# Predators and Prey

> Wolves usually run short of food before the moose run out: when there are few moose for each wolf, wolves tend to catch moose less often, and if they get too little food, fewer wolves survive, so the moose can recover. You use that number, moose per wolf, as a clue on a model island and then in the winter counts from Isle Royale in Lake Superior from 1980 to 2026, where food turns out to be one limit on wolves but not the only one. Afterwards you can explain how predators and prey change each other's numbers, and how herds and packs help animals get what they need.

Course: Life Science (Living together). Level: grades 7–12. About 40 minutes.
Lesson page (link this one when citing): https://stemhop.com/lessons/predators-and-prey/

Builds on: Food Webs and Energy · Producers, Consumers and Decomposers

## What you'll learn

- You will explain what a predator and its prey are, how a population of one species lives in a community with other populations, and how a food web shows who eats whom.
- You will explain how predators and prey help control each other's population sizes and the flow of energy, and how social behaviors help animals get what they need: herds that protect the group, and packs that hunt together, share prey and raise young.
- You will read Isle Royale wolf and moose counts from several decades and make a claim, with evidence and reasoning, about how the two populations affect each other.

**Scientists have surveyed the wolves and moose of Isle Royale in most winters for decades. They count the wolves and estimate the moose. The wolves have never eaten every last moose.**

The first film built a rule on a model island. Here you test it on the real one, with one clue: moose for each wolf (moose ÷ wolves). First, decide what you think now.

What do you think? Decide before you read.

1. Predators keep eating their prey until every prey animal is gone. Agree Disagree **Scientists disagree:** When prey become scarce, the predators usually run short of food first. Fewer predators survive and raise young, and the prey can recover. Scientists see this in long records of predator and prey counts, though not every population recovers. What scientists think **Scientists disagree:** When prey become scarce, the predators usually run short of food first. Fewer predators survive and raise young, and the prey can recover. Scientists see this in long records of predator and prey counts, though not every population recovers.
2. There must be more predators than prey, because predators are stronger. Agree Disagree **Scientists disagree:** Each wolf eats many moose over its life, and only part of the energy in each moose passes to the wolf. In winter 2010, Isle Royale had an estimated 510 moose and 19 wolves. The island can feed far fewer wolves than moose. What scientists think **Scientists disagree:** Each wolf eats many moose over its life, and only part of the energy in each moose passes to the wolf. In winter 2010, Isle Royale had an estimated 510 moose and 19 wolves. The island can feed far fewer wolves than moose.
3. If we remove the predators, the prey will be better off forever. Agree Disagree **Scientists disagree:** Without predators, prey numbers can grow until the animals eat much of their own food. Then many can starve. On Isle Royale, researchers found that more moose went with more bites taken from young fir trees. What scientists think **Scientists disagree:** Without predators, prey numbers can grow until the animals eat much of their own food. Then many can starve. On Isle Royale, researchers found that more moose went with more bites taken from young fir trees.

> **The one idea: wolves usually run short of food before the moose run out.** When there are few moose for each wolf, wolves tend to catch moose less often. If they get too little food, fewer wolves survive and raise pups, so the moose can recover.
>
> *What the film left out:* moose for each wolf is a rough clue, not a measure of what wolves eat. It is one number for the whole island, not each wolf’s share. By itself it cannot show that wolves are hungry, so keep that in mind each time you read “few moose for each wolf” below. The rule fits a predator that eats mostly one kind of prey, in a place like Isle Royale where neither animal can easily leave or arrive. A predator with other food may not go hungry, so it could eat one prey down to nothing. Weather, ticks, disease, inbreeding (close relatives having young together) and people moving wolves also change the counts.

| Winter | Moose (estimated) | Wolves | Moose for each wolf |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| 2019 | 2,060 | 15 | 2,060 ÷ 15 ≈ **137** |
| 2026 | 524 | 37 | 524 ÷ 37 ≈ **14** |

In 2019 there were about ten times as many moose for each wolf as in 2026. That is only a clue; you come back to 2026 below.

