# Producers, Consumers and Decomposers

> A forest's leaf pile works like a bathtub: every autumn new leaves pour in, and decomposers drain it, sending much of each leaf into the air as carbon dioxide and water and its nutrients back to the soil, where producers use them again. You meet the three jobs (producer, consumer, decomposer), work out how tall the pile gets, run a model forest floor with and without decomposers, then read real data from bags of leaves left in a forest for two years. Afterwards you can explain how producers, consumers and decomposers depend on each other and back a claim with data.

Course: Life Science (Matter and energy in ecosystems). Level: grades 7–12. About 40 minutes.
Lesson page (link this one when citing): https://stemhop.com/lessons/producers-consumers-decomposers/

Builds on: Photosynthesis Feeds the World · Releasing Energy from Food · Food Webs and Energy

## What you'll learn

- You will explain the roles of producers, consumers and decomposers: consumers eat producers or other consumers, and when producers or consumers die, decomposers such as fungi and bacteria break them down and return nutrients that producers use again.
- You will use a model of a Virginia forest to predict what happens when one group grows, shrinks or disappears, including ways people help or harm producers, consumers and decomposers.
- You will read real leaf-bag data (mass left over time) and make a claim, with evidence and reasoning, about how decomposers return matter to the ecosystem and what can speed them up.

**In autumn, many Virginia trees drop their leaves onto the forest floor. Turn over the top layer and the older leaves below are often dark, soft and full of holes.**

The first film shows who takes the old leaves away and where they go. This lesson does the counting: how tall the pile gets, and how fast real leaves lose mass. First, decide what you think now.

What do you think? Decide before you read.

1. Predators like hawks are the most important living things in a food web. Agree Disagree **Scientists disagree:** Hawks depend on others. Producers such as trees and algae capture the energy that almost every other living thing uses. Decomposers such as fungi and bacteria return the nutrients that producers need to grow. Each role is needed. Some predators do have large effects on the rest of a food web, but no forest runs without producers and decomposers. What scientists think **Scientists disagree:** Hawks depend on others. Producers such as trees and algae capture the energy that almost every other living thing uses. Decomposers such as fungi and bacteria return the nutrients that producers need to grow. Each role is needed. Some predators do have large effects on the rest of a food web, but no forest runs without producers and decomposers.
2. Food chains are separate, so losing one kind of organism only affects what eats it. Agree Disagree **Scientists disagree:** Real ecosystems are webs. Every living thing dies, and decomposers break it down. In a model with no outside supply of nutrients, losing decomposers would leave producers short of nutrients, and that would reach the animals that eat them. What scientists think **Scientists disagree:** Real ecosystems are webs. Every living thing dies, and decomposers break it down. In a model with no outside supply of nutrients, losing decomposers would leave producers short of nutrients, and that would reach the animals that eat them.
3. Dead leaves and animals just disappear or turn into dirt by themselves. Agree Disagree **Scientists disagree:** Researchers who weigh bags of leaves left in a forest see the mass drop over many months. Fungi, bacteria and small animals do most of that work. The matter does not vanish. It goes back into the air, water and soil. What scientists think **Scientists disagree:** Researchers who weigh bags of leaves left in a forest see the mass drop over many months. Fungi, bacteria and small animals do most of that work. The matter does not vanish. It goes back into the air, water and soil.

> **The one idea: the leaf pile is a bathtub.** Producers pour new leaves in each autumn, and consumers carry some matter along. Decomposers drain the pile back into carbon dioxide, water and nutrients that producers use again. The pile stops growing when the drain takes out as much as falls in each year.
>
> *Where it applies:* this is a simple model of **matter** (the stuff living things are made of), such as carbon and nutrients. It assumes about the same leaf fall each year and decomposers that keep removing a share of the pile. In peat bogs, cold or waterlogged ground nearly stops the drain, and dead plants keep piling up. Energy does not go around: it enters as sunlight and leaves as heat ([Food Webs and Energy](https://stemhop.com/lessons/food-webs-and-energy/)).

## Explain: three jobs in an ecosystem

- producer
- consumer
- decomposer
- nutrient
- fungi
- bacteria
- respiration

A **producer** captures energy from sunlight and stores it in sugar (glucose) built from carbon dioxide and water ([Photosynthesis Feeds the World](https://stemhop.com/lessons/photosynthesis-feeds-the-world/)). Trees, grasses, mosses and algae are producers.

A **consumer** is an organism that gets energy by eating other organisms. The “order” counts steps from the producer. A deer eating acorns is a **first-order consumer**. A fox eating a seed-eating mouse is a **second-order consumer**.

