 5 levels with the turkey vulture, down to order Accipitriformes. Being called a buzzard does not move a bird closer.

Claim, evidence, reasoning

Make a claim that answers the essential question: if people call the same bird by different names, how do scientists know they mean the same living thing? Use the table.

Claim Your answer to the question, in one sentence.

Start with: Scientists know they mean the same bird when blank.

Evidence The data that support your claim.

Start with: In the table, the word buzzard is used for blank, but the turkey vulture is in genus blank and family blank.

Reasoning Why the evidence supports the claim, using the science.

Start with: This matters because a common name blank, while a scientific name blank.

> **Compare with a model answer.** Scientists know they mean the same bird when they use its scientific name and its classification. In the table, the British buzzard is Buteo buteo, in family Accipitridae. The turkey vulture, which some Virginians call a buzzard, is Cathartes aura, in family Cathartidae. The red-tailed hawk shares seven of eight levels with Buteo buteo; the turkey vulture shares five. A common name changes from place to place, but a scientific name is shared everywhere. Limit: these are one database’s records on one day, names can be revised, and another checklist puts vultures in a different order.

Saved in this browser only.

### Design problem

Does the order of questions in a key change how well people use it? Plan a test with picture cards.

> **One way to do it.** - **Question:** Does the order of questions change how many organisms people name correctly?
> - **Independent variable:** the order of the questions (key 1 or key 2, same questions).
> - **Dependent variables:** the number of correct names out of 10 cards, and the time in seconds to finish.
> - **Constants:** the same 10 cards, the same time limit, and no help from others.
> - **Control:** key 1, the order you started with.
> - **Trials:** at least 10 classmates per key. Report the mean score and mean time.
> - **What results mean:** similar scores suggest the order matters little for naming in this test, even though the neighbors change; compare the times too.
> - **Limit and safety:** one class and one picture set; use pictures, not live or wild-caught animals.

## Evaluate: check your thinking

A scientific name, such as *Cathartes aura*, and its place in the eight levels remove the “buzzard” mix-up between Virginia and Britain.

**Science practices you used:** using a key to identify organisms, reading and comparing data in a table, calculating a percent, making a claim with evidence, and planning a fair test with repeated trials.

## Going deeper

### The Costa Rica butterflies

In a 2004 study in Costa Rica, butterflies that looked almost alike were compared by their caterpillars, the plants the caterpillars ate, and short stretches of DNA from museum specimens. The study proposed at least ten species in that region, in a butterfly long treated as one species. Scientists still debate the exact count.

### When databases disagree

Besides the vultures’ order, Integrated Taxonomic Information System (ITIS) lists the brook trout’s class as Teleostei, while many books use the larger group Actinopterygii, the ray-finned fishes. A count of shared boxes ranks grouping in one classification; it does not tell how long ago the organisms’ most recent common ancestor lived.

---

From STEMhop (https://stemhop.com), free lessons by Christopher Deppmann. Lesson text © the authors. Practice questions: https://stemhop.com/lessons/sorting-living-things/
