# Double Fertilization: How a Flower Makes a Seed

> The father reaches only the embryo and the endosperm of a seed; the seed coat and the fruit wall are the mother's own tissue. In most flowering plants, counting chromosome sets from each parent shows it: the embryo carries one maternal and one paternal set, the endosperm two maternal and one paternal, and the seed coat and fruit wall none from the pollen parent. A pollen grain grows a tube and delivers two sperm to an ovule; one starts the embryo and the other starts the endosperm, the food store, and that double fertilization makes the seed. This lesson names the parts of a flower, follows pollen from anther to ovule, compares wind and animal pollination, and traces the ovule to a seed and the ovary to a fruit. Afterwards you can count the chromosomes in every part of a maize kernel and judge what evidence a claim of flower-pollinator coevolution needs.

Course: Organismal Biology (How plants work). Level: first- and second-year university. About 18 minutes.
Lesson page (link this one when citing): https://stemhop.com/lessons/plant-reproduction/

Builds on: Plants on Land · Plant Body and Growth · Plant Cells and Animal Cells

## What you'll learn

- Explain double fertilization: trace pollen from the anther down a pollen tube to the ovule, say which of the two sperm starts the embryo and which starts the endosperm, and give the chromosome number of embryo, endosperm and seed coat.
- Name the four whorls of a flower and their parts, trace pollen from meiosis in the anther to a grain of two or three cells that delivers two sperm, and distinguish pollination from fertilization.
- Compare wind and animal pollination and selfing with outcrossing, and state what evidence shows that a flower and its pollinator have coevolved.
- Describe how a seed and a fruit form, interpret Nitsch's strawberry experiment, and explain dormancy, germination, dispersal and asexual reproduction by stolons, tubers and apomixis.

**Dust the silks of a white-kernelled maize plant with pollen from a plant true-breeding for yellow kernels, and the ear that ripens on the white plant this season fills with yellow kernels.** The first film counted the chromosome sets in a kernel; here those sets solve the yellow ear.

> **The one idea.** The father reaches only the embryo and the endosperm; the seed coat and the fruit wall are the mother’s own tissue. Counting **chromosome sets** (one set is the chromosomes of one egg or sperm) from each parent, written maternal + paternal, shows it: embryo 1 + 1, endosperm 2 + 1, seed coat and fruit wall 2 + 0. The pollen tube brings one paternal set in each of its two sperm.
>
> *Scope:* flowering plants whose embryo sac grows from one spore and whose central cell holds two copies of the maternal set: Arabidopsis, maize and most species. Water lilies, most lilies and plants that make seed without fertilization change the numbers, not the logic (Going deeper).

## The parts of a flower: four rings of organs

For the count, three parts matter: the anther, the stigma and the ovule. A **flower** is a short shoot that bears the reproductive organs of a flowering plant (an angiosperm). Typically the organs sit in four rings, or **whorls**, on the swollen tip of the flower stalk, the **receptacle**. From the outside in:

- **Sepals**, together called the **calyx**, are often green and enclose the bud.
- **Petals**, together the **corolla**, are often coloured.
- **Stamens** are the male organs. Each is a stalk, the **filament**, holding an **anther**, where pollen forms.
- **Carpels** are the female organs. A carpel has a sticky tip, the **stigma**, a neck, the **style**, and a swollen base, the **ovary**, which holds one or more **ovules**.

Not every flower has all four whorls. Maize has male flowers in the tassel and female flowers on the ear, and each silk is a long style and stigma, covered in hairs that catch pollen.

*Figure (AI-generated illustration).* A flower's four whorls from the outside in: sepals, petals, stamens and carpels, on the receptacle. Pollen forms in the anther; the ovules sit in the ovary. In maize each silk is a long style and stigma. Image: a generic flower cut lengthwise, showing sepals at the base, petals, two stamens with anthers on filaments, and a central carpel with stigma, style and an ovary holding ovules, all on a receptacle. A small inset shows a maize tassel above an ear with long silks.

## Before the sperm: two tiny generations

Recall **alternation of generations** ([plants on land](https://stemhop.com/lessons/plant-diversity-life-cycles/)): a diploid, spore-making **sporophyte** alternates with a haploid, gamete-making **gametophyte**. In a flowering plant the gametophytes are the tiny generations the first film showed inside the flower; the table adds where each comes from.

|  | Male gametophyte: the **pollen grain** | Female gametophyte: the **embryo sac** |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Where | In the anther | In the ovule |
| Starts as | A diploid **microspore mother cell** divides by meiosis ([chromosomes and meiosis](https://stemhop.com/lessons/chromosomes-and-meiosis/)) into four haploid **microspores** | In Arabidopsis, maize and most flowering plants, one haploid spore, a **megaspore** |
| Becomes | Each microspore divides by mitosis into a **tube cell** (also called the vegetative cell), which grows the tube, and a **generative cell**, which divides into the two sperm | Nuclei that are all mitotic copies of the megaspore’s one set: the **egg**, a large **central cell** with two **polar nuclei**, and two **synergids** |

In Arabidopsis the two polar nuclei fuse before the sperm arrive, but the central cell still carries two maternal sets. Around the embryo sac lie one or two layers of the mother’s own diploid tissue, the **integuments**, which leave a small opening, the **micropyle**.