## Explore: run an island with wolves and moose

Bars and a line graph track moose and wolves over 40 years; a food meter shows the plants left for the moose.

*Interactive on the lesson page:* Model island: wolves and moose

**Try this.**

1. Set the starting wolves to 20. (Model numbers are not real counts.) Predict: over 40 years, does the loop keep repeating, or do the swings shrink until both lines go flat? Then run it.
2. Set the wolves to 0. Predict what will happen to the moose and to the food meter over 40 years. Then test it.
3. Press the harsh winter button once. Predict how the moose line and then the wolf line will change in the next few years. Then check.

## Explain: populations, communities and food webs

- population
- community
- predator
- prey
- food web
- first-order consumer
- second-order consumer
- herd
- pack

The first film defined **population**, **predator** and **prey**.

A **community** is all the populations that live together in one place. On Isle Royale, the community includes the wolves, the moose, the fir trees, beavers, birds and many more. The populations in a community depend on one another.

A **food web** links many food chains. A moose eats producers, the plants that make their own food, so it is a **first-order consumer** ([Food Webs and Energy](https://stemhop.com/lessons/food-webs-and-energy/)). A wolf that eats the moose is a **second-order consumer**.

> balsam fir → moose → wolf

When a wolf eats a moose, only part of the moose’s energy passes to the wolf. Every animal gives off some energy as heat, lost to the chain. So each wolf needs many moose over its life, and the island can feed far fewer wolves than moose.

*Figure (AI-generated illustration).* In the Isle Royale community, energy moves from balsam fir to moose to wolf, and every animal gives off some of its energy as heat. Image: on Isle Royale, arrows run from young balsam fir trees to a browsing moose and from the moose to two wolves. Wavy lines rise from the animals for heat, and a beaver and birds in the background stand for the rest of the community.

**Key idea:**

A population is one species in one place, a community is all the populations living together, and a food web shows who eats whom.

## Explain: how predators and prey change each other’s numbers

In the simulation the first film’s loop goes round again, with smaller swings. Look at the timing: the wolf line peaks a few years after the moose line. Put your finger on a moose peak, then slide right to the next wolf peak. Real wolves respond late because pups take time to be born and grow up. This sketch has no pups; its delay comes from made-up rates for how fast wolves are gained and lost.

*Interactive on the lesson page:* Tap to enlarge many moosewolves increasefewer moosewolves decrease many mooseblankfewer mooseblank Word bank: wolves dec

Other limits on populations, such as competition for food and space, come in [Competition and Cooperation](https://stemhop.com/lessons/competition-and-cooperation/).

**Key idea:**

Predators and prey help control each other’s numbers, so the predator population often rises and falls a little after the prey population.

## Explain: herds and packs

Many animals live in groups, and these social behaviors help them get what they need. A **herd** is a group of plant-eating animals that live and move together. More eyes can spot danger, and adults can guard young. When predators come near, adult muskoxen, large shaggy plant eaters of the far north, can form a circle with their young inside. Moose mostly live alone, so they do not.

A **pack** is a group of predators, such as wolves, that live and hunt together. Pack members share the prey they catch and help care for the pups.

*Figure (AI-generated illustration).* A herd can guard its young, and a pack hunts together, shares the prey and raises pups. Image: on the left, adult muskoxen stand in a ring facing outward with two calves inside while wolves approach. On the right, a wolf pack feeds together on a moose, and an adult wolf at a den lowers its head to feed two pups.

| Group | Who | How the group helps |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Herd | Muskoxen and other plant eaters | Spot danger and guard the young |
| Pack | Wolves | Hunt large prey, share it, raise pups |

- A herd helps prey because blank.
- A pack helps predators because blank.
- One way the two groups differ is blank.

**Key idea:**

Herds can protect prey, and packs help predators hunt, share food and raise young.

A pack can share a kill, but it cannot make more moose. **Reminder:** wolves usually run short of food before the moose run out. Does the real island follow that rule? The second film checks.

