# Size, Scale and Surface

> When a body grows without changing shape, its middle ends up farther from its outer surface, and diffusion time grows with the square of that distance; in a simple model of a solid ball of tissue fed from air at its surface, oxygen runs out at the centre beyond a radius of about 1.5 mm for slow tissue and a few tenths of a millimetre for busy tissue, so bodies stay thin, add internal exchange surfaces or use bulk flow. This lesson works through the geometry of size: how the ratio of surface to volume falls as a body grows, why diffusion is fast over micrometres and slow over centimetres, how deep it can reach into busy tissue, and how metabolic rate scales with body mass. Afterwards you can calculate a surface-area-to-volume ratio and a diffusion time, predict total and per-kilogram metabolic rates from a power law, and say what a fitted scaling exponent does and does not tell you.

Course: Organismal Biology (Organisms and their diversity). Level: first- and second-year university. About 18 minutes.
Lesson page (link this one when citing): https://stemhop.com/lessons/size-and-scaling/

Builds on: What an Organism Has to Do · Diffusion and Osmosis

## What you'll learn

- Calculate surface area, volume and their ratio (in units of per length) for cubes or spheres of two sizes, and explain why the ratio falls as size rises.
- Use t = L^2 / 2D to show that diffusion time grows with the square of distance, and explain why, in thick, busy animals, bulk flow does most of the carrying and diffusion finishes the last few micrometres.
- Use metabolic rate = a x M^b to predict total and per-kilogram (mass-specific) rates for two body sizes, and explain why the exponent b differs among groups and states and why its cause is still debated.
- Identify flattening, folding, branching and bulk flow as recurring answers to the surface problem, with an animal and a plant example of each.

A flatworm has no lungs and no heart, yet oxygen reaches all its cells; a mouse needs both. The first film traces why; this text adds the depth limit, plants, and energy use. It builds on [what an organism has to do](https://stemhop.com/lessons/organism-problems/).

> **The one idea.** When a body grows without changing shape, its middle ends up farther from its outer surface, and diffusion time grows with the square of that distance. In a simple model of a solid ball of tissue fed from air at its surface, oxygen runs out at the centre once the radius passes about 1.5 mm for slow tissue, or a few tenths of a millimetre for busy tissue; other shapes give other limits. So bodies stay thin, add internal exchange surfaces, or move fluid in bulk (**bulk flow**: pumped blood, air or sap), leaving diffusion only the last few micrometres.
>
> *Scope:* oxygen in metabolically active tissue, bodies compared at the same shape and density and supplied from their outer surface. The depth numbers come from an idealized model (Going deeper); low-demand tissue, or a cell with an unusual internal arrangement, shifts the limit.

## A bigger cube has less skin per unit of inside

The **surface-area-to-volume ratio**, outer area divided by enclosed volume, measures the first cost the first film’s cubes showed: less surface per bit of inside. For an ideal cube of side s, the area is 6s² (six square faces) and the volume s³.

> **Equation card: How much outer surface a cube has for each unit of volume inside it, and how that changes with size.**
>
>     surface area / volume = 6s² / s³ = 6/s
>
> In words: Surface area over volume is six s squared over s cubed, which simplifies to six over s.
>
> - 6s²: the area of the cube’s six square faces, each s × s (um²)
> - s³: the cube’s volume, s × s × s (um³)
> - 6/s: the ratio: surface per unit of volume. Area divided by volume leaves one length on the bottom, so the unit is per length. (per um)
>
> Sanity check: s sits on the bottom, so the ratio falls as the cube grows. A very small cube has a huge ratio, which is why single cells can manage by diffusion alone.
> Try one number Cancel step by step: s² / s³ = (s × s) / (s × s × s). Two s’s cancel top and bottom, leaving 1/s, so 6s² / s³ = 6/s. For a cube of side 10 um: 6/10 = 0.6 per um. A sphere of radius r gives 3/r (Going deeper).

