# Capturing Sunlight

> A plant is built mostly from air and water, powered by light: photosynthesis rearranges carbon dioxide and water into sugar and oxygen, so most of a plant's dry mass comes from the air, and photosynthesis runs only as fast as its limiting factor allows. You run a virtual leaf-disk race, read a 1600s willow experiment and Chesapeake Bay underwater-grass surveys, and finish able to write the photosynthesis equation, say where its atoms and energy go, and name what limits how fast it runs.

Course: Biology (The chemistry of life). Level: grades 7–12. About 40 minutes.
Lesson page (link this one when citing): https://stemhop.com/lessons/photosynthesis-energy-capture/

Builds on: Water and Life · What Am I Made Of?

## What you'll learn

- You will describe photosynthesis as the process in which plants, algae and cyanobacteria use light energy to turn carbon dioxide and water into energy-rich glucose and release oxygen, so that light energy is stored as chemical energy and the plant's mass comes mostly from carbon dioxide, and write the word equation and the balanced equation (6CO2 + 6H2O + light energy → C6H12O6 + 6O2).
- You will explain how the chloroplast and chlorophyll turn light energy into chemical energy, what happens to glucose (used, stored as starch, or rebuilt into other molecules), and how photosynthetic prokaryotes use membranes instead of chloroplasts.
- You will use van Helmont's willow data and Chesapeake Bay underwater-grass and light data to make and defend a claim about where a plant's mass comes from and what limits photosynthesis.

**The first film traced most of a willow’s dry mass to the air. It left two puzzles open.** The leaf gives off oxygen gas, and both carbon dioxide and water contain oxygen: which one does the gas come from? And if light adds no atoms, only energy, why does a plant stop speeding up in brighter light? Both questions matter in Chesapeake Bay, where underwater grasses spread in some years and shrink in others. Decide what you think now.

What do you think? Decide before you read.

1. A plant gets its mass from the soil. That’s what the roots are for. Agree Disagree **Scientists disagree:** A potted plant can gain a lot over years while its dried soil hardly changes. Most of a plant’s dry mass is built from carbon dioxide taken in from the air. Roots take in water, which makes up much of a living plant’s weight, and small amounts of minerals, which add little to its dry mass. What scientists think **Scientists disagree:** A potted plant can gain a lot over years while its dried soil hardly changes. Most of a plant’s dry mass is built from carbon dioxide taken in from the air. Roots take in water, which makes up much of a living plant’s weight, and small amounts of minerals, which add little to its dry mass.
2. Plants do photosynthesis and animals do respiration. Agree Disagree **Scientists disagree:** Plant cells also carry out cellular respiration, day and night. A carbon dioxide sensor shows it: a plant sealed in a dark jar makes the carbon dioxide level rise. In light, photosynthesis usually uses carbon dioxide faster than respiration releases it, so the level falls. What scientists think **Scientists disagree:** Plant cells also carry out cellular respiration, day and night. A carbon dioxide sensor shows it: a plant sealed in a dark jar makes the carbon dioxide level rise. In light, photosynthesis usually uses carbon dioxide faster than respiration releases it, so the level falls.
3. Plants make oxygen for us to breathe. Agree Disagree **Scientists disagree:** Animals do breathe oxygen that plants release, but plants do not release it for us. Oxygen comes off as a by-product when water molecules are split inside the chloroplast. The plant uses some of it in its own respiration, and the rest leaves the leaf. What scientists think **Scientists disagree:** Animals do breathe oxygen that plants release, but plants do not release it for us. Oxygen comes off as a by-product when water molecules are split inside the chloroplast. The plant uses some of it in its own respiration, and the rest leaves the leaf.

> **The one idea: a plant is built mostly from air and water, powered by light.** Photosynthesis rearranges the atoms of carbon dioxide and water into sugar and oxygen, so most of a plant’s dry mass comes from the air. Light adds no atoms, only energy. And at any moment, photosynthesis runs only as fast as its **limiting factor** allows: the scarcest input or least favorable condition.
>
> *Scope:* dry mass is the mass left after drying; much of a living plant’s fresh weight is water. Soil supplies a small but essential share of the dry mass as minerals such as nitrogen. The rate rule covers light, carbon dioxide and temperature over the range you can test here, with the other conditions held fixed. In real plants two factors can limit at once, and whole-plant growth also depends on how the plant spends its sugar.

## Explore: race leaf disks under a lamp

In this virtual lab, disks punched from a spinach leaf have had the air pulled out, so they sink in water with baking soda, which adds dissolved carbon dioxide. As oxygen gas collects inside them they float back up. You set the lamp distance, baking soda and water temperature; the time to float is plotted for you. The simulation is a sketch, not real measurements; read the shape of each graph.

