# Helping Ecosystems Recover

> Remove the harm, protect what remains, and help ecosystems recover over time. You test that idea with a model of Virginia's bald eagles, then read real eagle survey counts from 1977 to 2016. You also trace how people change ecosystems near and far, and why conservation and restoration can help without making recovery fast, complete or exactly like the past.

Course: Life Science (Changing ecosystems). Level: grades 7–12. About 40 minutes.
Lesson page (link this one when citing): https://stemhop.com/lessons/restoring-ecosystems/

Builds on: People Change Habitats · Big Changes: Dead Zones, Storms and Climate · The Carbon and Water Cycles

## What you'll learn

- You will explain how changes in living and nonliving factors, natural or caused by people, can change ecosystems, including changes in climate, water supply, air quality, energy production, ocean acidification and waste management.
- You will explain how people affect places far beyond their own ecosystem (burning fossil fuels, clearing forests, industry), and how sustainable practices, conservation and restoration can protect and improve ecosystems.
- You will read Virginia bald eagle survey counts from several decades and make a claim, with evidence and reasoning, about whether and how people helped the population recover.

The first film ends with a rule. Here you test it in more than one ecosystem.

**The one idea:**

Remove the harm, protect what remains, and help ecosystems recover over time.

**Scope:**

This works when people can reduce what causes the damage, and when key living things, habitat or natural processes remain or can return. It does not promise recovery that is fast, complete or exactly like before.

First, decide what you think now.

What do you think? Decide before you read.

1. What people do does not really affect the environment. Agree Disagree **Scientists disagree:** Carbon dioxide from burning coal, oil and gas is warming Earth. People can also help. After the United States banned most uses of the pesticide DDT and protected eagles, Virginia’s yearly surveys counted far more eagle pairs. What scientists think **Scientists disagree:** Carbon dioxide from burning coal, oil and gas is warming Earth. People can also help. After the United States banned most uses of the pesticide DDT and protected eagles, Virginia’s yearly surveys counted far more eagle pairs.
2. Once an ecosystem is damaged, it can never recover. Agree Disagree **Scientists disagree:** By 1933, a disease and a hurricane had wiped out eelgrass in Virginia’s coastal bays. Scientists later spread eelgrass seeds there, and a 2020 study reported thousands of hectares of meadow. A review of 400 studies found that damaged places often improve, but full recovery is less common. What scientists think **Scientists disagree:** By 1933, a disease and a hurricane had wiped out eelgrass in Virginia’s coastal bays. Scientists later spread eelgrass seeds there, and a 2020 study reported thousands of hectares of meadow. A review of 400 studies found that damaged places often improve, but full recovery is less common.
3. A recovered ecosystem will be exactly the same as it was before. Agree Disagree **Scientists disagree:** Scientists sampled small animals in the restored eelgrass meadows. Within a few years they looked much like a natural meadow nearby, and later some kinds turned up that the natural meadow lacked. A place can recover and still be different, because ecosystems keep changing. What scientists think **Scientists disagree:** Scientists sampled small animals in the restored eelgrass meadows. Within a few years they looked much like a natural meadow nearby, and later some kinds turned up that the natural meadow lacked. A place can recover and still be different, because ecosystems keep changing.

## Explore: bring the eagles back

The simulation is a made-up model, not Virginia’s survey. It shows a Bay shoreline and a bar of eagle nests for each decade from the 1950s to the 2020s. You choose when a harmful pesticide is banned, or never ban it. You also set how much shoreline forest is protected and whether a new pollution problem begins.

*Interactive on the lesson page:* Bald eagle nests on a Bay shoreline: ban the pesticide, protect forest

**Try this.** Ban the pesticide in 1972. Compare low and high forest protection. Then switch on the new pollution problem, which starts in 2000, after the bars have risen.

**Predict 1.** What will the new pollution problem do after the model population has recovered?

> **Check your prediction.** The bars fall. Recovery does not make a population safe from every later pressure. Its bar heights are invented, so use it to test ideas, not to report Virginia’s history.