*Figure (AI-generated illustration).* An ideal cell of side 20 um holds eight times the volume of one of side 10 um but only four times the outer surface, so the surface-area-to-volume ratio halves. These cubes are illustrative, not measured cells. Image: a small cube beside a larger cube built from eight small cubes in two layers of four, with the outer surfaces tinted gold and brackets showing the side of each. A small inset repeats the pair with an arrow between them.

For real cell sizes and shapes, see [the measured eukaryotic cell](https://stemhop.com/lessons/measured-eukaryotic-cell/).

## Diffusion: fast over micrometres, slow over centimetres

**Diffusion** is the net spread of molecules from where they are more concentrated to where they are less, driven by their random motion. Its speed is set by the **diffusion coefficient**, D. For a small molecule in water, D is about 1,000 um² per s. Crossing membranes is in [membrane transport](https://stemhop.com/lessons/membrane-transport/).

In a simple model of free diffusion along one direction, the mean squared distance travelled in time t is 2Dt; its square root is the typical distance L. Set L² = 2Dt and divide by 2D:

> **Equation card: Roughly how long diffusion takes to spread a molecule a given distance.**
>
>     t = L² / (2 × D)
>
> In words: The time is the distance squared, divided by two times the diffusion coefficient.
>
> - t: the typical time to spread a distance L along one direction (s)
> - L²: the distance, multiplied by itself (um²)
> - D: the diffusion coefficient: how fast this molecule spreads in this medium. About 1,000 um² per s for a small molecule in water. (um² per s)
>
> Sanity check: Double the distance and the time goes up four times, because L is squared. A larger D, a faster-spreading molecule, means a shorter time.
> Try one number The distance the first film skipped: L = 1 mm = 1,000 um, D = 1,000 um² per s. L² = 1,000,000 um², and 2D = 2,000 um² per s. t = 1,000,000 / 2,000 = 500 s, a little over 8 minutes. Units: um² divided by um² per s leaves seconds. These are rough, typical times (Going deeper).

## How deep can diffusion reach?

The table fills in the middle of the first film’s model-ball range, from the same idealized model:

| Oxygen use of the tissue (mL O₂ per g per hour) | Largest radius of a solid ball whose centre still gets oxygen |
| --- | --- |
| 0.05 (slow) | 1.45 mm |
| 0.3 | 0.59 mm |
| 1.0 | 0.33 mm |
| 3.0 (busy) | 0.19 mm |

For scale, a resting human averages about 0.2 mL O₂ per g per hour over the whole body; on the 3/4 fit later in this lesson, which is in energy units, a resting mouse uses about seven times as much per gram. Depth goes as one over the square root of the rate of use, so tenfold faster use (0.3 to 3.0) cuts reach only about threefold.

**Predict.** Planarians, like many flatworms, are flattened and take oxygen in by diffusion through two faces; a ball takes it in from every direction. In the same model, is a sheet’s largest half-thickness (face to middle) bigger or smaller than the ball’s largest radius?

> **Check your prediction.** Smaller. The sheet’s half-thickness limits are 0.84, 0.34, 0.19 and 0.11 mm, less than the ball’s radius at every rate by a factor of about 1.7, the square root of 3. Flattening does not allow thicker tissue; it works because length and width can grow while thickness stays under the limit.

*Figure (AI-generated illustration).* Flattening answers the surface problem in both kingdoms: in a planarian and in the lamina of a leaf, no cell is far from the outside. A compact, rounded body of the same material would leave its inside far from any surface. Image: on the left a flat leaf-shaped planarian and a thin slab with arrows entering both faces, on the right a broad green leaf blade with a midrib and a similar thin slab. A small inset shows a round solid blob with arrows entering only at its surface and a gold dot at its centre.

## Four answers in two kingdoms

**Flattening.** Besides the planarian, the blade, or **lamina**, of a typical eudicot leaf (a broad-leaved flowering plant, such as a bean) is a wide, thin sheet in which no cell is far from the surface.

