# Mendel and Punnett Squares

> Allele separation creates inheritance chances; Punnett squares organize, not guarantee, outcomes. Build squares for one gene and two independently assorting genes, test them in a simulation, and compare their probabilities with Gregor Mendel’s real pea counts. Afterwards you can predict genotype and phenotype ratios and explain why real offspring need not match them exactly.

Course: Biology (DNA and inheritance). Level: grades 7–12. About 40 minutes.
Lesson page (link this one when citing): https://stemhop.com/lessons/punnett-squares/

Builds on: Meiosis and Variation

## What you'll learn

- You will use the terms gene, allele, dominant, recessive, homozygous, heterozygous, genotype and phenotype, and explain how probability applies to inheritance: each sex cell from a heterozygous parent has a 50 percent chance of carrying either allele.
- You will create and read Punnett squares for one-gene (monohybrid) and two-gene (dihybrid) crosses to predict genotype and phenotype ratios (3:1, 1:2:1 and 9:3:3:1), and explain why a Punnett square gives probabilities, not certainties.
- You will compare Mendel’s real pea counts with the predicted ratios and make a claim about how well the model fits, using the idea that larger samples usually come closer to the predicted ratio.

Mendel crossed true-breeding purple-flowered and white-flowered pea plants, and every offspring was purple. When those offspring fertilized themselves, he counted 224 white-flowered plants among 929, about one in four. The first film traced where the white was hiding; this page tests that answer against chance, a second gene and Mendel’s counts.

> **The one idea.** Allele separation creates inheritance chances; Punnett squares organize, not guarantee, outcomes.
>
> *Scope:* Here the one-gene crosses have two alleles with complete dominance. The two-gene cross also assumes that the genes assort independently.

What do you think? Decide before you read.

1. Dominant traits are more common than recessive traits. Agree Disagree **Scientists disagree:** Dominant only means one copy of the allele is enough for the trait to show. It says nothing about how many individuals in a population have the trait. Geneticists who count traits in real populations find some dominant traits are rare and some recessive traits are common. What scientists think **Scientists disagree:** Dominant only means one copy of the allele is enough for the trait to show. It says nothing about how many individuals in a population have the trait. Geneticists who count traits in real populations find some dominant traits are rare and some recessive traits are common.
2. A Punnett square shows exactly what traits an offspring will have. Agree Disagree **Scientists disagree:** A Punnett square lists the possible combinations and how likely each one is. Breeders and geneticists who count real offspring find the numbers wander around the prediction, especially in small families or small batches of seeds. What scientists think **Scientists disagree:** A Punnett square lists the possible combinations and how likely each one is. Breeders and geneticists who count real offspring find the numbers wander around the prediction, especially in small families or small batches of seeds.
3. If a couple has three children with a dominant trait, the fourth is sure to show the recessive trait. Agree Disagree **Scientists disagree:** Each child comes from a new egg and a new sperm, so each birth is a fresh chance. Medical genetics guides state that when both parents carry the same recessive allele, the chance is the same for every pregnancy. What scientists think **Scientists disagree:** Each child comes from a new egg and a new sperm, so each birth is a fresh chance. Medical genetics guides state that when both parents carry the same recessive allele, the chance is the same for every pregnancy.

## Explore: cross two plants and count the offspring

Pick parents for one gene or two, “plant” 10, 100 or 1,000 random computer offspring, and compare the counts with the square’s prediction.

*Interactive on the lesson page:* Cross and count: plant offspring of two pea plants

**Try this.**

1. Cross two Pp plants. Predict how many of 10 will be white, then plant 10. Repeat three times.
2. Now plant 100, then 1,000. Predict first: will the share of white move closer to one in four, or stay as scattered?
3. Cross PP with pp. Predict the offspring, then test.
4. Switch to two genes and cross two RrYy plants. Predict which seed type will be rarest, then plant 1,000 and check.