**Film transcript: What the Island's Counts Show**

### Film transcript: What the Island's Counts Show

Does the real island follow the rule? The first film used a model island, where wolves usually ran short of food before the moose ran out. Now we check the real counts. Isle Royale is an island in Lake Superior, where wolves hunt moose.

Scientists survey both animals in most winters. Wolves are counted from the air, so the wolf count is close to every wolf. Moose are too many to count one by one. Scientists count them on small squares of land and use those counts to estimate the whole island. So moose numbers are estimates. Here are the counts from many winters. The brown line is the moose. The grey line is the wolves. Some winters have no count. Look at nineteen ninety-five.

The moose line is near its highest point. There are only sixteen wolves. The counter is high, so the wolves had plenty of moose to hunt. Two winters later, the moose had dropped to about five hundred. The wolves had risen to twenty-four. The counter fell, and the wolves now had few moose to hunt. The counts alone do not say why the moose fell. Weather and food can matter too. What we can follow is the counter. So here is a question for you. Only about twenty-one moose for each wolf. What happens to the twenty-four wolves by the next winter? Pause and predict.

By the next winter, there were only fourteen wolves. Hundreds of moose were still alive. That fits the rule from the first film. But be careful. One run of counts can fit the rule. It cannot prove the cause by itself. Now jump to twenty sixteen.

Scientists counted only two wolves on the whole island. They estimated one thousand three hundred moose. The counter shoots way up. With so much food, you might expect more wolves. That did not happen. The last wolves were close relatives. Mating between close relatives is called inbreeding. The wolves carried harmful inherited traits, which added to their health problems. So a shortage of moose was not what held these wolves back. Then people stepped in. In twenty eighteen and twenty nineteen, the Park Service brought nineteen new wolves to the island. So food matters. Few moose for each wolf can mean fewer wolves. But weather, ticks, disease, inbreeding and people moving wolves also change the counts. Food is one limit on wolves, not the only one.

From the film

- On Isle Royale, a drop to few moose for each wolf came before a drop in wolves in the late 1990s.
- Counts like these fit the rule but cannot prove the cause by themselves.
- In 2016 there were plenty of moose for each wolf, yet only 2 wolves: food is not the only limit.
- Weather, ticks, disease, inbreeding and people moving wolves also change the counts.

## Elaborate: read the Isle Royale counts

Here is every winter count from 1980 to 2026, including the years the second film skipped. Moose are on top, wolves below, sharing one year axis. To read a winter, go up from its year to each line, read each on its own scale, and divide. Moose numbers are estimates, so look for big changes, not small wiggles.

*Interactive on the lesson page:* On Isle Royale the moose rose and fell many times from 1980 to 2026, yet never came close to zero. Shaded years: 1, a do

- In blank, the moose line was at about blank and the wolf line at about blank.
- From blank to blank, the moose line went blank while the wolf line went blank.
- One change the counts cannot explain by themselves is blank.

**Predict.** In 2026 there were only about 14 moose for each wolf. What do you think the wolf line will do over the next few winters? Name one thing besides food that could change your answer.

> **Check your prediction.** No one knows yet: the counts stop in 2026. By the rule, the wolves could level off or fall. Weather, disease, inbreeding and people can also change what happens.

| Winter | Wolves (animals) | Moose (estimated animals) |
| --- | --- | --- |
| 1980 | 50 | 664 |
| 1990 | 15 | 1,216 |
| 1995 | 16 | 2,400 |
| 1997 | 24 | 500 |
| 1998 | 14 | 700 |
| 2010 | 19 | 510 |
| 2016 | 2 | 1,300 |
| 2017 | 2 | 1,600 |
| 2019 | 15 | 2,060 |
| 2024 | 30 | 840 |
| 2026 | 37 | 524 |

Source: National Park Service, Isle Royale National Park, “Wolf and Moose Populations from 1980 through 2026” (downloaded 2026), winter counts for the whole island. In 2018 and 2019, the Park Service brought 19 new wolves to the island; the rise in wolves after 2018 comes from them and their pups. In the early 1980s, a dog disease called canine parvovirus spread among the wolves, and their numbers crashed from 50 to 14 in about two years.