**Folding.** The mammalian lung folds its exchange surface into a vast number of small air sacs, the alveoli. Exchange depends on that area divided by the barrier’s thickness, because a thin barrier is a short diffusion distance. Leaves fold surface inside too: their **mesophyll**, the photosynthetic tissue, is full of air spaces. Using X-ray [microCT](https://stemhop.com/methods/x-ray-microct/), Mathers and colleagues (2018) measured 21.3 mm² of exposed mesophyll surface per mm² of leaf area in barley and 15.5 in rice. Area over area has no units: the inside surface is fifteen to twenty times the leaf’s one-face area, unlike the cube’s ratio in per um.

**Branching.** The airways of the mammalian lung divide about 23 times in the standard textbook model of the adult human, from the trachea to the alveolar sacs. In a typical eudicot leaf, veins branch from the **midrib**, the main central vein, into finer and finer veins. Their **xylem** carries water and minerals, and dense fine veins shorten the path water must take from the xylem, through living tissue, to where it evaporates.

**Bulk flow.** Bulk flow moves a whole fluid, and everything in it, by a pressure difference or by motors. Breathing, blood circulation and sap in phloem (sugar-carrying tissue) are bulk flow ([gas exchange](https://stemhop.com/lessons/gas-exchange/), [circulation](https://stemhop.com/lessons/circulation-and-heart/), [plant transport](https://stemhop.com/lessons/plant-transport/)). Even single cells use it: in the giant cells of the alga Chara, motors drive the cytoplasm round at up to about 100 um per s.

None of these removes diffusion. In the mammalian lung, transport shifts from bulk airflow toward diffusion in the finest branches, and oxygen crosses the alveolar wall into the blood by diffusion, not by active transport.

Bulk flow has to deliver whatever the tissue burns. So how much does a body burn, and does every kilogram burn the same? The second film follows the experiments that first asked.

**Film transcript: Does Every Gram Cost the Same?**

### Film transcript: Does Every Gram Cost the Same?

A human is more than two thousand times heavier than a mouse. Does the human burn two thousand times as much energy every day? The first film showed why a thick, busy body pumps blood and air. That flow has to deliver whatever the tissue burns. So how much does a body burn? In 1883, Max Rubner asked a simple question. Does every gram of an animal cost the same to run? He studied resting dogs of many sizes. Dogs suit the question well. One species spans a wide range of sizes. So size can change without changing the kind of animal. Take one dog that is ten times heavier than another. If every gram cost the same, it would make ten times the heat.

Does it? No. Total heat rose with size, but much less steeply than mass. Each kilogram of a small dog made more heat than each kilogram of a big one. Then Rubner divided each dog's heat by its estimated body surface. The values came out roughly equal. Heat tracked surface more closely than mass. In 1932, Max Kleiber gathered resting rates for animals from rats to steers. He plotted them on logarithmic axes, where a power law becomes a straight line. Metabolic rate equals a constant, called a, times body mass raised to a power, called b. On these axes, b is the slope of the line. If b were one, every kilogram would cost the same. Kleiber's line had a slope near three quarters.

Rubner's surface rule implies two thirds. Now place a mouse and a human on the widely used three-quarter fit. The human burns far more in total, but only a few hundred times more. Divide each by body mass. Each kilogram of mouse burns about seven times as much as each kilogram of human. That is a fitted prediction, not a single measurement. In most comparisons of adult mammals and birds, b is positive but below one. So total rate rises more slowly than mass, and rate per kilogram falls as mass rises. Treat three quarters as a fit, not a law. The exponent changes with the animals, their state and the method. Its cause is still debated. So across most adult mammals and birds, bigger animals burn more in total.

But they burn less per kilogram.

From the film

- Rubner found that bigger dogs make more heat in total but less heat per kilogram.
- Metabolic rate is fitted as a constant times body mass to a power b, and b is positive but below 1 in most comparisons of adult mammals and birds: bigger burns more in total, but less per kilogram.
- On the widely used fit with b = 3/4, a mouse burns about seven times as much per kilogram as a human: a fitted prediction, not a single measurement.
- The exponent is a fitted number that changes with the animals, their state and the method, and its cause is still debated.