## Explain: changes start chains of effects

- biotic factor
- abiotic factor
- fossil fuel
- deforestation
- ocean acidification
- pesticide
- conservation
- restoration
- sustainable practice

A **biotic factor** is a living part of an ecosystem, such as eelgrass, oysters or eagles. An **abiotic factor** is a nonliving part, such as water, air, sunlight or temperature. A change in either kind, natural or caused by people, can start a chain of effects.

**Predict 2.** A disease and a hurricane had wiped out eelgrass in Virginia’s coastal bays by 1933. Which change was biotic, and which was abiotic?

> **Check your prediction.** The disease was a biotic change because disease involves living organisms. The hurricane was an abiotic change because a storm is nonliving.

## Explain: what the eagle survey can show

The first film showed three harms to eagles (DDT, habitat loss and illegal shooting) and the protections that eased them. It left out the date. In 1972, the United States banned most uses of DDT, once a common **pesticide** (a chemical used to kill pests) in this country.

*Figure (AI-generated illustration).* DDE, which forms when DDT breaks down, made many bald eagle eggshells thin. Thin shells often broke while the parents sat on them, so few young were raised. Image: a bald eagle sits on a large stick nest in a tree by a river. Two close views compare eggs: one with a thick shell and a chick inside, and one with a thin, cracked shell and no chick.

**Conservation** means protecting living things and their habitats so they last. Saving eagles was conservation. Test the film’s explanation against selected years from the real survey.

| Breeding year | Eagle pairs (occupied nesting territories) | Chicks counted in spring |
| --- | --- | --- |
| 1977 | 33 | not listed |
| 2003 | 435 | 454 |
| 2004 | 428 | 612 |
| 2005 | 453 | 657 |
| 2007 | 560 | 737 |
| 2008 | 584 | 864 |
| 2010 | 684 | 883 |
| 2011 | 726 | 938 |
| 2016 | 1,070 | not listed |

Work one comparison. From 1977 to 2011, the count rose by `726 − 33 = 693` pairs. The later count was `726 ÷ 33 = 22` times the earlier count.

That is strong evidence of a long rise. The film named one limit, search coverage. Here are the details. The survey flew from late winter into spring over the Bay’s tidal rivers and the lower Eastern Shore. Each pair means two adults using and caring for a nest. The survey did not count every eagle. The searched area grew over time. By 2016, ground checks and volunteer reports from inland counties also contributed. The table cannot show how much each protection caused.

**Predict 3.** From 2003 to 2004, the pair count dipped. Did the chick count also dip?

> **Check your prediction.** No. Pairs fell from 435 to 428, while chicks rose from 454 to 612. One year’s pair count does not tell the whole story. Weather and survey coverage can also change.

Use the table again:

1. Find the next year after 2004. What happened to the pair count?
2. Compare 2007 and 2008. Did both pairs and chicks rise?

Claim, evidence, reasoning

Make a claim that answers the question: can people help a damaged ecosystem come back? Use the eagle table.

Claim Your answer to the question, in one sentence.

Start with: The data show that Virginia’s eagle population blank after people blank.

Evidence The data that support your claim.

Start with: The survey counted blank pairs in 1977 and blank pairs in blank, with a dip in blank.

Reasoning Why the evidence supports the claim, using the science.

Start with: DDE from DDT made eggshells blank, so after the ban and nest protection, more eggs could blank.

> **Compare with a model answer.** People can help a damaged population come back. Virginia’s survey counted 33 eagle pairs in 1977, 726 in 2011 and 1,070 in 2016, with a small dip from 435 to 428 in 2004. DDE from DDT thinned eggshells, so many eggs broke. After the United States banned most DDT uses in 1972 and protected eagles and nests, more eggs could hatch. One limit: the table cannot show how much each action helped, and the area searched changed over the years.

Saved in this browser only.

**Key idea:**

Remove the harm, then measure recovery over time. A long rise can include a small dip.