## The hidden allele

- gene
- allele
- dominant
- recessive
- homozygous
- heterozygous
- genotype
- phenotype
- Punnett square
- probability
- dihybrid cross

A **gene** is a section of DNA that is a basic unit of inheritance. Many genes code for a protein. An **allele** is one version of a gene. For most genes, the body cells of peas, like ours, carry two alleles, one from each parent. P is the purple allele and p the white one. The pair is the **genotype**. The **phenotype** is the trait you can observe or measure; it can be chemical, such as whether a body makes an enzyme.

- A **dominant** allele (capital letter) shows its trait when one copy is present.
- A **recessive** allele (lowercase letter) shows its trait here only when both copies are recessive.
- **Homozygous** means the two alleles match (PP or pp); **heterozygous** means they differ (Pp).

| Genotype | Homozygous or heterozygous? | Phenotype |
| --- | --- | --- |
| PP | homozygous dominant | purple |
| Pp | heterozygous | purple |
| pp | homozygous recessive | white |

*Figure (AI-generated illustration).* Each purple first-generation plant carried the recessive allele, allowing white flowers to return in the next generation. Image: three rows of pea plants. A purple-flowered plant crossed with a white-flowered plant gives three purple-flowered offspring; when those fertilize themselves, the next row has three purple plants and one white plant.

During meiosis, the two alleles separate into different sex cells. This is the **law of segregation**, and the [meiosis and variation lesson](https://stemhop.com/lessons/meiosis-and-variation/) follows the cell movements behind it.

**Probability** is the chance that something will happen, from 0, never, to 1, always. A Pp plant makes P and p sex cells in about equal numbers, so a sex cell picked at random has a 50 percent chance of carrying either allele. This resembles a coin toss, but nothing is tossed: meiosis physically separates the alleles.

**Key idea:**

A heterozygous parent passes on each of its two alleles with a 50 percent chance, so a recessive allele can stay hidden for a generation and then show up again.

## Build a one-gene Punnett square

A **Punnett square** is a grid that shows every way one sex cell from each parent can combine. The first film filled one in for two Pp plants. Try a cross it did not show.

**Predict.** A Pp plant makes P and p sex cells. A pp plant makes only p sex cells. Which offspring genotypes can a Pp × pp cross produce?

> **Check your prediction.** Pp or pp. Half the equally likely boxes are Pp and half are pp, so purple and white offspring are equally likely.

The first film’s Pp × Pp square is a **monohybrid cross**: both parents are heterozygous for one gene.

|  | P (1/2) | p (1/2) |
| --- | --- | --- |
| **P (1/2)** | PP | Pp |
| **p (1/2)** | Pp | pp |

*Interactive on the lesson page:* Tap to enlarge one parent’s sex cellsthe other parent’s sex cellshomozygous dominantheterozygoushomozygous recessive one

Each box has a 1 in 4 chance (1/2 × 1/2). The genotypes come out 1 PP : 2 Pp : 1 pp (1:2:1), and the phenotypes 3 purple : 1 white (3:1), because PP and Pp both look purple.

**Predict.** Two Pp parents have three purple offspring. Has the chance that their next offspring will be white changed?

> **Check your prediction.** No. Each offspring begins with a new pair of sex cells, so the chance of pp is still 1 in 4. A recessive offspring is never “due.”

The four boxes are equally likely outcomes, not four promised offspring. All four offspring could be purple: 3/4 × 3/4 × 3/4 × 3/4, about 32 percent.

**Key idea:**

A Punnett square gives the probability of each outcome, so real counts of offspring scatter around its ratios instead of matching them exactly.

So far each sex cell carried one allele of one gene. Follow a second gene and each sex cell must carry one allele of each, so the grid has to grow.

**Film transcript: Two Genes, Sixteen Chances**

### Film transcript: Two Genes, Sixteen Chances

The first film followed one gene. What changes when two genes travel through the same cross? The grid must track both allele pairs together. Mendel followed seed shape and seed color. We will use capital R and small r for shape.

Capital Y and small y track color. Each parent is heterozygous for both genes. Every sex cell receives one shape allele and one color allele. In this model, the genes assort independently. Receiving either shape allele does not affect which color allele joins it. That creates every pairing. Predict how many different sex-cell types this parent can make. Follow every path from a shape allele to a color allele.