## Pollen meets pistil: one tube, two fertilizations

The first film kept **pollination**, the transfer of pollen from an anther to a stigma, apart from **fertilization**, the fusion of a sperm with a female cell inside the ovule, which may never follow. On a compatible stigma the grain takes up water; its **pollen tube** runs down the style, carrying sperm that have no flagella, and usually enters the ovule through the micropyle.

The film’s two fusions are **double fertilization**, and the **endosperm** they start is triploid (3n) in Arabidopsis, maize and most flowering plants. In most animals one sperm fuses with one egg, usually swimming to it ([animal reproduction](https://stemhop.com/lessons/animal-reproduction/)). Sergei Navashin (1898) and Léon Guignard (1899) first saw both fusions, in lily ovules.

### Worked problem: the yellow ear

The one idea again: embryo 1 + 1, endosperm 2 + 1, seed coat and fruit wall 2 + 0. Multiply sets by n, the chromosomes in one set, to get chromosome numbers; follow alleles through the sets to get kernel colours.

Maize (Zea mays) has 2n = 20, so n = 10. Assume one gene for endosperm colour, with yellow (Y) fully dominant over white (y); in real maize the yellow deepens with each extra Y copy.

1. *Chromosome counts.* Egg and each sperm: 1 set, 10. Central cell: 2 sets, 20. Zygote and embryo: 1 + 1 = 2 sets, 20. Endosperm: 2 maternal sets + 1 paternal set = 3 sets × 10 = 30. Seed coat and fruit wall, the mother plant’s own tissue: 20.
2. *The yellow ear.* The white-kernelled mother is yy; the pollen comes from a true-breeding yellow plant, YY.

**Predict.** What colour are this ear’s kernels, and which tissue sets it?

> **Check your prediction.** The egg is y, the central cell yy, and every sperm Y. The embryo is Yy and the endosperm yyY, so the kernels are yellow on a plant whose selfed kernels would be white. Because the endosperm is a product of fertilization, the pollen parent’s genes show in this generation’s seed: **xenia**.
>
> A colour carried in the **pericarp**, the fruit wall around each kernel, is set by the mother’s genotype, so it does not change with the pollen parent the way endosperm colour does.

**Predict.** Cross Yy ♀ × yy ♂, then yy ♀ × Yy ♂. Half the Yy parent’s gametes carry Y, so half the kernels are yellow either way. Recall that both polar nuclei copy the egg’s set. Which cross gives the deeper yellow?

> **Check your prediction.** The first. A Yy mother’s central cell is YY or yy, never Yy, so a yellow kernel’s endosperm is YYy, two doses of Y. A Y from the father comes in one sperm, so its endosperm is yyY, one dose. The rule counts sets, not alleles.

*Going deeper selfs a heterozygote on a 400-kernel ear, with an interactive.*

## Flowers and their animals: wind, insects and coevolution

Grasses such as maize, and oaks, are wind-pollinated: their flowers have small petals or none, no nectar and exposed stigmas, and shed huge amounts of light, dry pollen, almost all of which lands nowhere useful. Field mustard, Brassica rapa, is pollinated by bees and hoverflies. Its petals, scent and nectar attract visitors, and its sticky pollen travels on them to the next flower.

**Self-pollination** moves pollen to a stigma of the same flower or the same plant; **cross-pollination** moves it to another plant, and fertilization by pollen from another plant is **outcrossing**. Selfing is still sexual: it uses meiosis and fertilization, so a heterozygous plant’s selfed offspring vary. Many species, wild B. rapa among them, have **self-incompatibility**: the stigma or style rejects pollen carrying the plant’s own incompatibility alleles.

**Coevolution** is reciprocal evolutionary change between interacting lineages: each changes in response to the other ([mutualism, parasitism and coevolution](https://stemhop.com/lessons/mutualism-parasitism-coevolution/)). The Madagascar orchid Angraecum sesquipedale holds its nectar at the bottom of a spur nearly 30 cm long. In 1862 Darwin predicted a moth with a tongue to reach it; in 1903 Rothschild and Jordan described the hawkmoth Xanthopan morganii praedicta (since 2021 usually treated as a species of its own, Xanthopan praedicta).