## Explain: from nearby changes to global effects

People also change living and nonliving factors. You met habitat loss and invasive species in [People Change Habitats](https://stemhop.com/lessons/people-change-habitats/). These six areas show other pathways.

| Area | What people do | One effect |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Climate | Burn coal, oil and gas | Carbon dioxide builds up in the air and warms Earth |
| Water supply | Pump water from streams and wells | Streams can carry less water |
| Air quality | Release exhaust from cars and factories | Ozone near the ground can slow photosynthesis in sensitive trees, such as black cherry and tulip poplar |
| Energy production | Run power plants | Some release carbon dioxide and air pollutants; some return warmer water to rivers |
| Ocean acidification | Add carbon dioxide to the air | The ocean absorbs it and becomes more acidic |
| Waste management | Throw away, reuse or treat waste | Wastewater with extra nutrients can feed algae; reusing things saves energy |

**Predict 4.** A smokestack adds carbon dioxide to the air. Will its climate effect stop at a country’s border?

> **Check your prediction.** No. Air moves around the planet, so carbon dioxide from one place adds to climate change elsewhere. Factories can also pollute air and water far away.

A **fossil fuel** is a fuel formed from ancient living things, such as coal, oil or natural gas. **Deforestation** is clearing forests for farms, roads or towns. Burning fossil fuels and clearing forests both add carbon dioxide to the air.

The ocean absorbs some of that gas. **Ocean acidification** means seawater becomes more acidic as it absorbs carbon dioxide. Seawater is still not an acid like vinegar. But the change leaves less of the material oysters use for shells and corals use for skeletons.

Burning fossil fuels also moves carbon from underground into the air ([The Carbon and Water Cycles](https://stemhop.com/lessons/carbon-and-water-cycles/)). Extra fertilizer adds nitrogen to rivers. Changes can help too: new meadows and forests take in carbon dioxide for photosynthesis.

*Interactive on the lesson page:* Tap to enlarge power plantdeforestationcarbon dioxideocean acidificationoyster power plantblankblankblankoyster Word ban

**Key idea:**

An action can change a living or nonliving factor, that change can travel, and organisms can respond nearby or far away.

Easing pressure let Virginia’s eagles recover because breeding pairs remained to raise young. What if a habitat has almost nothing left to restart it?

**Film transcript: When Stopping Harm Is Not Enough**

### Film transcript: When Stopping Harm Is Not Enough

The first film showed eagles recovering after people reduced harm and protected nesting places. But what if the harm stops and an ecosystem still cannot restart? A bare Virginia bay gives us that puzzle. The water moves, but no meadow grows. The bay once held eelgrass meadows. A disease was a living, or biotic, change. A hurricane was a nonliving, or abiotic, change. Together they wiped out the eelgrass in these coastal bays. The green meadow disappeared. Few green plants remained to continue the cycle. Later, the water could support eelgrass again. Yet almost no plants remained to make seeds. Once the disease and storm had passed, the door was open.

But nothing nearby could walk through it. Recovery was blocked by a missing starter population. Suitable conditions alone could not make seeds appear. Conditions are suitable again, but there is almost no seed source. Will the meadow refill by itself? Or must something supply the missing starter? Keep watching the empty bay while you choose. Notice which piece the picture lacks.

Scientists supplied the starter. They spread eelgrass seeds by hand in marked plots. This is restoration: helping a damaged ecosystem recover. The action did not build a finished meadow. It placed living starters where suitable conditions could support them. Their choice matched the barrier they had found. Seeds grew into plants. Those plants made more seeds, which moved beyond the plots. Green patches widened into a meadow over time. The recovery used both human help and the plants' own reproduction once the missing starter returned. The plots became sources instead of final borders. Recovery does not mean an exact rewind. A restored place can improve while some parts remain missing.

It can also gain kinds of organisms absent from a nearby natural meadow. Ecosystems keep changing, even during successful recovery. Different does not automatically mean failed. That limit changes the first decision. Protecting a healthy ecosystem is safer than trying to rebuild it later. When damage has happened, first reduce its cause. Then ask what remains, what is missing, and what evidence will show progress. Restoration begins with diagnosis, not one favorite tool. The eagle and eelgrass stories use different parts of one rule. Remove the harm, protect what remains, and help ecosystems recover over time. The needed help may be protection, a missing starter, or another repair.

The outcome still needs patient measurement. The rule guides action without promising a perfect return.