## Body mass and metabolism: Rubner, Kleiber and the debate

**Metabolic rate** is the rate at which an organism uses energy; **basal metabolic rate** is that rate in an adult **endotherm** (an animal that keeps itself warm with its own heat: mammals and birds) at rest, fasted, and at a temperature where it spends nothing extra on heating or cooling.

Rubner’s 1883 “surface law” is usually quoted as an exponent near 2/3, but what he reported was heat roughly constant per unit of estimated body surface. That implies 2/3 if the dogs are treated as one shape and one density: surface grows as length², mass as length³, so surface grows as mass to the power 2/3. It ruled out simple proportionality in these dogs; it did not show that surface heat loss is the cause in other animals. Kleiber’s 1932 fit, rats to steers, gave about 3/4. Both are written as power laws:

> **Equation card: How an animal’s total metabolic rate changes with its body mass.**
>
>     metabolic rate = a × M^b
>
> In words: Metabolic rate equals a constant times body mass raised to the power b.
>
> - a: a constant for the group of animals: the rate of a 1 kg animal, since 1 to any power is 1. M goes in as a plain number of kilograms, so a carries the units. (kcal per day)
> - M^b: body mass M, in kilograms, raised to the power b, the exponent. Plot log rate against log mass and the power law becomes a straight line, log rate = log a + b × log M, whose slope is b.
>
> Sanity check: If b were 1, rate would be proportional to mass: ten times the mass, ten times the rate, and the same rate per kilogram. If b is between 0 and 1, rate rises more slowly than mass, so rate per kilogram falls as animals get bigger.
> Try one number Kleiber’s b = 0.75, one animal ten times heavier than another: the rate goes up by 10^0.75, about 5.6 times, not ten (a calculator job: type 10, press the power key, type 0.75).

For rate per kilogram, divide the total by M: rate per kg = a × Mb / M. Dividing powers of the same thing subtracts exponents, Mb / M1 = Mb − 1, so

> **rate per kg = a × Mb − 1**

With b = 0.75 the exponent is −0.25, a negative power, so rate per kilogram falls as M rises.

**Worked problem.** The second film held b at 0.75 on the widely quoted mammal fit, basal metabolic rate of about 70 x M0.75 kcal per day with M in kg, whose exponent is debated. Now change b:

1. The mouse’s rate per kilogram over the human’s is (Mmouse / Mhuman)b − 1.
2. A negative power flips a fraction: that equals (Mhuman / Mmouse)1 − b.
3. The mass ratio is 70 / 0.03 = 2,333. With b = 3/4 the power is 1/4: 2,3331/4, about 7. With b = 2/3 the power is 1/3, a cube root: 2,3331/3, about 13 (check: 13 × 13 × 13 = 2,197).

The exponent alone nearly doubles the predicted difference. White and Seymour (2003) found a mammalian exponent near 2/3 once body temperature and digestive state were controlled. The exponent depends on the group, the state (basal, field or maximal), temperature and method, and no explanation of it is settled.

*Interactive on the lesson page:* Metabolic rate and body mass — a fitted power law

### Design problem

Illustrative data: plotting log basal metabolic rate against log body mass gives a slope of 0.70 for 40 rodent species and 0.68 for 40 bird species. Pooling those species with shrews and whales gives a slope of 0.76. A classmate says the pooled slope confirms that metabolic rate is set by the branching geometry of blood vessels, as one well-known network model (West, Brown and Enquist, 1997) proposes. What does each slope tell you, and what would you say to your classmate?

> **One way to do it.** Each slope is an estimate of b for that set of animals. Within rodents, a 100-fold rise in mass predicts about 1000.70, roughly 25 times the total rate (100 is 10², so 1000.70 = 101.4); within birds, about 1000.68, roughly 23 times. The pooled slope is a different quantity. Adding shrews and whales stretches the mass range, and if the groups differ in their constant a, the line through all of them can be steeper or shallower than the line within any one group. At 0.76, a 100-fold rise predicts about 33 times the rate.
>
> Before trusting any of the three, ask how the rates were measured (basal, field or maximal), at what temperature, and with what regression. Related species are not independent points, so a phylogenetic regression may give a different slope from an ordinary one; see [reading phylogenetic trees](https://stemhop.com/lessons/reading-phylogenetic-trees/).
>
> To your classmate: a slope near 3/4 is consistent with the network model, but so are other explanations, and the within-group slopes here are nearer 2/3. A fitted number cannot confirm a mechanism. Testing one would need a prediction that rival explanations do not share, checked in data collected under the same conditions.