*Interactive on the lesson page:* Leaf-disk float race

**Try this.**

1. Predict how the time to float will change as you move the lamp from 40 cm to 10 cm. Then test it.
2. Set the lamp close and try no baking soda, then a little, then a lot. Predict first: will more always be faster?
3. Keep light and baking soda fixed and change the temperature from cold to warm to hot. Predict, then run it.
4. Find a setting where changing one factor stops making a difference. Which factor is holding the rate back there?

## Explain: which atoms go where

- photosynthesis
- chloroplast
- chlorophyll
- stomata
- glucose
- conservation of matter
- chemical energy
- starch
- cellulose
- cellular respiration
- prokaryote
- limiting factor

**Photosynthesis** is the process in which plants, algae and cyanobacteria use light energy to turn carbon dioxide and water into **glucose**, a sugar with 6 carbon atoms, releasing oxygen:

> carbon dioxide + water + light energy → glucose + oxygen
>
> 6CO2 + 6H2O + light energy → C6H12O6 + 6O2

The first film counted the atoms on each side and found them equal: **conservation of matter**, the rule that atoms are rearranged, never created or destroyed. The count does not say which oxygen atoms go where.

**Predict.** Suppose you could tag the oxygen atoms in the water a plant takes in. Would the oxygen gas the leaf gives off carry the tag?

> **Check your prediction.** Yes. In the standard account from atom-tagging experiments, the oxygen a leaf releases comes from split water. That seems impossible at first: 6 water molecules hold only 6 oxygen atoms, but 6 O2 need 12. The answer is that the full process splits 12 water molecules and makes 6 new ones, and the summary equation cancels those 6 out. Some tagged oxygen can also end up in sugar and in water, because oxygen atoms can swap places between molecules. So the equation cannot tell you where every oxygen atom goes. The safe map: the sugar’s carbon and much of its oxygen come from carbon dioxide, its hydrogen from water, and the released oxygen gas from split water.

*Figure (AI-generated illustration).* A soil loss of about 2 ounces cannot explain a gain of more than 160 pounds; the willow's dry matter was built mostly from carbon dioxide in the air. Image: a pot with a small willow stem on the left and the same pot years later with a tall willow tree on the right; arrows from the air and water lead to the tree.

Energy is conserved too: light energy is not used up or made, only transformed. **Chemical energy**, energy held in the arrangement of atoms, belongs to glucose and oxygen together, not to glucose alone; cellular respiration releases it as they rejoin into carbon dioxide and water.

**Predict.** A leaf stores only part of the light energy it absorbs as chemical energy. Energy is never destroyed. So where does the rest go?

> **Check your prediction.** Most of it leaves the leaf as heat; no energy vanishes. Of all the sunlight that falls on a leaf, the share stored as chemical energy is smaller still, because some light is never absorbed.

**Key idea for this section:**

The sugar’s carbon comes from carbon dioxide and its hydrogen from water, the oxygen gas released comes from split water, and light supplies energy, not atoms.

## Explain: where it happens and where the sugar goes

The first film showed the **chloroplast**, the green organelle where plants and algae photosynthesize; its stacked membranes hold **chlorophyll**, a pigment that absorbs mostly red and blue light. Carbon dioxide enters and oxygen leaves through **stomata**, tiny leaf pores. The film left out cells with no chloroplasts, and what a plant does with its sugar.

*Interactive on the lesson page:* Tap to enlarge lightcarbon dioxideglucoseoxygenwater lightblankblankblankwater Word bank: carbon dioxide, glucose, oxyge

A **prokaryote** is a cell with no nucleus and no chloroplasts or mitochondria, such as a bacterium. Cyanobacteria are prokaryotes that photosynthesize and release oxygen; in almost all of them, chlorophyll sits on folded membranes inside the cell instead of in chloroplasts.

A plant has three main uses for glucose:

- **Used right away.** Plant cells carry out **cellular respiration**, which breaks glucose down and releases its energy in a form cells can use, in light and dark. [Respiration and ATP](https://stemhop.com/lessons/respiration-and-atp/) follows that path.
- **Stored.** Glucose molecules are linked into **starch**, a long chain the plant stores in seeds, roots and leaves.
- **Rebuilt.** Linked a different way, glucose becomes **cellulose**, the fiber of cell walls and so of wood. Plants also rebuild glucose, with minerals from soil, into proteins, fats and DNA; the minerals supply elements sugar lacks, such as nitrogen. [What Am I Made Of?](https://stemhop.com/lessons/macromolecules/) covers those molecules.