1. About how many moose were there for each wolf in 1990? In 2024? In which year were there more?
2. On the graph, find another winter, not 1997, with few moose for each wolf. What did the wolves do by the next count? Does that fit the rule?
3. In 1980 there were only about 13 moose for each wolf, and the wolves then crashed. Read the source note under the table: why can that crash not count as clean evidence for the rule?

Claim, evidence, reasoning

Make a claim that answers the essential question: if wolves eat moose, why don't they eat every last moose? Use the Isle Royale counts.

Claim Your answer to the question, in one sentence.

Start with: Wolves do not eat every last moose because blank.

Evidence The data that support your claim.

Start with: In blank (your winter from question 2), there were only about blank moose for each wolf. By the next count, the wolves had gone from blank to blank.

Reasoning Why the evidence supports the claim, using the science.

Start with: When there are few moose for each wolf, wolves tend to blank, so blank.

> **Compare with a model answer.** Wolves do not eat every last moose because they usually run short of food first. In 2006, there were only about 13 moose for each wolf (about 385 moose and 30 wolves). By 2007, the wolves had fallen from 30 to 21, and about 450 moose were left. With few moose for each wolf, wolves tend to catch moose less often. If they get too little food, fewer wolves survive, so the moose can recover. One limit: counts from one island fit this idea but cannot prove the cause. People moved new wolves there in 2018 and 2019, and weather, ticks, disease and inbreeding changed the numbers too.

Saved in this browser only.

### Design problem

Does living in a group protect prey? Test it with a model. The prey are 30 paper squares, each 2 centimeters on a side, on a square of floor 1 meter by 1 meter. The predator is a 10 centimeter cardboard square dropped from 1 meter high. Any prey the card touches is found, but the predator eats only one prey per drop. That is a rule of the model, not true of every real predator. Plan a fair test that compares prey in one tight group with prey spread out.

> **One way to do it.** - **Question:** Do prey in a tight group lose fewer members than prey spread out?
> - **Independent variable:** how the prey are placed, in one tight group or spread out evenly.
> - **Dependent variable:** the number of prey eaten (one for each drop that touches any prey).
> - **Constants:** 30 prey, the same field, card and drop height, the same person dropping with eyes closed from random spots all over the field.
> - **Control:** the spread-out field, which you compare the group against.
> - **Trials:** 50 drops for each setup, or pool the class’s drops, since a tight group is rarely hit. Put caught prey back after each drop.
> - **Safety:** drop only paper and cardboard, and pick up all pieces.
>
> If drops land at random all over the field, a tight group is hit on far fewer drops. With the one-prey rule, it then loses fewer prey. Without that rule, one drop can catch many grouped prey, and the group can lose about as many in all. Real predators aim, though, and real herds watch and move.

## Evaluate: check your thinking

Answer the hook with numbers in three parts: one winter with few moose for each wolf, what the wolves did by the next count, and one other thing that also changed the numbers.

**Science practices you used:** testing predictions with a model, reading and comparing data in a graph and a table, making a claim from evidence, and planning a fair test.

## Going deeper

### Weather and food versus wolves

One long study found that weather and food explained more of the year-to-year change in moose numbers than wolves did. A study of records like this can show which factors go with the changes, but it cannot by itself prove a cause. Predators are one cause of change, not the only one.

### Virginia connection: the same rule?

In the Chesapeake Bay, ospreys dive for menhaden, a small fish. Would the rule fit them? Ask first whether the predator eats mostly one kind of prey.

### How pack wolves feed their pups

Adults feed the pups meat that they bring up from their own stomachs, starting while the pups are still drinking their mother’s milk.

---

From STEMhop (https://stemhop.com), free lessons by Christopher Deppmann. Lesson text © the authors. Practice questions: https://stemhop.com/lessons/predators-and-prey/