From the film

- Suitable water was not enough because almost no eelgrass remained to make seeds.
- Scientists supplied the missing starter by spreading eelgrass seeds in plots.
- A recovering ecosystem can improve without becoming exactly like the past.
- Remove the harm, protect what remains, and help ecosystems recover over time.

## Explain: helping a damaged place heal

In the second film, **restoration**, helping a damaged ecosystem recover, meant supplying a missing starter. The film did not show other kinds of repair work, or the evidence that recovery has limits.

*Figure (AI-generated illustration).* Eelgrass restoration supplied missing seeds; new plants then made seeds that spread beyond the planted plots. Image: three side views of a shallow bay. First, a person in a boat scatters eelgrass seeds over two marked plots. Second, short eelgrass grows in the plots. Third, eelgrass fills the plots and spreads beyond them into a wide meadow.

Other Virginia projects build oyster reefs in rivers such as the Lafayette, keep strips of trees along streams and upgrade wastewater plants ([Big Changes](https://stemhop.com/lessons/eutrophication-and-big-changes/)). A **sustainable practice** meets people’s needs now and leaves enough resources for the future. Using only the fertilizer crops need and reusing things are examples.

The evidence for those limits:

- **It is often partial.** A review of 400 studies found that damaged places often improved, but full recovery was less common while scientists watched.
- **It can look different.** Within a few years, small animals in the restored eelgrass looked much like those in a nearby natural meadow. Later, the restored meadow held some kinds the natural meadow lacked.
- **Protection is safer than repair.** A 2017 study found that restoration cannot always replace protecting a healthy ecosystem.
- **The kind and length of damage matter.** Recovery needs the cause reduced or removed, and long-lasting damage is harder to undo.

- After blank was banned, the number of eagle pairs blank.
- A recovered ecosystem can still differ from before because blank.

**Key idea:**

Remove the harm, protect what remains, and help ecosystems recover over time. Recovery is often slow, partial and different.

## Elaborate: test a sustainable practice

Does a strip of plants along a stream keep soil from washing into the water? Plan a fair test with trays of soil.

**Predict 5.** After the same amount of water, which tray will lose less soil: bare soil or soil with grass at its lower end?

> **Check your prediction.** The grass tray should lose less soil if the strip slows runoff and holds soil. The test still has to measure the result.

> **One way to do it.** - **Question:** Does a strip of grass sod at the low end of a soil tray reduce the soil that washes off?
> - **Independent variable:** a strip of grass sod at the low end, or bare soil.
> - **Dependent variable:** the mass of soil caught from runoff, in grams. Weigh a dry coffee filter first. Pour the runoff through it, let the filter dry, weigh it again and subtract the filter’s mass. Very fine clay may pass through the filter.
> - **Control:** trays of bare soil with no grass strip.
> - **Constants:** the same soil, tray size, slope, amount of water (500 mL) and pouring speed.
> - **Repeated trials:** three trays of each kind. Find the mean for each.
> - **Safety:** wear goggles and gloves, wipe up spills so no one slips, and wash your hands.
> - **Meaning:** less soil from grass trays supports the idea that the strip holds soil back. Trays are a model, not a stream.

## Evaluate: check your thinking

Virginia’s eagle counts show recovery over decades, not overnight, and the counts are not perfect. Eelgrass shows why active help may be needed when a starter population is missing. People can help damaged ecosystems come back, but recovery is often slow, may be partial, and can leave a place different from before.

**Science practices you used:** testing a model and naming its limits, reading a data table and calculating change, planning a fair test, and making a claim from evidence.

## Going deeper

### Does planting beat simply ending the damage?

In a review of 400 studies, active work such as planting did not, on average, bring faster or fuller recovery than simply ending the damage. Read that result with care: few studies directly compared different restoration actions in the same place after the same disturbance. Ending a disturbance can also take substantial work.

### Where the eagle counts come from

Sources are a 2002 survey history by Watts and Byrd for 1977, yearly reports of the Center for Conservation Biology at William and Mary and Virginia Commonwealth University for 2003 to 2011, and the Center’s 2016 survey release.

---

From STEMhop (https://stemhop.com), free lessons by Christopher Deppmann. Lesson text © the authors. Practice questions: https://stemhop.com/lessons/restoring-ecosystems/