*Figure (AI-generated illustration).* A plant uses its glucose three ways: it breaks some down right away in respiration, stores some as starch, and rebuilds some as cellulose for its cell walls. Image: a small plant with arrows from a glucose marker in a leaf to three places: a cell with a mitochondrion, a root packed with stored chains, and a plant cell wall made of fibres.

**Key idea:**

Chlorophyll in chloroplasts (or, in almost all cyanobacteria, on membranes inside the cell) captures light, and the glucose made is used in respiration, stored as starch, or rebuilt into cellulose and other molecules.

Your leaf-disk race showed that sugar-making has a speed limit; the second film finds what sets it.

**Film transcript: The Slowest Worker Sets the Pace**

### Film transcript: The Slowest Worker Sets the Pace

The first film showed what a plant builds its sugar from. This film asks how fast it can build. Why does more light stop speeding a leaf up? Here is a way to watch the rate. Punch small disks out of a spinach leaf. Pull the air out of them so they sink. Drop them into water with baking soda. Baking soda adds dissolved carbon dioxide. Now shine a lamp on the cup. As the disks photosynthesize, oxygen gas collects inside them. One by one, they float back up.

The sooner they float, the faster the rate. Move the lamp closer, step by step. Each time, the disks float sooner. Plot the rate against brightness, and the curve climbs. This cup has only a pinch of baking soda. Keep moving the lamp closer. Does the curve keep climbing? Make your guess.

It flattens. Brighter light now changes almost nothing. The disks are running short of carbon dioxide to build with. Carbon dioxide has become the slow worker, and the whole process waits for it. An input or condition that holds a process back is called a limiting factor. On the rising part of this curve, it was light. On the flat part, it is carbon dioxide. So add more baking soda. Now the curve climbs higher before it flattens again. Something else, such as temperature or enzyme speed, now sets a new ceiling. When a curve is flat, more of that factor barely changes the rate. Now leave the lab for the Chesapeake Bay. Underwater grasses grow on the bottom of its shallow water.

Most eelgrass lives in the lower Bay, where the water is saltier. Light has to pass down through the water to reach the grass. Mud and floating algae block it. So does material growing on the leaves themselves. For the saltier Bay, there is a habitat target. More than 22 percent of the light at the surface should reach the grass. When murky water cuts the light, light can become the limiting factor. In this cup, with the other conditions held fixed, carbon dioxide capped the rate. In the Bay, murky water can make light the limit. Real plants can face two limits at once. A flat curve means more of that factor is no longer helping much.

From the film

- A limiting factor is the input or condition that holds a process back.
- More light speeds photosynthesis only until another factor, such as carbon dioxide, becomes the limit.
- When the rate curve goes flat, adding more of that factor barely changes the rate.
- Murky water can make light the limiting factor for underwater grasses.
- One or more limiting factors cap how fast photosynthesis runs.

## Explain: what limits the rate

Three things the second film did not show change how you read your race.

**What you timed was net oxygen.** The disks’ own cells respire the whole time and use some of the oxygen. For otherwise matched disks, a shorter time to float means faster net oxygen build-up: what photosynthesis makes minus what respiration uses. It is evidence about the rate, not a direct measurement of it.

**Temperature is not an input.** Warmth adds no atoms to the sugar; it changes how fast **enzymes**, the proteins that speed up the reactions, can work.

**Predict.** Keep the lamp close and add plenty of baking soda. Now warm the cup step by step from cold to hot. Does the rate keep rising?

> **Check your prediction.** No. Warmth speeds the enzymes up at first. Too much heat slows photosynthesis, partly because key enzymes and the helper proteins that keep them working lose their shape. So the rate usually rises, peaks and then falls, unlike the light curve, which usually rises and levels off. [Enzymes at Work](https://stemhop.com/lessons/enzymes-at-work/) explains why.

**A real plant has limits the cup hides.** Water and mineral nutrients can limit photosynthesis too. A leaf short of water closes its stomata and takes in less carbon dioxide.

On the flat part of the light curve, the film’s slow worker might be carbon dioxide supply, temperature, or how fast enzymes attach carbon from carbon dioxide to other molecules. Unlike workers in a line, a plant’s factors affect each other and can limit together: heat, for example, changes how much water a leaf loses.

**Key idea:**

Light, carbon dioxide and temperature can each limit photosynthesis; when more of one stops raising the rate, a different factor is holding it back.