A **decomposer** breaks down dead plants, dead animals and wastes. The main decomposers are **fungi** and **bacteria**. Fungi include mushrooms and molds; most of a fungus is a mass of thin threads hidden in the leaves or soil. Bacteria are single cells, far too small to see without a microscope.

| Job | Gets energy from | Forest example | In the bathtub |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Producer | sunlight | oak tree, moss | the tap |
| Consumer | eating other organisms | deer, fox, hawk | carries matter along |
| Decomposer | dead matter and wastes | fungi, bacteria | the drain |

**Key idea:**

Producers capture energy from sunlight, consumers eat other organisms, and decomposers break down dead matter.

## Explain: the drain in the bathtub

*Figure (AI-generated illustration).* Fungi and bacteria break a leaf down outside their bodies and take in the small pieces. Worms and millipedes tear leaves into bits, which gives fungi and bacteria more surface area to work on. Image: dark, holey dead leaves on soil, with white fungus threads spreading under a lifted leaf, a small mushroom, an earthworm pulling a leaf bit and a millipede chewing a leaf edge. A circular close-up shows one fungus thread releasing chemicals that break the leaf into small pieces, which move into the thread.

**Respiration** is not breathing. It is how cells release the energy in food, and in you and most forest decomposers it uses oxygen. Carbon is a large share of a dry leaf, so, as the first film showed, much of it leaves as invisible gas ([The Carbon and Water Cycles](https://stemhop.com/lessons/carbon-and-water-cycles/)).

A **nutrient** is a substance, such as nitrogen, that living things need to grow. Nutrients are a small part of a leaf’s mass. Decomposers return them to the soil, or to the water in a stream. Some of the broken-down leaf becomes the dark part of the soil. Name each numbered part of the loop below, from the oak back to its own roots.

*Interactive on the lesson page:* Tap to enlarge producerconsumerdead leaves and a dead animaldecomposersnutrients producerconsumerblankblankblank Word ba

### How tall does the pile get?

In a simple model, one autumn’s worth of leaves falls each year, and decomposers remove half the pile over the next year. Each new pile is half the old one plus 1. In year 2, half of 1 is 0.5, plus 1 makes 1.5:

| Year | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Pile just after leaf fall (autumns of leaves) | 1 | 1.5 | 1.75 | about 1.9 | almost 2 |

The pile stops near 2, because half of 2 is 1. Real leaves do not lose the same share every year, so this model cannot tell us how big a real pile gets (Going deeper).

**Abiotic factors**, nonliving conditions such as temperature and moisture, help set how fast the drain runs; leaf type and the decomposers matter too. In many forests, warm and damp weather speeds decomposers up, and cold or very dry weather slows them down.

**Predict.** In a second simple model of cold, dry years, suppose decomposers remove only a quarter of the pile each year. Does the pile still stop growing? If so, at about how many autumns’ worth? (Hint: look for the pile size where the drain takes out exactly 1 autumn’s worth.)

> **Check your prediction.** It still levels off, but higher: near 4 autumns’ worth, because a quarter of 4 is 1. Getting there takes more than ten years in this model. A slower drain means a taller pile, not an endless one.

**Key idea:**

Decomposers drain the leaf pile. They send much of each leaf into the air as carbon dioxide and water, and return its nutrients to the soil for producers to use again.

## Explore: run a forest floor for five years

Set the decomposers (none, few or many), the season, and a soil poison or compost. Bars show the leaf pile, soil nutrients and plant growth each year. The rates are made up, and all decomposers are one group.

*Interactive on the lesson page:* Forest floor over five years

**Try this.**

1. Turn the drain off. Predict the leaf pile and the plants after five years with no decomposers, then test it.
2. Set decomposers to many. Predict how a cold, dry season will change the leaf pile compared with a warm, wet one. Then test it.
3. Spray the soil poison, then add compost instead. Predict which choice gives more plant growth by year five, and check.

## Explain: when one group changes

Many changes act on the tap, the drain or both, and can reach the other groups.

- **Fewer producers (a weaker tap):** plant eaters have less food, and so may the animals that eat them. Fewer new leaves fall.
- **Fewer decomposers (a clogged drain):** dead leaves pile up. Fewer nutrients return to the soil, so plants may grow less over time.
- **More decomposers (a faster drain):** leaves break down faster, but only while dead leaves remain.

People change both sides. Clearing a forest removes producers and the new leaf litter that feeds decomposers. Planting trees adds producers. Pesticides and pollution can kill soil life and clog the drain. Raking away every leaf removes nutrients. Leaving leaves in a yard corner, or composting, feeds decomposers and shelters small animals.