The paths make capital R capital Y, capital R small y, small r capital Y, and ry. Each type is equally likely here. Each sex cell carries one allele for each gene. No path carries both shape alleles or both color alleles from one parent. Place those sex-cell types along both sides. The square expands to show every possible meeting. Each box receives one type from each parent. Read each box gene by gene.

Combine the shape alleles first, then the color alleles. The finished genotype controls both visible traits. Now group boxes by phenotype. A dominant shape allele makes round seeds. A dominant color allele makes yellow seeds in this model. The largest group is round and yellow. Two smaller groups carry one recessive phenotype. The smallest group is wrinkled and green. The smallest group needs recessive alleles at both genes. That combination occupies only the bottom corner of the organized grid. The ratio describes probabilities, not a promised batch. Random offspring can land unevenly. Larger samples usually settle closer to the predicted shares.

Mendel's pea counts landed close, but not exactly on the predicted groups. That is what repeated chance events should look like. This pattern needs independent assortment and complete dominance. Linked genes, close together on one chromosome, can depart from it. Other allele relationships can change it too. One gene or two, the logic stays steady. Alleles separate, sex cells combine, and the square organizes the chances. Two independent genes simply give four sex-cell types and sixteen equal chances.

From the film

- Genes that sort independently turn four sex-cell types into 9:3:3:1 chances.
- An RrYy parent makes RY, Ry, rY and ry sex cells, each with a 1 in 4 chance.
- Only 1 box in 16, rryy, gives wrinkled green seeds.
- Real counts scatter around the prediction; larger samples usually come closer.
- Linked genes, close together on one chromosome, can depart from 9:3:3:1.

## Two genes at once

A **dihybrid cross** follows two genes at once. Mendel’s plants were heterozygous for seed shape (R round, r wrinkled) and seed color (Y yellow, y green). The second film built their four sex-cell types: RY, Ry, rY and ry. Each type has a 1 in 4 chance only if getting R or r does not affect getting Y or y. That is the **law of independent assortment**, and it holds well for genes on different chromosomes.

|  | RY | Ry | rY | ry |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| **RY** | RRYY | RRYy | RrYY | RrYy |
| **Ry** | RRYy | RRyy | RrYy | Rryy |
| **rY** | RrYY | RrYy | rrYY | rrYy |
| **ry** | RrYy | Rryy | rrYy | rryy |

Each box is one of 16 equally likely outcomes, because the four sex-cell types are equally likely. It is not a promise about the next 16 seeds. Grouped by phenotype:

> round yellow : round green : wrinkled yellow : wrinkled green = 9 : 3 : 3 : 1

**Predict.** Ignore color. What share of the seeds are expected to be wrinkled?

> **Check your prediction.** Wrinkled needs rr: four of the 16 boxes (rrYY, two rrYy, rryy), or 1 in 4. Because shape sorts independently of color, each gene still gives its own one-gene 3:1.

Genes close together on one chromosome are linked and can depart from 9:3:3:1. The Biology II ladder previews other patterns that change phenotype ratios.

## Test the model against Mendel’s counts

For seven traits, Mendel let hybrid plants fertilize themselves and counted the second generation. In each row, the first trait listed is the one every first-generation plant showed.

| Trait | Dominant count | Recessive count | Total | Recessive share (%) |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Seed shape: round vs wrinkled (seeds) | 5,474 | 1,850 | 7,324 | 25.3 |
| Seed color: yellow vs green (seeds) | 6,022 | 2,001 | 8,023 | 24.9 |
| Flower color: purple vs white (plants) | 705 | 224 | 929 | 24.1 |
| Pod form: inflated vs constricted (plants) | 882 | 299 | 1,181 | 25.3 |
| Unripe pod color: green vs yellow (plants) | 428 | 152 | 580 | 26.2 |
| Flower position: along stem vs at tip (plants) | 651 | 207 | 858 | 24.1 |
| Stem length: long vs short (plants) | 787 | 277 | 1,064 | 26.0 |

Counts are from Mendel’s paper, printed in Brno in 1866 (English translation, *Experiments in Plant Hybridization*). Each row is one experiment on one trait, counting seeds or plants as labelled; the paper gives no harvest year per row. Recessive share = recessive count ÷ total.