## Elaborate: underwater grass in the Chesapeake

The second film’s underwater grasses are what scientists call submerged aquatic vegetation (SAV). Every year the Virginia Institute of Marine Science (VIMS) maps the grass beds from the air.

| Survey year | Mapped underwater grass, Bay and tidal rivers (acres) | Coverage note from VIMS |
| --- | --- | --- |
| 2018 | 99,511 | Some tributary areas not fully mapped |
| 2019 | 66,684 | Much of the loss was widgeongrass |
| 2020 | 63,132 | Satellite images replaced aerial ones for the Anacostia and northernmost Potomac |
| 2021 | 68,025 | Weather kept parts of the Mattaponi and Pamunkey rivers from being imaged |
| 2022 | 77,425 | Satellite images filled in for murky rivers; part of the Potomac imaged by satellite only |
| 2023 | 79,716 | Upper Potomac imaged after the grass had peaked |

Source: VIMS annual SAV survey executive summaries, 2018 to 2023, for Chesapeake Bay and its tidal tributaries (all mapped beds, not a single station). For areas mapped in both 2018 and 2019, VIMS compared 98,828 acres with 62,334 acres, a 37% drop.

The light targets come from a Chesapeake Bay Program technical synthesis (2000) and apply to the growing season: more than 22% of surface light should reach the grass through the water in the saltier middle and lower Bay, and more than 13% in fresher upper reaches.

1. Which year had the smallest mapped area? By how many acres did the area grow from that year to 2023?
2. Why is it fairer to compare 2018 and 2019 using the matched areas than the two totals?
3. The table has no water-clarity numbers. What would you need to add before claiming that clearer water caused the increase after 2020?

Claim, evidence, reasoning

Make a claim that answers the essential question: where does a plant’s mass come from, and what limits how much it can build? Use the willow numbers and the Bay data.

Claim Your answer to the question, in one sentence.

Start with: A plant’s mass mostly comes from blank, and its growth can be limited by blank.

Evidence The data that support your claim.

Start with: The willow gained about blank while the soil lost only blank. Bay grasses need more than blank of surface light, and their mapped area changed from blank to blank.

Reasoning Why the evidence supports the claim, using the science.

Start with: Photosynthesis builds glucose from blank and blank using light energy, so if blank is in short supply, the plant blank.

> **Compare with a model answer.** A plant’s dry mass mostly comes from carbon dioxide in the air, and light can limit how much it builds. Van Helmont’s willow gained about 164 pounds while its soil lost about one-eighth of a pound, so soil cannot explain the gain. Photosynthesis builds glucose from carbon dioxide and water using light, and the plant turns glucose into wood. Bay habitat targets call for more than 13 percent (fresher water) or 22 percent (saltier water) of surface light to reach the grasses. Their mapped area rose from 63,132 acres in 2020 to 79,716 in 2023, though the areas imaged differed between years. One limit: van Helmont had one tree, weighed it alive rather than dried, and never weighed the air, and the Bay table has no clarity readings, so it cannot show cause.

Saved in this browser only.

## Evaluate: check your thinking

A plant is built mostly from air and water, powered by light, and paced by its limiting factor.

**Science practices you used:** testing predictions, planning a fair test with a control and repeated trials, reading a data table and its coverage notes, separating a pattern from a cause, and naming a model’s limits.

### Design problem

Plan a real leaf-disk experiment to test how light intensity affects the rate of photosynthesis. Name your variables, what you keep the same, your control, and how many trials you would run.

> **One way to do it.** - **Independent variable:** lamp distance, such as 10, 20, 30 and 40 cm.
> - **Dependent variable:** the time for 5 of 10 disks to float, in minutes.
> - **Constants:** same leaf type and disk size, same baking-soda amount, same volume of water, same starting water temperature, same lamp. An LED lamp or a clear water barrier cuts down the lamp’s heat; check the water temperature in each trial.
> - **Control:** one cup of disks kept in the dark. If those float too, something other than photosynthesis is lifting them.
> - **Trials:** three cups at each distance, and report the mean time.
> - **Safety:** keep cords and lamps away from water, and let hot bulbs cool before you touch them.
>
> If the time to float gets shorter as the lamp gets closer, then levels off, light was limiting at first and then something else became the limit.

## Going deeper

### How much of a plant is water?

Much of a living plant’s fresh mass is water, about 80 to 90 percent in soft leaves and stems. Drying a sample before weighing removes this water, so only solid material counts. Van Helmont weighed his willow alive, not dried, so part of its 164-pound gain was water.

### How good was van Helmont’s soil weighing?

In the 1600s, van Helmont planted a 5-pound willow stem in a pot of 200 pounds of dried soil; five years later he reported a tree of about 169 pounds, and the soil was only about 2 ounces lighter. Too rough to measure the minerals the tree took up: rainwater carried minerals in, fallen leaves were never weighed, and dried soil is hard to weigh to the ounce. The conclusion stands, since even a missed pound or two is tiny next to 164 pounds.

---

From STEMhop (https://stemhop.com), free lessons by Christopher Deppmann. Lesson text © the authors. Practice questions: https://stemhop.com/lessons/photosynthesis-energy-capture/