## Does a lower rate per kilogram rescue a big body?

**Predict.** On the 3/4 fit, a kilogram of human burns about a seventh of what a kilogram of mouse burns, and the depth table says slower tissue is supplied more deeply. Could that let a human-sized body shaped like a mouse live on diffusion through its skin?

> **Check your prediction.** No; it helps, but far too slowly. Reach grows only with the square root of the drop in demand. From mouse to human the body gets about 13 times wider (2,3331/3), but the reach grows only about 2.6-fold on the 3/4 fit (the square root of 7), and about 3.6-fold with b = 2/3 (the square root of 13).

And the outer surface? For bodies of one shape and one density, b = 2/3 would keep demand per unit of outer surface constant with size, and b = 3/4 would raise it about 1.9-fold from mouse to human. That does not mean skin could supply a mammal, whose oxygen enters through its lungs. Either way, the middle moves away faster than reach grows. The one idea again: for the same shape, a bigger body means a longer path, so bodies stay thin, add inner surface or pump fluid. Next, metabolic rate meets body temperature in [thermoregulation](https://stemhop.com/lessons/thermoregulation/).

## Going deeper

### The sphere’s ratio, step by step

For a sphere of radius r, surface area over volume is 4πr² / (4/3 πr³) = 3/r. Here π (“pi”) is about 3.14, and it cancels: π over π is 1, 4 divided by 4/3 is 3, and r² over r³ leaves 1/r.

### What t = L² / 2D does and does not measure

The formula gives a typical spread along one coordinate, not the time to fill a cell or the first arrival: some molecules arrive sooner, and evening out a whole region takes longer.

### The depth model behind the table

The table uses an idealized steady-state model: uniform tissue using oxygen at a constant rate Q per unit volume, surface oxygen held at air’s P = 0.21 atm, no internal supply or carrier-bound oxygen, and the centre just reaching zero. Then the largest ball radius is √(6KP/Q) and the largest sheet half-thickness √(2KP/Q), so their ratio is √3. K is Krogh’s diffusion constant, the diffusion coefficient times oxygen’s solubility in tissue: 1.4 × 10⁻⁵ mL O₂ per cm per min per atm. To use the table’s rates in mL O₂ per g per hour, take tissue density as 1 g per cm³ and divide by 60 to get Q per cm³ per minute. The human figure of about 0.2 is a resting oxygen use of about 250 mL per minute spread over 70 kg.

Since rate per kilogram goes as Mb − 1, reach grows as M^((1 − b)/2), against a body radius growing as M1/3, assuming one shape, constant density, K and P, and tissue demand in step with the whole body’s rate per kilogram.

Stores barely help. Tissue in equilibrium with air would hold about 0.0045 mL of dissolved O₂ per mL, an upper bound, lasting about 1.3 minutes at the resting human rate, about 11 seconds at seven times that, and about 5 minutes at the table’s slowest rate. Real tissue oxygen and carrier-bound stores differ.

### More on the exponent

**Allometry** is the study of how a trait changes with body size when it does not change in simple proportion. Griebeler and Werner (2016), comparing ordinary and phylogenetic regression across 17 mammalian orders, found no single exponent for all the groups.

### A limit with exceptions

These limits are conditional. Volland and colleagues (2022) described a bacterium, Candidatus Thiomargarita magnifica, whose cells averaged more than 9,000 um long: shape and internal arrangement can push a single cell far beyond the usual size.

---

From STEMhop (https://stemhop.com), free lessons by Christopher Deppmann. Lesson text © the authors. Practice questions: https://stemhop.com/lessons/size-and-scaling/