- If the decomposers disappeared, the dead leaves would blank.
- Plants would then get blank nutrients, because blank.

**Key idea:**

Losing decomposers would let dead matter pile up and leave producers short of nutrients.

The model needs a removal rate. The second film follows researchers who weighed yellow birch leaves in fine mesh bags. That gives a useful rate for leaves in bags, not for a whole forest floor.

**Film transcript: Weighing the Drain**

### Film transcript: Weighing the Drain

The first film showed decomposers draining the leaf pile. But how fast does a real forest's drain run? How could you measure matter you cannot see leaving? Researchers in West Virginia found a way. In October 2011, they worked in the Weimer Run watershed, near the town of Davis. They sealed dried yellow birch leaves in mesh bags, and weighed the leaves first. Then they set the bags on the forest floor, at three heights above the stream. Five times over two years, they brought some bags back. Different bags came back each time. They dried the leaves and weighed them again. Why dry the leaves before weighing?

Wet leaves are heavier. Drying them means that water in the leaves does not change the result. Let's follow the higher site. The graph shows the percent of the starting mass left. Every bag started at 100 percent. Each later dot is an average of 8 or 9 bags. After one month, about 72 percent was left. That first drop was fast. Part of it was probably rain washing sugars and other substances out of the fresh leaves. This is called leaching. It does not need decomposers. Now jump to 12 months. About 60 percent of the mass was left. So about 40 percent was gone in one year. At 24 months, a little under half was left. The bags were still losing mass, but more slowly than in the first year.

One more thing. The mesh kept earthworms and millipedes out. On an open forest floor, would leaves break down faster or slower than in the bags? Probably faster. Worms and millipedes tear dead leaves into smaller bits. Smaller bits give fungi and bacteria more surface to work on. So the bags probably show the drain running slower than it really does. In these bags, about 40 percent drained away in a year, and about half in two. Suppose a model drain took 40 percent of the whole pile every year. The pile would level off near 2.5 autumns' worth. But these bags lost mass more slowly in year two. So two years cannot tell us how big a real pile gets.

Some early loss was probably leaching, and decomposers did some too. Weighing measures all the loss together. It cannot split decomposers from leaching or bits lost through the mesh. And it shows one kind of leaf in bags, not a whole forest floor. Weighing leaf bags measures how fast leaves lose mass.

From the film

- Researchers weighed sealed bags of dried leaves left on a West Virginia forest floor for two years.
- At the higher site, about 40 percent of the leaf mass was gone after one year and about half after two; year two was slower, so two years cannot tell how big a real pile gets.
- Part of the first month's loss was probably leaching, rain washing material out of fresh leaves, which needs no decomposers.
- Weighing measures all the mass loss together: it cannot split decomposers from leaching or bits lost through the mesh.
- The mesh kept worms out, so leaves on an open forest floor probably break down faster.

## Elaborate: two years in a bag of leaves

Here the second film’s higher site sits beside the lower site, further down the same hillside.

**Predict.** By month 24, did leaves at the lower site keep more of their mass than at the higher site, less, or about the same?

*Interactive on the lesson page:* Leaves at both Weimer Run sites kept losing mass for two years, and the lower site usually lost a little more. After 24 

Check your prediction: dots sit at the months bags came back, so they are unevenly spaced. Find month 12 on the bottom axis, go up to each line, then across to the left axis. Repeat at month 24.

- At month 12, the lower site had about blank percent of its mass left.
- At month 24, the line that is lower belongs to the blank site.
- Between months 1 and 8, the lower site’s line goes blank.

| Time after setting out (months) | Lower site: mass left (%) | Higher site: mass left (%) |
| --- | --- | --- |
| 0 (October 2011) | 100 | 100 |
| 1 (November 2011) | 68.9 | 72.0 |
| 8 (June 2012) | 70.9 | 68.9 |
| 12 (October 2012) | 54.4 | 59.7 |
| 20 (June 2013) | 51.6 | 55.8 |
| 24 (October 2013) | 41.2 | 47.8 |

Source: Atkins, Epstein and Welsch, Ecosphere, 2017, Weimer Run, West Virginia, 2011 to 2013. Two of the three sites are shown. Different bags were weighed each time, so values bounce around; more in Going deeper.

*Figure (AI-generated illustration).* Weighing dried leaves in mesh bags over months on the forest floor shows how fast they lose mass. Decomposers do much of that, but rain washing material out and bits falling through the mesh count in the weighing too. Image: three numbered steps. 1, hands seal dried leaves in a mesh bag. 2, three mesh bags lie on a forested hillside at low, middle and high spots above a stream. 3, dried leaves from an opened bag sit on an electronic balance.