A match like this suggests an interaction; on its own it is a hypothesis, not evidence of coevolution. Coevolution needs evidence on both sides: that moth tongues imposed selection on spur length, and that orchid spurs imposed selection on tongue length. If the tongue lengthened for other reasons and the orchid tracked it, that is one-sided adaptation.

### Design problem

Gervasi and Schiestl (2017) let fast-cycling Brassica rapa be pollinated only by bumblebees, only by hoverflies, or by hand, with three replicate populations of 36 plants per treatment. After nine generations of selection and a round of crosses between replicates within each treatment, they compared the plants of generation 11. Bumblebee-pollinated plants became taller, and bumblebees preferred them in a choice test. Hoverfly-pollinated plants self-pollinated more. Is this coevolution? What does each part of the design rule out, and what more would you need? Hint: what would **drift**, random change in small populations, do to three replicates?

> **One way to do it.** The hand-pollinated lines shared the greenhouse, so traits that changed only in insect lines are not greenhouse effects. Three replicates test repeatability: drift would push replicates in different directions, while selection by one pollinator should push them the same way.
>
> So pollinators can drive plant evolution quickly. One hypothesis for the hoverfly result: where a pollinator delivers little outcross pollen, plants that selfed may leave more offspring.
>
> It is not evidence of coevolution: only the plants were followed, so you would also need insects whose traits changed in response to the plants. And one pollinator in a greenhouse is not a field community, so the result shows what pollinators can do, not what they do in a meadow.

## From ovule to seed, ovary to fruit

A strawberry’s red flesh is the mother’s own tissue, yet it swells only after the flower is pollinated. The second film asks what tells it to grow.

**Film transcript: Why Does a Strawberry Swell?**

### Film transcript: Why Does a Strawberry Swell?

A strawberry's red flesh is the mother's own tissue, with no chromosomes from the father. So why does it swell only after the flower is pollinated? The first film counted the sets in a seed. It ended with the seed coat and fruit wall as the mother's tissue. This film asks what tells her tissue to grow. Start with the general rule. After fertilization, the ovule becomes the seed. In most flowering plants, the ovary around it becomes the fruit. A strawberry flower is unusual. It has many separate ovaries sitting on a dome. The dome is the receptacle, the swollen tip of the flower stalk. After fertilization, each ovary becomes an achene, a small dry fruit holding one seed. Those specks on the surface are the true fruits.

The red flesh is swollen receptacle. A fruit whose flesh comes from tissue other than the ovary is called an accessory fruit. Compare a tomato. Its flesh develops from the ovary itself. In 1950, Jean Paul Nitsch asked what makes the receptacle grow. He worked on young receptacles from pollinated flowers, each studded with achenes. One idea is that the receptacle grows on its own once the flower is pollinated. If so, the achenes should not matter. So Nitsch removed every achene from some young receptacles. If pollination alone were enough, what would happen to a stripped receptacle?

It did not enlarge. The intact receptacles grew, but the stripped ones stayed small. Growth needed the achenes, not just pollination. Next, Nitsch coated some stripped receptacles with a paste containing an auxin, a plant hormone. Those receptacles grew. Put the three results together. The developing achenes supply a growth signal.

Applied auxin can stand in for that signal. Notice what this does not show. Auxin was enough to restore growth. That does not prove the natural signal is auxin alone. Nor does it show how the signal moves. Back to the ledger. The flesh is all mother, two magenta blocks. In a normal fruit, it grows on a signal from the developing achenes. This is one experiment, in one kind of accessory fruit. The receptacle is the mother's tissue. But the developing achenes tell it to grow.

From the film

- After fertilization the ovule becomes the seed and, in most flowering plants, the ovary becomes the fruit, whose wall is the mother's own tissue.
- A strawberry is an accessory fruit: its red flesh is swollen receptacle, not ovary as in a tomato, and the true fruits are the small dry achenes on its surface, each holding one seed.
- Nitsch found that a pollinated receptacle stripped of its achenes did not enlarge, and that applied auxin made a stripped receptacle grow.
- So the developing achenes supply a growth signal that auxin can mimic: the receptacle is the mother's tissue, but the achenes tell it to grow. The experiment does not show that the signal is auxin alone, or how it moves.

Auxins are one family of plant hormones ([plant hormones and responses](https://stemhop.com/lessons/plant-signals/)); later work points to gibberellins in strawberry growth as well (Going deeper).

*Figure (AI-generated illustration).* Stripped of its achenes, a pollinated receptacle stays small; auxin paste restores growth, so the achenes supply a signal auxin can mimic. Image: three young strawberries side by side. The left is covered with achenes and swollen. The middle has had its achenes removed and stays small. The right has had its achenes removed and a gold smear of auxin paste applied, and it is swollen like the left. An inset shows one achene.