**Predict.** Before reading the last column, is 224 white plants out of 929 closer to 24 percent or 32 percent?

> **Check your prediction.** 224 ÷ 929 × 100 is about 24.1 percent, close to the predicted 25 percent.

In his dihybrid experiment, Mendel counted 556 seeds from 15 plants: 315 round yellow, 108 round green, 101 wrinkled yellow and 32 wrinkled green. A 9:3:3:1 ratio predicts about 313, 104, 104 and 35.

1. Which two traits had the largest samples? How close were their recessive shares to 25 percent?
2. Which trait had the smallest sample, and how far was its share from 25 percent?
3. In the dihybrid count, which category was furthest from its prediction, and by how many seeds?

Claim, evidence, reasoning

Make a claim about how well the Punnett square model predicts real offspring, using Mendel’s counts.

Claim Your answer to the question, in one sentence.

Start with: Mendel’s counts show that the Punnett square model blank.

Evidence The data that support your claim.

Start with: For the seven traits, the recessive share ranged from blank to blank percent, and the dihybrid counts were blank compared with a prediction of blank.

Reasoning Why the evidence supports the claim, using the science.

Start with: The counts are close but not exact because each offspring blank, and larger samples blank.

> **Compare with a model answer.** Mendel’s counts fit the Punnett square model well, but not exactly. For all seven traits, the recessive share was between 24.1 and 26.2 percent, close to the predicted 25 percent. The dihybrid counts of 315, 108, 101 and 32 were each within 4 seeds of the 9:3:3:1 prediction. The counts are not exactly 3:1 because each offspring is a separate chance event. The two largest samples, over 7,000 seeds each, came closest to 25 percent. One limit is that the rows are different traits, not one trait tested at several sample sizes, and all come from one researcher’s garden peas.

Saved in this browser only.

### Design problem

You have a purple-flowered pea plant. You do not know whether it is PP or Pp. Plan a cross that would tell you, and decide how many offspring you need.

**Predict.** Should you cross the unknown plant with PP, Pp or pp to make a hidden p allele easiest to detect?

> **One way to do it.** Cross the purple plant with a white plant (pp). This is a test cross. A PP parent can only give P, so every offspring would be purple. A Pp parent gives p half the time, so about half the offspring would be white.
>
> - **What you want to find out:** the purple parent’s genotype, which you work out from the offspring.
> - **What you measure:** the number of purple and white offspring.
> - **Constants:** the same white parent line, the same soil, water, light and growing time.
> - **Control of pollen:** remove the purple flower’s stamens before they ripen, brush on pollen from the white plant, and cover the flower so insects cannot bring other pollen.
> - **Sample size:** grow at least 20 offspring. Each offspring of Pp × pp has a one-half chance of being purple, so the chance of 20 purple in a row (no white plants) is one-half multiplied 20 times: under one in a million. With only 2 offspring, it is 1 in 4.
>
> Even one white offspring means the purple parent is Pp. All purple in a large sample means it is very likely PP.
>
> *Figure (AI-generated illustration).* Removing stamens, adding chosen pollen and covering the flower keeps both parents of each seed known. Image: three steps of a controlled cross: forceps remove the stamens from a purple pea flower, a brush carries pollen from a white flower to it, and a small bag covers the flower.

## Evaluate: check your thinking

The white allele was never gone. Mendel’s purple first-generation plants were Pp, so each of their offspring had a 1 in 4 chance of receiving p from both parents, and about one plant in four did. The square organized those chances; it did not promise offspring.

**Science practices you used:** making predictions before testing, using a Punnett square as a model and naming its limits, calculating proportions from real counts, and judging how sample size affects a result.

---

From STEMhop (https://stemhop.com), free lessons by Christopher Deppmann. Lesson text © the authors. Practice questions: https://stemhop.com/lessons/punnett-squares/