1. Describe the trend at the lower site from month 0 to month 24.
2. At month 24, how much higher is the higher site’s number, 47.8, than the lower site’s, 41.2? Subtract.
3. The lower site went from 68.9 to 70.9 percent between months 1 and 8. Why might that happen when different bags are weighed each time?

Claim, evidence, reasoning

Make a claim that answers the essential question: where do fallen leaves go? Use the Weimer Run data.

Claim Your answer to the question, in one sentence.

Start with: Fallen leaves blank over time because blank.

Evidence The data that support your claim.

Start with: At the lower site, blank percent of the mass was left after 12 months and blank percent after 24 months.

Reasoning Why the evidence supports the claim, using the science.

Start with: The mass dropped because blank broke the leaves down and rain washed some material out. The lost matter went into the blank and the blank.

> **Compare with a model answer.** Fallen leaves are broken down by decomposers, and their matter returns to the ecosystem. At the lower Weimer Run site, 54.4 percent of the leaf mass was left after 12 months and only 41.2 percent after 24 months. The higher site also lost mass. Fungi, bacteria and tiny animals small enough to get through the mesh probably did much of this work. In the first month, rain probably also washed dissolved material out of the fresh leaves. The lost matter went back to the soil, water and air, partly as nutrients and carbon dioxide. One limit: weighing does not show which of these caused the loss or where the lost mass went, since some bits may also have fallen out of the bags. This was also one leaf type in one West Virginia forest watershed.

Saved in this browser only.

### Design problem

Plan an investigation to test whether moist soil makes leaves break down faster than dry soil. Use leaves, cups of soil and a balance.

> **One way to do it.** - **Question:** Do leaves lose mass faster in moist soil than in dry soil?
> - **Independent variable:** moist soil or dry soil.
> - **Dependent variable:** the dry leaf mass left after 4 weeks, in grams, and the percent of the starting mass.
> - **Constants:** the same kind of leaf, 2.0 grams of leaves per cup, dried until their mass stops changing, the same soil, cup size and room temperature.
> - **Control:** cups of dry soil with no water added.
> - **Trials:** five cups of each. Find the mean for each group.
> - **Measuring:** after 4 weeks, rinse the leaves gently. Dry them the same way as the starting leaves, and weigh them each day until the mass stops changing.
> - **Safety:** wear gloves, keep cups covered with a lid that has small holes, do not sniff moldy cups, and wash your hands. Students with mold allergies should not handle the cups.
>
> If the moist cups keep less leaf mass, moisture increased mass loss in this setup. Water can also wash material out of leaves without any decomposers, so this test alone cannot show how much of the loss came from decomposers.

## Evaluate: check your thinking

In the simple model, the pile stops growing when the drain takes out as much as falls in each year. The leaf bags show how fast one kind of leaf lost mass in mesh bags over two years.

**Science practices you used:** predicting and testing with a model, reading a line graph and a data table and finding a difference, making a claim from evidence, and planning a fair test.

## Going deeper

### Jobs, not kinds

These are jobs, not kinds of living things. An earthworm helps break down dead leaves and is also food for robins. Some do not fit any job neatly: root fungi trade nutrients with living trees.

### Decomposers or detritivores?

Some textbooks call earthworms and millipedes decomposers, others detritivores. Either way, they shred the leaves.

### Why a real pile is not exactly 2 autumns

In the leaf bags, about 40 to 46 percent of the mass was gone after one year, but only about 12 to 13 percent more in the second. That fits breakdown slowing down once the easy parts of a leaf are used up. The weather also differed between years, though. If 40 to 46 percent of the pile vanished every year, the model pile would stop near 2.2 to 2.5 autumns’ worth. Older leaves drain more slowly, so a real pile probably holds more, and two years of bags cannot say how much. Worms, kept out by the mesh, would probably speed things up. Warmth does not always speed the drain either: see the story “Warmer did not mean faster.”

### About the leaf-bag data

The leaves were yellow birch. The 100 percent at month 0 is the starting value, not a weighing of recovered bags. This is the closest real data we found; it is not from Virginia. Each later value is a mean of 8 or 9 bags, from the authors’ shared data, rounded to one decimal. The mesh holes were about 1 millimeter wide, so earthworms and millipedes could not get in.

---

From STEMhop (https://stemhop.com), free lessons by Christopher Deppmann. Lesson text © the authors. Practice questions: https://stemhop.com/lessons/producers-consumers-decomposers/