The **embryo** is a new diploid plant with a root tip, a shoot tip and one or two seed leaves (**cotyledons**); the **seed coat** comes from the integuments. In maize and wheat grains the endosperm persists and holds the starch; in beans, peas and shepherd’s purse (Capsella) the cotyledons absorb it as the seed develops and store the food themselves. A maize grain is a whole fruit: its thin outer layer is fruit wall, the pericarp, fused to the seed coat.

*Figure (AI-generated illustration).* Three parts of three origins: the embryo from the zygote, the endosperm from the second fertilization, the seed coat from the mother's integuments. In maize the endosperm persists; in beans the cotyledons absorb it and store the food. Image: two seeds cut lengthwise. A maize grain has a thin outer covering, a large block of endosperm and a small embryo at one side. A bean has a thin seed coat around two fat cotyledons with no separate endosperm. A small inset shows an ovary becoming a fruit around its seed.

## Waiting and travelling: dormancy, dispersal and clones

**Seed dormancy** is the failure of an intact, viable seed to complete germination under favourable conditions. In the framework used in Arabidopsis seed studies, the hormone abscisic acid (ABA) is required to induce dormancy as the seed matures. Gibberellins promote **germination**, which begins when the seed takes up water and ends when the embryonic root pushes out through the seed’s coverings.

Dandelion fruits carry a parachute of fine hairs and drift on the wind. Coconut fruits float and travel by sea. Jays and squirrels bury acorns and miss some, which germinate away from the parent oak.

Many plants also reproduce asexually. Strawberry **stolons**, or runners, are horizontal stems that root at their nodes into new plants. Potato **tubers** are swollen underground stems whose buds (eyes) sprout. **Apomixis** is seed formation in which the embryo develops without fertilization from an unreduced cell, one that keeps the mother’s full chromosome number. Dandelions are a familiar apomict.

**Predict.** Count the sets in an apomictic embryo. At a gene where the mother is heterozygous (carries two different alleles), what will her apomictic seedlings carry?

> **Check your prediction.** All of the mother’s sets (2 in a diploid mother) and none from a father: a clone, so every seedling keeps every heterozygous gene. Selfed seedlings would segregate instead. In some apomicts the endosperm still needs a sperm to form.

Engineered apomixis is being studied to keep the best hybrid crops true, but in one hybrid rice it was still inefficient (Going deeper).

## Going deeper

### Building the gametophytes, species by species

In Arabidopsis and maize the grain is shed with three cells; in lilies it is shed with two and the sperm form inside the growing tube. In the Arabidopsis embryo sac, eight nuclei form seven cells.

### When the count changes

The count assumes one megaspore and two polar nuclei. Water lilies, with one polar nucleus, make diploid endosperm, 1 maternal + 1 paternal set. Most lilies, with tetrasporic embryo sacs, regularly make 4 + 1. In apomicts the embryo carries all of the mother’s sets and none from a father, a clone of the mother.

### Selfing a heterozygote: counting kernels on an ear of 400

1. *Selfing a heterozygote.* A Yy plant self-pollinates and an ear sets 400 kernels. Both polar nuclei copy the egg’s set, so the central cell is YY when the egg is Y and yy when it is y, each with probability 1/2. The sperm carries Y or y, each 1/2, independently ([probability and crosses](https://stemhop.com/lessons/probability-and-crosses/)), so the endosperm is YYY, YYy, yyY or yyy, each 1/2 x 1/2 = 1/4. Only yyy is white. Expected, assuming random fertilization and equal kernel survival: 3/4 x 400 = 300 yellow and 1/4 x 400 = 100 white (check: 300 + 100 = 400).

*Interactive on the lesson page:* Double fertilization and kernel colour in maize

### Auxin and gibberellin in strawberry growth

In Fragaria vesca, Tian and colleagues (2022) found that a gibberellin-synthesis blocker reduced the enlargement caused by applied auxin, and auxin transport from achene to receptacle remains a proposed model.

### Engineered apomixis in hybrid rice

Liu and colleagues (Plant Communications, online 2022) followed engineered apomictic lines of the hybrid rice Chunyou 84 for four generations: 1.9 to 3.2% of tested offspring were clones, and in one field season seed set was 5.7 to 7%, against 75.9% for the unedited hybrid. These figures describe one engineered line, not engineered apomixis in general.

---

From STEMhop (https://stemhop.com), free lessons by Christopher Deppmann. Lesson text © the authors. Practice questions: https://stemhop.com/lessons/plant-reproduction/
